I really don't think is scummy. The case against him not asking Andrew for his opinion on a vote was validated here
neil1113 wrote:TheLonging wrote:I don't care if andrew was literally the smartest person on Earth or the dumbest, I'd still want an explanation. Same with shotty. To excuse him like that is just bad and, quite frankly, scummy.
I didn't excuse him, I said I can imagine why he put his vote down, thus I wasn't really looking for his reasoning behind his vote. Beside, he already said he based it off of Hiraki. So what was the point in asking him again? He obviously had no case of his own.
Using that example against him is a rather poor argument and to be honest it looks like you are looking for something to put Neil through the rope because he has been so abrasive.
Neil, you seem like a good player, but honestly some of your comments are just mean. Your mean choice of words has burned bridges and made people generally suspicious of you.
I will say however that being Anti-Town is never a good thing and should be suspect for scummy behavior in general.
Shotty seems pretty interested in a Neil/Hiraki scum team, but I honestly cannot see that. Especially with the way they have been treating each other. However, none of Shotty's actions have been overtly scummy so he stands at a town-null for now.
DJ: Really hasn't done much of worth other than switch his vote a lot and try to start bandwagons.
I can't see how scum would openly state Lets go bandwagon. Almost as bad as a scum slip. Have him as town.
Andrew, FriendlyNoggin, and Jakesh all have low post counts and haven't contributed anything, but they have excuses so that is... excusable.
They better start posting more once their time frees up, though.
The Longing: Weird how on page 4 he already states that he has solid reads on people, but he doesn't share these reads. Isn't that the equivalent to Neil's actions? Why didn't anyone call him out? I know that this early in the game reads are likely to change a lot and that is natural. Why be hesitant in posting them?