My Little Pony Mafia - GENOCIDAL FRIENDSHIP PONIES

[inHimshallibe]

Jahudo's push here is interesting. I don't find it likely to come from scum as so many people have put my name higher on lists. Going to upgrade his status from the bottom of the list.

[Jahudo]

You voted TheLonging for seeing the "no lynch" vote as anti-town and scummy in theory, while not thinking of why scum would be motivated to make that move like that. His reasoning was that 1 no lynch vote is closer to getting a no lynch result, and that scum would want to try for that result.

WLC used different reasoning. He said that using no lynch is a way to not tie yourself to somebody. That argument can effortlessly be made without referencing TheLonging because they are different tells.

How you can not see the difference between the two makes me think you are not analyzing the case past the premise. You jumped into that vote within minutes of WLC's post, like you are trying to falsely push momentum from TheLonging wagon onto this one when it isn't justified.

[inHimshallibe]

I'm not analyzing his reasoning at all. I'm analyzing why he chose to only bring something up from the beginning of the game when there had been content from after that point.

[Jahudo]

No lynch voting as a means to avoid creating ties was brought up before him? I don't see where.

------

I used to be more bandwagony over little points and gut reads but I haven't been that way nearly as much in my past few games. I realized I'd end up writing walls back and forth whoever I was scumhunting but the amount of words being said weren't proportional to the things we were learning. So now I think slower starts with more prep work will result in better cases being made. That's the plan anyway.

[inHimshallibe]

Ok, I see it now.

The No Lynch vote was touched on briefly in the very beginning, but no, WLC's point had not been specifically addressed at the time of his vote. However, chesskid has posted more than that No Lynch vote, and I placed my vote on the reasoning that WLC's vote was made without considering the other behavior of chesskid/TheLonging/the person he was placing the vote on at that time.

To recap: WLC's post was a fly-by vote using incomplete information on a player, along with that reasoning being irrelevant at this juncture.

[Jahudo]

Yes, this line of thought does not excuse WLC's lack of scumhunting after his vote, like commenting on chesskid's other posts or talking about some other topics in general. WLC is someone to watch in that way.

[Gammagooey]

@Equi- I haven't done it to this extent but I did do something similar in Mafia Reverberation when I replaced in to explain how I felt about Rhinox-http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&t=13274
It's pretty much just a way to explain my thoughts on people better than I could with just normal "i think X&Y are prob scum and A,C,&F are all town", especially in the early game when my reads aren't super strong.

[Katsuki]

WHAT IN THE FLYING FUCK I WAS PLANNING ON FLAKING ON MPR BUT APPARENTLY HE MANAGED TO FLAKE ON ME FIRST.

I HAVENT READ THE GAME AT ALL, AND DON'T HAVE THE TIME FOR IT.

OUR HYDRA IS STILL INACTIVE.

[MehPlusRawr]

WHAT IN THE FLYING FUCK I WAS PLANNING ON FLAKING ON MPR BUT APPARENTLY HE MANAGED TO FLAKE ON ME FIRST.

I HAVENT READ THE GAME AT ALL, AND DON'T HAVE THE TIME FOR IT.

OUR HYDRA IS STILL INACTIVE.

YEAH SORRY ABOUT THAT BASICALLY I WAS WAITING ON THE HYDRA AND THEN DISAPPEARED FROM THE INTERNET FOR A DAY OR TWO AND NOW I'M POSTING

READING AND STUFF AND DAMMIT HYDRA ACTIVATEPLZ

[Gammagooey]

send a PM to mith/flay about the hydra. it makes things go faster.

[Twilight Sparkle]

Vote Count #6

WeyounsLastClone:

inHimshallibe, chesskid3, TheLonging (L-4)

chesskid3:

Fluttershy, Maziek, WeyounsLastClone (L-4)

inHimshallibe:

Mina, Jahudo

TheLonging:

Espeonage

Gammagooey:

Equinox

Espeonage:

hohum

Jahudo:

Gammagooey

Not Voting:

Jahudo

, MehPlusRawr

Day One Deadline

(expired on 2011-06-30 03:00:00)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

***

TheLonging, Maziek, and WeyounsLastClone have been prodded.

Mina and Fluttershy have also been prodded, but since they were V/LA, these prods won't count on their records.

Chesskid is V/LA until June 21st.

[Fluttershy]

yay late night reading >_> If there is anything you really want me to comment on, highlight it for me please

UNVOTE:
First and foremost, a very important question: Jahudo, have you actually watch My Little Pony at all?

For one you OMGUS'd me. For two, Post #20, "I don't need to explain myself", which is a really bad post to explain away anything, for three you're being defensive and panicky (which ties into the other 2)

You are really taking the OMGUS seriously?

