Mini 269 - Game Over

[warpdragon]

BJ, was that many posts necessary?

Anyway, I'm the town vandal. I can write a message of up to 10 words to be posted in the opening post of the day. Warpdragon is spelt out in the second letter of each word of the message for day 2. (sWarms rAn, dRank, sPun aDditional oRange aArdvark's eGgs've nOrthern oNtario) I have to say, though, that I have no idea why I chose those words.

[BabyJesus]

But GC isn't a cop, he's a "notary republic". There isn't really any reason he'd have a gun.

true...

[BabyJesus]

BJ, was that many posts necessary?

yes

[BabyJesus]

vote shamrock

If he's clean we obviously kill GC tomorrow.

[Shamrock]

Just to make 100% sure I've PMed the mod to confirm that GC does actually have a gun.

[Shamrock]

And , while I'm not the lynch, if I do get lynched + turn up gunsmith, lynch GC for me, kay?

[BabyJesus]

And , while I'm not the lynch, if I do get lynched + turn up gunsmith, lynch GC for me, kay?

obviously...

[Matjoeman]

How are we doing

Vote Count

wise?

[Poirot]

Okay, if GC was right about mjm, here's where the two (other) cops stand:

I'm a Gunsmith. My investigations were:
N1 - Falcone - Gun
N2 - BJ - No Gun
N3 - GC - Gun

My question is thus: did we know that BJ was the double-voter on Day 2 or 3?

This seems fairly stock. I don't understand why he didn't counterattack Falcone's claim as the Martyr...because the Martyr doesn't seem like they'd have a gun, vigilante role or not. So why didn't he? Maybe because this is purely fabricated?

Unlike Poirot, I've been given the ability to use my role every night, including on Night One. I've investigated Poirot, matjoeman and Shamrock in that order, starting on Night One. Vote: Shamrock. I was given his name as mafia.

Okay...we know he got Town, Town, Mafia. Again, fairly stock...except that he knew that mjm was the doctor. And he was right.

So one of two things are the case:
1) GC is a lying mafia investigator.

2) Shamrock is a lying mafia member, and GC is the Cop.

Anyways, does it matter who we lynch? As long as we lynch one of these two, we know who the scum is. We can afford a death to catch the last mafia.

BJ, we need to choose someone. Right now, I'll

Vote Shamrock

. We need to lynch someone.

[BabyJesus]

Okay, if GC was right about mjm, here's where the two (other) cops stand:

I'm a Gunsmith. My investigations were:
N1 - Falcone - Gun
N2 - BJ - No Gun
N3 - GC - Gun

My question is thus: did we know that BJ was the double-voter on Day 2 or 3?.

This is an excellent point.....while it "should" have been obvious day one, day two was when we had the big discussion about it and everyone knew I was a double voter....

I think I'm happy voting Shamrock first now 8)

[Shamrock]

We found out that BJ was the double voter on day 2 (we could have known by looking at the vote count at the end of day 1 but I didn't notice that until it was pointed out).

As for Falcone, I believed he'd have a gun because "martyr" doesn't necessarily imply using a certain weapon, and it's also probably reasonable to assume that any killing role would have a gun.

[Shamrock]

Night 2 was after Day 2, and Day 2 is when we had the discussion. Silly people.

[BabyJesus]

We found out that BJ was the double voter on day 2 (we could have known by looking at the vote count at the end of day 1 but I didn't notice that until it was pointed out).

As for Falcone, I believed he'd have a gun because "martyr" doesn't necessarily imply using a certain weapon, and it's also probably reasonable to assume that any killing role would have a gun.

so why did you investigate if I had a gun then?

[BabyJesus]

Night 2 was after Day 2, and Day 2 is when we had the discussion. Silly people.

umm...

[Shamrock]

I investigated BJ because a double-voting scum was too terrible a possibility to leave uncovered.

[BabyJesus]

I investigated BJ because a double-voting scum was too terrible a possibility to leave uncovered.

weak. If true, there are a ton of unknowns to be looking at, rather then someone practically cleared.

Regardless, lets end this. If you are telling the truth, we'll lynch GC tomorrow. Either way I think we have this game won.

[Shamrock]

Yeah, it was probably pretty stupid in retrospect.

[Poirot]

Right. If we're wrong, we lose a townie, plus another townie at night. There are still three townies alive in the morning, and we know who they all are.

[BabyJesus]

is shamrock dead? can we get a vote count??

[Poirot]

Does your vote count double today, BJ?

[BabyJesus]

Does your vote count double today, BJ?

I've left it at single for better accountability of votes...although if we don;t get much movement, I may just bump it up. I'd rather we decide equally whch to lynch...

[Poirot]

For simplicity, let's just go with who we're both voting for. Like I said, it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things. But do what you want. I just want this day to end with a lynch on one of them.

[warpdragon]

I can go with the whole Shamrock today/GC tomorrow plan.

Vote Shamrock

[halo freak]

Vote Count

1 Green Crayons - Shamrock

4Shamrock - Green Crayons, Matjoeman, Baby J Poriot

So Shamrock is lynched he was a Gunsmith

All choices by the 20th please, PM me

before

the deadline if you need longer

[halo freak]

Day Breaks

You find Baby J's body sprawled on the ground.
Baby J - Double Voter (killed night 4)

It is now day 4 with 4 alive it will take 3 votes to lynch.