Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[Mastermind of Sin]

@Thor- Did you somewhere point out the simplest explanation? 3 mafia and a one-shot town vig that missed?

Peregrine: Why would a one-shot town vig kill confirmed town Ooba?

[PeregrineV]

No offense to your neighbor, but Ant a)could have been lying about being a cop or investigating ooba or b)hit a babyface.

Otherwise, I'm to believe that a SK/vig decided not to kill anyone night1, or decided to kill ReaperCharlie along with the Mafia, or that the doc protected the SK/vig night1 kill, or the sk/vig role was roleblocked, or the sk/vig neglected to send in a target, or the sk/vig hit a bulletproof, or the Sk/bulletproof targeted someone else but was re-directed, or....

See what I mean?

And that's assuming assassinated =mafia and kill=non-mafia. If not, it opens other possiblities.

[Empking]

No offense to your neighbor, but Ant a)could have been lying about being a cop or investigating ooba or b)hit a babyface.

A vig still shouldn't kill them. Especially with someone who was as generally town as Ooba.

or decided to kill ReaperCharlie along with the Mafia,

I doubt there'd only be one kill flavour in that case.

[Thor665]

@Thor- Did you somewhere point out the simplest explanation? 3 mafia and a one-shot town vig that missed?

Pretty much what other people said.

If he thought Ant was lying scum he should have shot Ant.
If he thought Ant was the cop he should have shot at, well, someone the cop hadn't cleared yet as opposed to going "lol, GF hunting" and just stupidly blowing away someone who, even if there is a GF in the game, is still statistically far more likely to be town than scum.
If the Vig is 1 shot I *hate* the Vig.

@Rag - .... (<---this is what I see when I read your posts)

@MBF - why is MoS more and more scummy seeming? Also, why are you town?

@Those against the flavor claim - is there a really obvious Doc flavor claim in this show?

[Thor665]

@MBF - also, please reaffirm town feel for Rag.

[Empking]

There are two doctors but I don't think it makes sense for them to be

the

doctor.

[Thor665]

@Emp - your current read on MBF and Rag?

[Empking]

Rag = Scum
MBF = Maybe scum due to POE.

[xRECKONERx]

Ragnarokio (1): Empking
Mastermind of Sin (2): mikeburnfire, Ragnarokio
PeregrineV (1): Ant_to_the_max
ChannelDelibird (1): PeregrineV

Not voting: ChannelDelibird, Mastermind of Sin, Thor665

Notes:
Ant_to_the_max has limited access until June 25th.
No prods needed.
With

8

alive it takes

5

to lynch!
Deadline is in (expired on 2011-06-20 01:00:00).

[Ant_to_the_max]

lol

mod: you should take a look at your deadline counter

[Ragnarokio]

@Rag - .... (<---this is what I see when I read your posts)

What do you see when you read your own posts?

[Ragnarokio]

that last quote was by thor >.>

[Thor665]

I see pure awesome, scumhunting, pressure of suspects, explanation of clearing players I'm calling town, and the sexiest beard this side of ZZ Top.

What do you see when you read your posts?

[mikeburnfire]

Guys, I killed ReaperCharlie and Magua. I'm sorry. I'm the vig, and I'm terrible at it. I was planning to kill MoS, but he had just claimed to be a role, so I hesitated and killed Magua instead. The interactions between dana and Magua were always "null tell" and "no read", so I thought I could get a freebie there. I killed RC because he's RC. The mafia didn't kill anybody Night 1, which is why I'm suspicious of all this 'doctor' talk. The mafia would be the most likely to suspect a doc because a doc might have stopped them.

Rag isn't scum. She's my neighbor. She's always been. I have always eyed her suspiciously, and I can see why you guys might suspect her, but trust me- she's far more open in the private thread. She's been analyzing each and every player. When I told her to post it, she was worried that she would 'clutter the thread' with her 'scattered opinions'. If you could see what I see, you'd understand. She's playing like a townie.

I have some other small pieces of information that I cannot share right now. As it stands, Rag and EmpKing look town to me. Ant maybe. Thor, Peregrene and CD are wild cards, and MoS needs to die.

[Ant_to_the_max]

And the plot thickens.

But you also claimed neighbor, so how can you be sure of her alignment/her of yours?

[Empking]

Unvote

I'd like a nameclaim from at least MBF.

[mikeburnfire]

@Ant:
Honestly, I wasn't at first. Neither of us were confirmed to the other, but she seemed to trust me a lot. It seemed like buddying to me. However,

(1) She has been scumhunting more than people give her credit for
(2) I am 100% of her flavor, and it's a good character from the show (from what I've gleaned off a wiki)
(3) <Can't say reason 3 right now>

@EmpKing:
I'm fine with that. I'm the one who suggested the mass flavor claim. I'm CIA Agent Sarah Walker, who is, apparently, Chuck's love interest or wife or something.

[Empking]

Does it mention wife in your role PM?

[Thor665]

::headdesk::

Wait, so MBF - you're a Vig who also started the game as a neighbor to Rag? Plese do a clear and concise full claim so I understand this.

@Rag - PROTIP - YOU'RE *ALREADY* CLUTTERING THE THREAD...WITH FLUFF POSTINGS!

So, when did you and Rag become neighbors?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Assuming this is a 2/6 game right now, I think a full claim might work.

If there is a doc, they can protect me, and then they will probably die.
I can get one more investigation off.
MBF can vig once more. Even if the scum target him, his kill will go through. (I' assuming that is how it works)

Worst case we end up 2/3
dunno how that goes if he is a SK though...

Preview edit:

STOP IT EMPKING >_>
and I figured you were the other half :/

[Empking]

STOP IT EMPKING >_>
and I figured you were the other half :/

?

[Thor665]

Guys, I killed ReaperCharlie and Magua. I'm sorry. I'm the vig, and I'm terrible at it.

I will say this is pretty blatant flinging of town sweat from pores. SK would be dumb as hell to claim kills that weak and to claim killing role this early.

[Empking]

MBF: Why didn't you kill Dana?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Your question was totally uncalled for.
Look at the name of this game >_>

[Ant_to_the_max]

Nvm
*facedesk*