Fluttershy's call of policy lynch looked serious enough to respond in a serious manner. I do believe that chesskid is a good player and would know there is no foreseeable advantage to actually no lynch, which made it a clear joke, which meant there was no serious reason to suggest a no lynch. Also your posting style is hard to follow, some sections don't seem to have any point but if its just getting jokes out of the way early okay.

Did it? I can't remember what game I was watching, but someone called for a PL on Chesskid and I wanted to see if I could get a similar reaction. I have never played with him before.

Not to beat the 'no lynch' horse (or pony in this case) again, but I really don't get why you would vote No Lynch during random voting stage. If you're not trying to tie yourself to anyone, I think that's more beneficial as scum than town. It's a RVS for a reason.

Vote: TheLonging'

Need to read some other games of chesskid to see if this is how he plays. If so, it's a bit too 'flippant'. (not sure if that's the exact word I'm looking for, but hope you get what I mean).

Already hit by others. Not sure how I feel about it though. First was leaning scummy, but then I have started to drift back in the null direction.

What exactly would constitute the fun part? Any specific reason you're not voting for someone in your 'scum' category, but in the 'lingering between null and scum'?

Seems like you are grasping here. Are you worried that he is voting you?

If I had to chose between TheLonging, Weyouns and Espeonage right now my choice would be Espeonage.

Unvote, Vote, Espeonage

What is the case on Espeonage? I think I have missed the reasons behind it.

hum dee dum dum, 2 days of 10 hour drives coming up for me. Will be here more though, so I can properly jump back into this game.

[Gammagooey]

you were talking about the policy lynching of chesskid-

I wanted to see if I could get a similar reaction.

Why?

[Equinox]

Fluttershy isn't roleplayin' with me? That's a right shame.

Question of interest:

Jahudo, have you actually watch My Little Pony at all?

When Jahudo answers this, I'd be interested in knowin' why you addressed this to Jahudo in particular.

What is the case on Espeonage? I think I have missed the reasons behind it.

Lightnin' fast town reads of chesskid3 and Equinox when there wasn't enough evidence to warrant it. Result of recent questionin' about his remark of the WeyounsLastClone wagon still outstandin'.

[TheLonging]

anti-prod, will check in after school

[Ant_to_the_max]

Why?

Why not?

@Equinox: I concede to your awesomeness and wouldn't be able to keep up this whole game
I do have a reason for singling him out and yes I will share. Will look again with those notes in mind.

[Fluttershy]

*le sigh*
I should really not do this early in the morning. >___>

Why?

Why not?

@Equinox: I concede to your awesomeness and wouldn't be able to keep up this whole game
I do have a reason for singling him out and yes I will share. Will look again with those notes in mind.

[Jahudo]

Welcome back Flootershy. For some reason I thought you were a hydra and not an alt. And that Sotty may have been involved.

First and foremost, a very important question: Jahudo, have you actually watch My Little Pony at all?

I have watched every episode twice now, and frequent equestria daily and ponychan for moar pony. Although I didn't discover this show until mid-may. So why do you ask?

Did it? I can't remember what game I was watching, but someone called for a PL on Chesskid and I wanted to see if I could get a similar reaction.

What gamma said. What kind of reaction did that previous PL vote get? Do you remember any conclusions drawn from it?

[hohum]

LA next two days or so sorry

So you say but you have time to fuck around in facebook group chat.

Ah my little phony, trying to rile up the stables.

Chesskid just shot to the top of my list.

[hohum]

I really don't agree with the initial premise behind the Weyoun wagon based on what Chesskid is currently doing here. He should have gotten shit for a no-lynch vote even if he wasn't completely serious about it.

[chesskid3]

God forbid I want a two day break eh hohum?

[chesskid3]

I will have something up by the end of today but tbh nothing interesting happened in the last two days

[hohum]

It's not that you took a break. I'd be fine with it if you had simply disappeared and stayed within the stated posting guidlines or if you had actually gone somewhere but your activity on facebook seems to indicate that you've not gone anywhere -- at least not anywhere that wouldn't allow you to check the thread every so often.

[inHimshallibe]

LA next two days or so sorry

So you say but you have time to fuck around in facebook group chat.

Ah my little phony, trying to rile up the stables.

Chesskid just shot to the top of my list.

Glad he shot to being who you voted.

Wait.

FOS: hohum

[hohum]

Chesskid just shot to the top of my list.

Glad he shot to being who you voted.

Wait.

FOS: hohum

[/quote]

Way to strawman. I'm allowed to express an opinion about activity that I find scummy while continuing to pressure someone else for a read. Espe obviously has no desire to pay attention to the thread or participate in this game in any meaningful way.