1a) Excessive game theory posting
2) Weird wishy-washy, unnatural sounding interaction with Crazy
3) Lots of defending of various players while coming to no ultimate conclusions about anyone else
4) Overall profile of an inexperienced, nervous, overly-self-conscious player
4a) This is in direct contradiction with my "experience" (from the dead QT) of him in my Newbie game where he was a very strong and active scum hunter. I suspect he is nervous scum and doesn't play as scum well.