Brightest Day Mafia, Part 1 - GAME OVER

[inHimshallibe]

@Toast: Kept it there as a continuing means of observation.


Jeebus people, when talking about game-related info, think first. I know I know, lolfirstpostclaim from me too, but that's a function of Miller play, not a function of getting excited over a theme game. :igmeou:

[inHimshallibe]

vote: Toogeloo

More for what Toast pointed out and less of LLD's "scum trying to get a mislynch" (well, duh.)

[MagnaofIllusion]

Magna and I are discussing things in the QT currently but we want one thing clear –

Everyone playing the “White Lanterns are Anti-Cult, Scum are confirmed Red / Yellow Lanterns” flavor outguessing are doing it wrong.

The categories each have the ability (aside from Black Lanterns, who are more or less Mod confirmed as the Cult) to be placed in any sort of role.

Non-Lanterns – Can draw from traditional Super-heroes or Villans to fill out the Town / Mafia as needed.

Colored Lanterns – Obvious.

White / Black Lanterns – The White Lanterns do have some questionable characters (Maxwell Lord being the highest profile) that can be used in either fashion as necessary.

So until we have flips or have Cop claim that gives flavor Mod responses that restrict Mafia to a set group nothing about the make-up should be assumed. I’d expect a Mafia team mix (some Red / Yellow Lanterns, some other Villans, maybe a White Lantern)

We chose, in order,

Non-Lantern
Colored Lantern
White / Black Lantern

If someone could make a list of claims that would be fantastic.

Vezok – please confirm the following fact – your character is a female dressed in white named Freezer and you haven't screwed up reading in giving us this.

- AlmasterGM

[FrozenMirror]

Magna and I are discussing things in the QT currently but we want one thing clear –

Everyone playing the “White Lanterns are Anti-Cult, Scum are confirmed Red / Yellow Lanterns” flavor outguessing are doing it wrong.

The categories each have the ability (aside from Black Lanterns, who are more or less Mod confirmed as the Cult) to be placed in any sort of role.

Non-Lanterns – Can draw from traditional Super-heroes or Villans to fill out the Town / Mafia as needed.

Colored Lanterns – Obvious.

White / Black Lanterns – The White Lanterns do have some questionable characters (Maxwell Lord being the highest profile) that can be used in either fashion as necessary.

So until we have flips or have Cop claim that gives flavor Mod responses that restrict Mafia to a set group nothing about the make-up should be assumed. I’d expect a Mafia team mix (some Red / Yellow Lanterns, some other Villans, maybe a White Lantern)

We chose, in order,

Non-Lantern
Colored Lantern
White / Black Lantern

If someone could make a list of claims that would be fantastic.

Vezok – please confirm the following fact – your character is a female dressed in white named Freezer and you haven't screwed up reading in giving us this.

- AlmasterGM

God damn it stupid Hydras ...

Sorry I ruined the "gambit" AGM.

[Mr Subliminal]

- AlmasterGM

ALT DETECTED?!
Oh, it was just a very unethical and cheap hydra gambit, got it.

[Nikanor]

lolMoI.

Implying one of them is lying. I lean Nikanor actually. Though I'm not sure what their reason for lying could be.

It's possible that I'm a white lantern, but I doubt it. tans could be lying I guess, but I don't know why he'd do that.

[Toogeloo]

Hm. Main problem I have with Toog atm is the post in which he votes LLD. If he didn’t like what I said about vezok and kondi, why is he content with using a random vote instead of someone he has infor on?

I didn't like it because I see people bash or use vezok as a scapegoat all the time. You called yourself less idiotic than them, like it should be taken for fact, which is what I didn't like. I didn't vote you for it because you already had a wagon and I wasn't sure if we needed extra votes on wagons that I wasn't even sure were serious in the first place. I also Town Hunt on Day 1. I don't get aggressive and vote around. That's just how my playstyle is.

BTW,

Vote: Toog

This is scum looking for a mislynch.

Nice OMGUS considering I thought it was fairly common knowledge that my vote was done in jest. I even laughed about it pre-game. A little sensitive about a vote on you?

Nice excuse, scum.

A page 6 vote is "in jest"? I don't think so. You had PLENTY go on in content and wagons. A jest vote had NO PLACE in this game. This is merely your excuse to try and avoid the pressure. Sorry, you're not dodging this.

BTW, OMGUS is a buzzword used by scum to get reactions and help push a wagon.

Tell me Toog, if the vote was in Jest, who are your scum/town reads?

@Town: There needs to be more votes on Toog. He's scum.

