So where I do i start?
@LLD
- Day 1 ended at: Mon Jun 27, 2011 3:41 am
- Deadline is Tuesday, June 28 at 3pm PST (6pm EST)
- Total number of posts on site in this period: 120+
How better play from you could have influenced the game in town's favor
- Caught Kast on D2 (Because he roleblocked Kdub that night - you would have known that you not getting two actions + Kast on Kdub = Kast roleblocker)
- You obviously wouldn't have gotten lynched
Next time stop
blaming the mod because he stuck to deadline rules and get your action in on time. (Expecting a mod to
remind you for a night action is bad)
@Fate
Reads were good + the alliance we formed early on D1 was all town {Amrun,Robo,You,Me,Iece} - I needed to mislynch you because I knew you had a "secret scumread" on me. (Part of the reason I choose not to kill N3 along with number-endgame analysis).
But you had a Redirect - which IMO is the most powerful town ability there is (slightly lower than a Vig or CPR doc). Kast, Me, Sath were you scum reads. Trying to redirect one onto the other would have been the best move. Redirecting Iece to the same person he said he would target achieved no purpose except to get you lynched.
I think both the wasted watch and the wasted redirect went a long way in the town losing.
@ABR
- Could have been a bit more useful in the game. Plus you should have checked B&B1 before joining since flavor\theme of the game - instead of generally bitching about it in thread and not doing much. If you did check B&B1, you would have known that your message power had the use of confirming you didn't use any other ability that night (like Roleblocking)
Should have replaced out early if it irritated you so much.
@Iecerint
- Surprised that you thought I -ABR were a scum pairing - especially just coming after "Battle of Olympus". (where I hard-defended both Chess and gandalf as town). I never defend my scumbuddies as scum - and like I said - bussing ABR is the better play at that point in time. The bolded part in
this post was as close as I could come to a SK claim without giving up the chance to win. I was right about the fact that your night action would be nerfed or not that useful - Especially since LLD had a two shot Watch\Track. Overall, think you stuck to your flavor-analysis too much and didn't actually see what I was trying to tell you. For example - you should have definitely seen that Sathoris spent most of his posts SK hunting so he wasn't the SK.
I think the rest of the town was fine. I'm sorry @SpyreX for killing you but I had a gameplan as an SK which revolved around not getting crosskilled beyond N1 (since I was NK immune only for N1)
- Gambit on D1
- Massroleblock N2
- Claim Mass roleblocker + Bulletproof on D2
The Gambit would strengthen the ooba=Townie part of it meaning I wouldn't get lynched. The Bulletproof claim would mean scum would not crosskill me. SpyreX with an early vote on me threatened to disrupt those plans, so killed him.
A bit less RC bitching and more playing would have made for a better game - but overall, I think the playlist was good & would play again with you guys.
@RC
- Personally would have removed the "Beloved Princess" part of Kast's role and just made him a scum JoAT.
- I do think the game was too confusing in night actions. Stuff like the relfexive part of Robo's role and Fate's busdrive could have been omitted (B&B1 had a better mix of actions)
- I'm also surprised at the following line in the QT - "Sathoris is under the impression that you submitted a kill, Kast." - I mean you were strict with LLD on submitting the action choice by PM within the deadline & you didn't remind her too. If each Mafia-ite thought the other was submitting the kill, it points to a lack of coordination on their part and hence, no Mafia kill should have occurred. Would have lead to a Iece-Sath-Me endgame. Would have given either me or town a good chance to win - since we would have no lynched and Sathoris would decide who would have won by killing one of me or Iece. I prefer consistent molding across a game.
) Iec was saddled with a nigh insane cop that investigated ALL of the mafia as townies and one townie (plus any framed town) as scum.