Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[Ragnarokio]

Looking forward to it.

[Thor665]

@Rag - though as long as we're making requests. My request to you is that you copypasta some of that awesome scumhunting from your QT into the thread here.

[PeregrineV]

If I was a doc that could protect from Dayvigs why would that make the Dayvig pro-town? It would be the opposite, yes?
Why MoS?

So it would seem. Which brings up the question why you are so sure there is such a thing, and why you are inssiting on it before full claiming.

MoS because I believe Rag-MBF town for now:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 4#p3132464

[Thor665]

If I was a doc that could protect from Dayvigs why would that make the Dayvig pro-town? It would be the opposite, yes?
Why MoS?

So it would seem. Which brings up the question why you are so sure there is such a thing, and why you are inssiting on it before full claiming.

I'm sure...because I'm not a Daycop? I actually don't understand your point here at all. Could you restate it please?

[Thor665]

*Day doc - whatevs.

[PeregrineV]

@Rag - I will. But not prior till 9pm EST tonight. I'm still hoping the Vig wises up and claims, because between my power and his power we can deal with the you/mbf "vigs" and be looking very good going into tomorrow.

Does this mean you don't believe the vig claims?

Also @Rag- don't quote QT- Capital offense (http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=17331)
You can, however, paraphrase....

[PeregrineV]

If I was a doc that could protect from Dayvigs why would that make the Dayvig pro-town? It would be the opposite, yes?
Why MoS?

So it would seem. Which brings up the question why you are so sure there is such a thing, and why you are inssiting on it before full claiming.

I'm sure...because I'm not a Daycop? I actually don't understand your point here at all. Could you restate it please?

Why is it so important to out another PR, esp. a pro-town PR, and esp., how is it important to your (pro-town) role?
(you mentioned how you & dayvig could help win the game (but I'm hoping you mean for town), but it doesn't say why it's important)

[mikeburnfire]

My role name is NSA Agent John Casey

I verify, except I was told the title was "Colonel" John Casey.

So you're certain the remaining scumteam is dram/Thor - or are you compromising here?

Hell no I'm not certain. The only person who doesn't look like scum to me at this point is Rag and maybe Ant.

Also - why do you think my claim is fake?

Why should I believe it you haven't done it yet?

Isn't that against your point?

No, what I meant was that if town is really powerful, then the scum would not have killing restrictions.

Also, I already paraphrased Rag's QT suspicions few pages back. She hasn't really done much in the QT since then.

[PeregrineV]

@MBF- Did you learn she was the night1 vig before or after night1?

[Thor665]

Does this mean you don't believe the vig claims?

If my Dayvig buddy shows up - heck no I don't believe them.
If there is no dayvig...I'll be back to the drawing board.

Also @Rag- don't quote QT- Capital offense

Fair point - though I think you're allowed to quote yourself and have done so in other games. She can paraphrase it to avoid issues.

[Ragnarokio]

The culmination of my scumhunting up until that point of time was contained within my analysis of all living players that I posted a while back. I haven't done much since then.

I'll ask the mod if I'm allowed to quote things from the quicktopic.

[Empking]

Isn't that against your point?

No, what I meant was that if town is really powerful, then the scum would not have killing restrictions.

Yes but your point is that scum have some restriction that stopped them killing night 1 and that the two neighbour-vigs are both town. Isn't that contradicted by that quote.

[mikeburnfire]

@MBF- Did you learn she was the night1 vig before or after night1?

She told me she was the odd-night vig after I yelled in-game "Is there a restricted vigilante out there?!"

@Empking
No. What I'm saying is that if the town is really powerful (restricted vigilante, cop, neighborizer, dayvig, etc), then the mafia would have extra abilities to balance it out (roleblocker, godfather, etc). I don't think that they would be assigned a role that would be restrictive.

Unofficial vote count.
PeregrineV (1): Ant_to_the_max
dramonic (1): mikeburnfire
Thor665 (1): Ragnarokio
Ragnarokio (1): Empking
mikeburnfire (1):, dramonic
Mastermind of Sin (1): PeregrineV

Not voting:Mastermind of Sin, Thor665

Good grief.

[PeregrineV]

2. I'm 95% sure Rag is Mafia. If he is then I think MBF, MOS and Ant are town.

What if Rag is town. Then who can be mafia?

[Thor665]

@mbf - What's even funnier with that vote count is before I unvoted you weren't voting with your 'obv. town' buddy Rag for Thor - but where instead voting with obv. scum Thor for dramonic.
I really want there to be a Day Vig so we can wipe the slate clean of both of you.

[Empking]

2. I'm 95% sure Rag is Mafia. If he is then I think MBF, MOS and Ant are town.

What if Rag is town. Then who can be mafia?

MBF, MOS, Thor, You, Dram

[PeregrineV]

@MBF- Can you link to the post where you did that?

@Thor-Can you link to where MBF thinks your obvscum?

@EmpKing- lol- so Ant is town no matter what, and MBF and MOS hinge on Rag? Can you help me wxplain how you arrived at this cinclusion?
And if Rag is mafia, what is Thor? What am I? And what is Dram?

[mikeburnfire]

@mbf - What's even funnier with that vote count is before I unvoted you weren't voting with your 'obv. town' buddy Rag for Thor - but where instead voting with obv. scum Thor for dramonic.
I really want there to be a Day Vig so we can wipe the slate clean of both of you.

You are really ridiculous Thor. You and your fake claim.

[Thor665]

@Pere - one page ago when I asked him about his dram vote.

@mbf - I'll accept funny as better than the insults from earlier. Why is my claim so false?

[mikeburnfire]

@MBF- Can you link to the post where you did that?

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 8#p3109748

[mikeburnfire]

Why is my claim so false?

I'll tell you at 9PM EST.

[Thor665]

Before or after my full claim?

[PeregrineV]

@MBF- I found it.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 8#p3109748

At what point did you claim to Rag your ability? Did she know your target (Magua) before you sent it in, or only day3? What wer eher suggestions, if any, if you discussed it beforehand?

[Empking]

@EmpKing- lol- so Ant is town no matter what, and MBF and MOS hinge on Rag? Can you help me wxplain how you arrived at this cinclusion?
And if Rag is mafia, what is Thor? What am I? And what is Dram?

Look at what people have claimed. We clearly have a Cop.
We won't have a scum neighbour and scum neighbourizer.
If Rag is scum then he and MBF wouldn't link to each other.
If Rag is scum then I'd say Dram is the most likely buddy.

[PeregrineV]

@EmpKing- they've been neighbors the whole game, since the start.

@Thor- You are/were voting MBF, yet unvoted Dram, who MBF just voted for. ????