How does one

NOT

get over-defensive after a post like this? LLD came out swinging for the fences and I had to shoot down each in turn.

E4.

Vote: Toogeloo.

I went back looking for your case on me since apparently I need to start figuring out why people hate me, and this is all I saw. What exactly is E4?

[Oversoul]

Ok, Dana sent me Kublai's choices.

Kublai Khan's UPick choices were:
Non-lantern
Black/White Lantern
Colored Lantern

I got non-lantern

[ToastyToast]

You called yourself less idiotic than them, like it should be taken for fact, which is what I didn't like.

Welll, I do think it should be taken for fact, so....Thats like saying chesskid isn't a troll. I have never been the target of a policy lynch.
I do apologize for saying that (vezok and kondi), I got frustrated for being called an idiot.

Also, didn't realize ppl were doing this, so.
In addition to my choices, I got what I wanted (colored lantern)

[vezokpiraka]

Magna and I are discussing things in the QT currently but we want one thing clear –

Everyone playing the “White Lanterns are Anti-Cult, Scum are confirmed Red / Yellow Lanterns” flavor outguessing are doing it wrong.

The categories each have the ability (aside from Black Lanterns, who are more or less Mod confirmed as the Cult) to be placed in any sort of role.

Non-Lanterns – Can draw from traditional Super-heroes or Villans to fill out the Town / Mafia as needed.

Colored Lanterns – Obvious.

White / Black Lanterns – The White Lanterns do have some questionable characters (Maxwell Lord being the highest profile) that can be used in either fashion as necessary.

So until we have flips or have Cop claim that gives flavor Mod responses that restrict Mafia to a set group nothing about the make-up should be assumed. I’d expect a Mafia team mix (some Red / Yellow Lanterns, some other Villans, maybe a White Lantern)

We chose, in order,

Non-Lantern
Colored Lantern
White / Black Lantern

If someone could make a list of claims that would be fantastic.

Vezok – please confirm the following fact – your character is a female dressed in white named Freezer and you haven't screwed up reading in giving us this.

- AlmasterGM

Yep that's right.
She has big boobs and has white hair. She does have some light blue on the gloves though.

[Nikanor]

@Toog:
E4 is a chess move.
I voted you for your reaction to LLD's "goon-slip". Not your vote, but your first post. Looking at it in iso, the transition between your first and second posts looks really insincere.
Why do you not have a serious vote down yet?

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Toog, you're acting awful serious for a vote that is "in jest".

I think by this point we can say that the "Joke Vote" defense is bullshit.

So tell me Toog, am I scum?

Cut by Vezok being creepy and Nikanor echoing me (or me echoing him, whatever).

[FrozenMirror]

It's possible that I'm a white lantern, but I doubt it. tans could be lying I guess, but I don't know why he'd do that.

Go to Wikipedia and look up “White Lantern Corps” under the “Members” and “Labors of the Twelve” sections look to see if your character is listed. Report back with a simple Yes or No.

Yep that's right.
She has big boobs and has white hair. She does have some light blue on the gloves though.

And you are absolutely certain you aren’t actually Killer Frost instead?

[inHimshallibe]

Toog, you're acting awful serious for a vote that is "in jest".

I think by this point we can say that the "Joke Vote" defense is bullshit.

So tell me Toog, am I scum?

Cut by Vezok being creepy and Nikanor echoing me (or me echoing him, whatever).

I don't agree with this.


Actually, considering I DO think it was a joke vote...

unvote
vote: Andrius

[WeyounsLastClone]

Is it common practice with Upick to post your choices? (this is my first UPick)
My choices:
Preference:
1) No Lantern
2) Colored Lantern
3) Black/White

[Toogeloo]

@Toog:
E4 is a chess move.
I voted you for your reaction to LLD's "goon-slip". Not your vote, but your first post. Looking at it in iso, the transition between your first and second posts looks really insincere.
Why do you not have a serious vote down yet?

I'm not going to vote for Andrius or Toast right now. Neither wagon came off as serious the first time I looked at them. Toast's latest series of posts look townish enough that I don't even know why he has votes anymore. LLD's overreaction to my vote hasn't really given me a reason to remove it either. No one else is really standing out atm. Aside from that, I don't typically move my vote around much. As I said in my previous post, I town hunt more on Day 1. I don't vote just because people pressure me to do so.


PEDIT: LLD, did you seriously look at that post and think to yourself I was trying to get you mislynched? I didn't even present much of an argument in favor of your lynching. I really didn't think you would get as bent out of shape about it as you did considering the way I phrased it and everything . It's like when I try to make a joke at my wife when she is PMSing and she detonates on me that I am an insensitive prick or something.

