ASOIAF: Test of Faith Mafia (Game Over!)

[CyberSet]

CES is win.

I don't even mind that he called me mafia, I'm just happy he sees the Espeonage guilt.

If he does flip CR I'm going to be even more annoyed he wasn't killed d1 like he should've been.

[ooba]

Vote Count

Benmage (5)

- Empking, SpyreX, vezokpiraka, Bogre, Espeonage

Lost Butterfly (1)

- Thor665

vezokpiraka (1)

- Benmage

Espeonage (4)

- CyberSet, Cogito Ergo Sum, Lost Butterfly, Hinduragi

Not Voting (3)

- Magua, AlmasterGM, Nexus

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

[LimMePls]

I'm massively behind in this game folks and I don't see any way to catchup. I'm really sorry, but I'm going to have to replace out.

@Mod: Please replace me. And sorry for the inconvenience. Life has just gotten super busy the past 3 or 4 weeks

[Thor665]

Unvote LB
Vote: Espeonage

I still want Espe's read of Cyberset though.
Plus, we need a tiw with the Benwagon, since he's obv. scum and I want to push this counterwagon through

[Benmage]

unvote vote espeonage

Should've kept buddying.

L-2 lets hear a claim.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Woo.

[Faraday]

Hey, CES, if I told you Espe prefers scum would it strengthen your read?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Yarr.

[Faraday]

Yarr!

[AlmasterGM]

YARR is how I feel about this espeonage wagon. I'd CHOO CHOO but the train is lookin a little full so I'll wait till we've heard a fakeclaim and hop on when its time for ALL ABOARD FOR LYNCH CITY

[Lost Butterfly]

[Lost Butterfly]

Just actually re-read Espeonage in ISO.

He slipped quite a while ago, I think. CLAIM or die.

[CyberSet]

Amazing how willing people suddenly are to get on this wagon today with only the lightest of pushes to get the ball rolling. Gratifying, but amazing.

[Lost Butterfly]

You should have quoted a super long wall post before this to draw my attention to the fact he was scum, you can't blame me for not reading this thread. i've too much CHARISMA wasting my time on that.

[Lost Butterfly]

also any sort of killing role should kill vezok tonight for the love of god.

[Thor665]

Amazing how willing people suddenly are to get on this wagon today with only the lightest of pushes to get the ball rolling. Gratifying, but amazing.

Welcome to Benmage today too. People are all insane...or cult

[Empking]

Amazing how willing people suddenly are to get on this wagon today with only the lightest of pushes to get the ball rolling. Gratifying, but amazing.

Welcome to Benmage today too.

Yes because lying is only the lightest of pushes.

[Thor665]

@Empking - flat out, what alignment do you think Benmage is and why should we lynch him today? (feel free to leave out 'lying' as a reason, he admitted to the lying so we all know that happened)

[Empking]

@Empking - flat out, what alignment do you think Benmage is and why should we lynch him today? (feel free to leave out 'lying' as a reason, he admitted to the lying so we all know that happened)

1. Scum and an important one at that.
2. Trying to out power roles.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Is Empking normally this bad at scum?

[Faraday]

Is Empking normally this bad at scum?

He's town. Cult recruit at worst.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Oh, I agree he looked town early on. Recruit is exactly what I'm thinking.

[SpyreX]

This game is giving me a migraine.

Esp needs to die so that isn't bad.

That doesn't change one whit that Benmage is with almost pure raw gold certainty, scum - and this move makes more sense from cult-scum than scum-scum (the ONLY thing pointing to scum-scum would be trying to out the scum-cop).

So, dearest scum:

If Esp is NOT cult I absolutely implore you to shoot benmage in the face.

[Magua]

Jesus christ, you people.

magua would have obviously voted you, he hates ya. that's 6, I can get 2 more, Locke Lamora and LMP in all likelyhood if AGM doesn't play ball.

No. There was no way that Benmage's claim was a scum-motivated 1-for-1. I was ready, willing, and able to vote you until I got to his retraction, and still feel itchy in that direction. I don't think you're mafia because of your words on the night-kills, but I could see LB-cult-mad-that-they're-caught-for-the-wrong-reasons. Mina's lack of posting figures heavily into this.

The one thing holding me back on this is your reversal to "Benmage may be insane cop," but even that doesn't mollify things all the way. See "tracking Sottyrulez in Metamafia" for example.

Benmage telling mafia to shoot me because I'm the likely cult recruiter is lulz.

SpyreX is still bugging me. Yes, he's got this claim, which, yes, I do believe at this point, which is why there's no vote, but the thing is this: SpyreX has been wrong on every single thing so far this game. Every single one. And not just a little wrong, but unrepentantly wrong. I twitch about his early claim with almost zero pressure. I twitch every time I read his posts. Like the one above.

So who does that leave for cult?

Can't be Bogre. Can't be Thor.

I'm buying it as unlikely that it's SpyreX, mostly due to the claim at this point in time, as indicated above.

I *heavily* believe that Hinduragi is recruited, due to the hasdgfas-hammer-silliness that was D3. I *do not* believe that Hinduragi is a recruiter of any sort, because his role in that was just too obvious -- willing to sacrifice himself to get hasdgfas lynched does not fit the CR methodology.

Leaves:
4. vezokpiraka - Pretty sure vezok is scum, though due to the little content, not sure about scum buddies.
6. CyberSet
7. Lost Butterfly
9. Empking
11. Nexus - Nexus being a recruiter means I would have to admit I was wrong on a D1 read, and I would prefer death. Recent posts have given me the feeling that he's recruited, but I maintain not a recruiter, and not scum at all.
12. Cogito Ergo Sum
17. Benmage - Can't see Benmage-scum at all. Can't see Benmage-recruiter. Could see Benmage-culted, but the motive there would be to push a lynch on someone the cult failed to recruit (and so likely mafia) to remove the opposing faction; Benmage's retraction negates that. Probably town at this point.
19. Espeonage
20. AlmasterGM - Likely not cult recruiter nor scum due to D1/D2 interactions. Recruited at the worst.

Leaves CyberSet, Lost Butterfly (hai Faraday), Empking, CES, and Espeonage as the people who I suspect may be recruiters.

So I'm all on board to VOTE: Espeonage

[Hinduragi]

Faraday would've recruited me so I doubt he's CR. Plus I was sheeping him onto the hammer, not sacrificing myself or whatever shenanigans are being spouted there.