Lemming Mafia - Mini 1196

[Tazaro]

Okay, yours is not a woman.

[CryMeARiver]

Don't have time to read past 3 pages.

Choose: Payoff

[Tazaro]

Oh hey. I'll read up in a second, but for now:

Chose: Shooter

Interesting pick; I don't know if farside is intentionally making a limited number of these words seem like they are obvious.

[CryMeARiver]

Oh hey. I'll read up in a second, but for now:

Chose: Shooter

Interesting pick; I don't know if farside is intentionally making a limited number of these words seem like they are obvious.

Like Concrete Mixer + Concrete or whatever it is -__-

[Jedo the Jedi]

My first two choices actually survived until the last three people.

Choose: Cliff Diving

[farside22]

This game is not based on Lemming the video game.

Mission Cards:

Lemming Pledge
Concrete Mixer
Jack hammer
Cement

Order of picking:

forest_air (can pick at any time)
Quilford (picking)
PeregrineV
me=weird
TOGTFO (picked Creatures)
Chuji Kunisada (picked Bookie)
mikemike778 (picked Limo)
Tazaro (Pier)
sAbLLimINal (picked Fedora)
animorpherv1 (picked shooter)
CryMeARiver (picked Payoff)
Jedo the Jedi (picked Cliff Diving)

Vote Count:

forest_air (2) Quilford, me=weird
Tazaro (3) forest_air, sAbLLimINal, animorpherv1
Me=Weird (1) TOGTFO
Peregrine (2) Chuji Kunisada, Jedo the Jedi
animorpherv1 (2): Tazaro, mikemike778
mikemike (1) CryMeARiver,
cmar (1) PeregrineV

Not voting:

No one.

With 12 players it takes 7 to lynch
Deadline is July 14th, 1:15pm PST

QUilford

has 48 hours to pick a mission

Forest_air

can pick a mission at anytime.

[Quilford]

Jack hammer

, please.

I promise I'm rereading.

[farside22]

PeregrineV

has 48 hours to pick a missionForest_air can pick a mission at anytime.

[Quilford]

Forest_air

has siteflaked, by the way.

I'm way ahead of you and already put in a request for a replacement.

[Jedo the Jedi]

I was belligerent by saying please?

No. It was by not just answering the questions to which you knew I was referring.

Just to clear it up here, if I knew what questions you were referring to, I would have answered them. Since I did not, and you offered to repeat them, I asked you to. Sorry if you feel like I was purposefully obtuse.

I'll concede the point, but I have trouble believing you couldn't remember (or look up) the very questions

you

asked.

That second part is poor. Trying to reverse that statement on me is ineffective because, of anybody, I know what you are doing and believe it to be neutral as far as scumminess (though not helpful to the town when we want to analyze vote patterns later). You could have answered that first question more descriptively than by giving a black-and-white answer.

What are the merits of the cases?

Surely they aren't just 100% fallacious/subjective/wrong.

You don't think so? If I said every game I played in scum had 3 syllables in their name and voted someone for that reason, that would be a good argument? What if I posted links to 5 games in which it was true, would that be a good argument?
I will read opinion cases and even consider what is said, but don't expect me to take them seriously.

This response is perplexing. First, you still haven't deigned to respond outside of black-and-white. Generally speaking, things are not 100% good or 100% bad. Often there is a good point or two in a bad case, or vice versa. If you are being properly critical, you're likely to find that. I don't understand what those examples of yours signify.

Also, I'm not sure they have all been opinion cases. (Taz's almost definitely, but not the others.) Beside that, what would you take seriously? Most of this game is drawing inferences and interpreting people's responses. That lends itself to being based on opinion. In fact, the very reason we will have multiple lynch candidates is because people see different things and disagree on what is truly scummy. So, I'm not exactly sure what you are looking for in a case other than some night results, but that's not likely to happen any time soon. Considering all this, I do expect you to take the cases seriously, to be critical of them to sift out the trash from the gold, and to discuss their merit with the rest of the town.

Anyway, a few of Peregrine's recent responses have caused me to consider him less scummy. I'll

unvote

for now.

[PeregrineV]

Unvote.

Woohoo!! I got!!

I pick

Lemming Pledge

!!

Back for more fun after I do crappy work stuff.

[Tazaro]

I pick

Lemming Pledge

!!

Are you right now looking at this pick and regretting it? If you think about it, it seems to be a mission that just keeps you at your lemming home.

[PeregrineV]

@Taz- I didn't think about that. There is no way I'm going to figure out a mission role from a name. Maybe after the first rounds go through and we hear some examples, then maybe.
But, I like puns.
C'mon...Lemming Pledge!!!

[farside22]

This game is not based on Lemming the video game.

Mission Cards:

Concrete Mixer
Cement

Order of picking:

forest_air (can pick at any time)
me=weird
TOGTFO (picked Creatures)
Chuji Kunisada (picked Bookie)
mikemike778 (picked Limo)
Tazaro (Picked Pier)
sAbLLimINal (picked Fedora)
animorpherv1 (picked shooter)
CryMeARiver (picked Payoff)
Jedo the Jedi (picked Cliff Diving)
Quilford (Picked JackHammer)
PeregrineV (Lemming Pledge)

Vote Count:

forest_air (2) Quilford, me=weird
Tazaro (3) forest_air, sAbLLimINal, animorpherv1
Me=Weird (1) TOGTFO
Peregrine (2) Chuji Kunisada, Jedo the Jedi
animorpherv1 (2): Tazaro, mikemike778
mikemike (1) CryMeARiver,

Not voting:

PeregrineV

With 12 players it takes 7 to lynch
Deadline is July 14th, 1:15pm PST

MeWeird

has 48 hours to pick a mission

Forest_air

can pick a mission at anytime.

[TOGTFO]

@M=W- How would you think is the best way as scum to stay involved but not become really noticed. I.E> Dont lurk but dont become the center of attention.

[Tazaro]

M=W is a lurker. Also, he has only seven posts in this game to be specific. You've been here since 3/30/11; M=W was in the first game I was in and another. He's a lurker, perhaps because of business, if you remember his reasoning for coming back later to make a decision in "Help my computer got infected...," or whatever, mafia.

[Tazaro]

I've been here longer than 2011, with some M=W experience, so I really just you make a more useful vote than a lurker vote that you made.

[Tazaro]

*really just urge that you...

[Tazaro]

^Above stuff was @TOGTFO.

[mikemike778]

This game is not based on Lemming the video game.

Thats why I signed up what is it based on then ?

[mikemike778]

Don't have time to read past 3 pages.

Choose: Payoff

You probably missed people asking why you voted me then for no apparent reason. Or chose not to answer it. Anyways Ani looks scum to me so my vote is staying there.

[Tazaro]

I demand forest_air's replacement to get rid of forest_air's RVS vote.

UNVOTE

VOTE :forest_air

Seriously, I have two dead votes on me. And I'm going to look into sAb for choosing to be with those two.

[Tazaro]

Yes, I'm making a deal with the replacement. Scratch my back, then I'll take the itchy cloth off of yours.

[Tazaro]

I mean, Geesus, I do something bad in another game and talk too much around the noobie, when a good game starts, who gets motivated to RVS me as a result. I can't believe how I'm unfairly the top wagon for this shit.

[Tazaro]

And yes, the fact that sAb hasn't unvoted me is a choice, a fairly convenient one, too, if he's scum. Yes, I overreact, now vote for someone for which that's a tell!