[inHimshallibe]

Subliminal and mastin are town btw.

[Nikanor]

Go to Wikipedia and look up “White Lantern Corps” under the “Members” and “Labors of the Twelve” sections look to see if your character is listed. Report back with a simple Yes or No.

Oh.
Yes.

[ooba]

Let's get one thing straight
- Black lantern(s) are mod-confirmed to be cult (Dueling cults is fun to speculate on but barring new info, I'll just assume it's one cult)
- Really shouldn't matter who the scum team is right now
- "Lynch scum for the first lynch; lynch cult for second lynch" is funny. Cult's obviously the growing threat and trust me - we are going to have a hard time lynching CR even if two lynches are spent on the cause.

Also, finally, Andrius is not cult - so your votes are better used elsewhere.

I'll whittle down the rest of the list for possible CRs and come up with a lynch list - expect a post on this in

(expired on 2011-07-31 15:59:59)

[hiplop]

It's possible that I'm a white lantern, but I doubt it. tans could be lying I guess, but I don't know why he'd do that.

Go to Wikipedia and look up “White Lantern Corps” under the “Members” and “Labors of the Twelve” sections look to see if your character is listed. Report back with a simple Yes or No.

Yep that's right.
She has big boobs and has white hair. She does have some light blue on the gloves though.

And you are absolutely certain you aren’t actually Killer Frost instead?

thats gotta be who he means, exactly what she looks like too...

add in my case, and hes fucking scum

[FrozenMirror]

add in my case, and hes fucking scum

Expect a response after Vezok responds to our latest post ...

[Mr Subliminal]

It's possible that I'm a white lantern, but I doubt it. tans could be lying I guess, but I don't know why he'd do that.

Go to Wikipedia and look up “White Lantern Corps” under the “Members” and “Labors of the Twelve” sections look to see if your character is listed. Report back with a simple Yes or No.

rolefishrolefishrolefish

[zMuffinMan]

Skimmed so far, choices were 3>1>2, catching up properly after some sleep.

[Oversoul]

- FrozenMirror

Non-Lantern
Colored Lantern
White / Black Lantern

- nopointinactingup


- Kast


- Andrius

I guess I'll start.
I sent in Colored Lantern, then Non-Lantern, then B/W Lantern.
Faraday sent in Non-Lantern, then Colored Lantern, then B/W Lantern.
I'm not sure what the mods took as legit, since neither of them went in through Callandor.

- Toogeloo


- Candle Jack

SnakePlissken chose Nonlantern/Colored/White or Black when sending in Lantern choices (pity, I'd have preferred the exact opposite order, I wanted possible White Lantern anti-Cult powers and I'd rather start Cult than be recruited anyways). Wound up colored lantern so...

- WeyounsLastClone

My choices:
Preference:
1) No Lantern
2) Colored Lantern
3) Black/White

- marco1610


- hiplop

I sent in: Coloured
White/Black
Non-Lantern

- Mr. Subliminal


- GhostWriter


- ToastyToast

My choices were:
Colored
black/white
non-lantern

- vezokpiraka

WTF?

I picked 1)non latern
2)Colored lantern
3) Black/white lantern and I got a white lantern????

- ooba

1) White\Black lantern
2) Colored lantern
3) Non-Lantern
were my choices.

- tanstalas

1)Non-lantern
2)Colored lantern
3)black/white

I got colored lantern.

- Bogre


- Nikanor

I picked:
Black/White
Coloured
Non-lantern

- Apokalyptika

The person I replaced picked
-Colored lantern
-Black/white lantern
-Non-lantern

- zMuffinMan

Skimmed so far, choices were 3>1>2, catching up properly after some sleep.

- Mastin2

Non-lantern
Colored
Black/White

In that order.

- Lady Lambdadelta


- kondi2424


- inHimshalibe

I've never done this before, but it's right.

Claiming Miller

Greatpostan about Andy's FOS and no vote.

Nikanor and Mastin are town. Secret townlean as well, will reveal after a while.

vote: Andrius

Guy Gardner.

- Oversoul

Kublai Khan's UPick choices were:
Non-lantern
Black/White Lantern
Colored Lantern

I got non-lantern

Someone (I think Magna?) asked for a list, but I don't know how useful it will be.


Anyways Nika, I don't like you overassuming that you know vezok. I hate it when people bring meta into games. Meta is the worst reason for or against someone.

All in all, we have alot of inactive players in order for this list of Lantern choices to be completed. :\

[Mr Subliminal]

Meta is useful when applied properly. But it's rarely applied properly.