Time Travel Mafia (Game Over)

[Tragedy]

I'm more amazed of MrTrow + Smargaret connection now.

Smarg (Rated Scum): 10th -> 6th -> 3rd
imaginality (Rated Scum): 9th -> 1rst -> 2nd
Amrun (Rated Scum): 1rst -> 5th -> 1rst

I don't get his list of scum anymore, for some reason.

[GhostWriter]

Let me see if I have this right: you have a problem with his reads changing as the game goes on?

[Tasky]

Amrun (7): Exe, MrTrow, RedCoyote, GhostWriter, imaginality, Maxous, Kcdaspot
smargaret (2): Tragedy, C-Worl
Not Voting (1): GreyICE




Amrun, ???? has been lynched Day 2!


It is now N2.
Since I will be away until saturday, this night will last a little longer than usual.
Send me all your actions until 04.06.2011, 12:00 CET.

IMPORTANT:

I hope everyone in this game trusts me and continues to play even if it looks demotivating. Please refrain to criticize me until you know the setup and the mechanics. If you think I have abused your trust after the game is over, feel free to rage at me and to blacklist me as a mod.
This is not a bastard game and it is made for your entertainment.
I cannot and will not reveal anything in order to keep the game intact, but I give you my word that you will not regret continuing to play.

[Tasky]

GreyICE, Casual Bystander

, modkilled (and thus loses the game) and erased from history for unsporting behavior.

The history so far:

*

Spoiler: Day 1 nominations

Zinger2099 7: smargaret, Amrun,

GreyICE

, Doombunny9, imaginality, Zinger2099, Exe, MrTrow
Kcdaspot 5: RedCoyote, Tragedy, Doombunny9, imaginality, Zinger2099
Amrun 4: RedCoyote, Tragedy, GhostWriter, MrTrow
Smargaret 3: Amrun, Kcdaspot, Maxous
Maxous

3

2: smargaret,

GreyICE

, Exe
RedCoyote 1: Kcdaspot
Exe 1: Maxous
Doombunny 1: GhostWriter

GreyICE: MrTrow

Zinger2099 and Kcdaspot on the block.

Spoiler: Day 1 lynch

Zinger (6): smargaret, Exe, Maxous, Tragedy, Doombunny9, RedCoyote
Kcdaspot (1): GhostWriter
Not Voting (3): MrTrow, Amrun, imaginality

Zinger2099, ???? lynched D1

Spoiler: Results N1

GhostWriter, Casual Bystander

, killed N1

Spoiler: Day 2 nominations

Amrun (4):

GhostWriter

, RedCoyote, imaginality, smargaret, MrTrow
smargaret (4): C-Worl, Kcdaspot, Amrun, Maxous
imaginality (4):

GhostWriter

, Tragedy, Maxous, MrTrow, Kcdaspot
MrTrow (3): Tragedy, C-Worl, smargaret,

GreyICE

GreyICE (3): RedCoyote, Kcdaspot, Amrun

RedCoyote (2): Exe,

GreyICE

, Amrun
Tragedy (1): imaginality
C-Worl (1): Exe
Exe (1): RedCoyote
=>2 players chosen randomly out of {Amrun, smargaret, imaginality}: Amrun and smargaret on the block.

Spoiler: Day 2 lynch

Amrun (6): Exe, MrTrow, RedCoyote, imaginality, Maxous, Kcdaspot
smargaret (2): Tragedy, C-Worl

Amrun, ???? lynched D2

Spoiler: Results N2

imaginality, Casual Bystander

, killed N2

The following players are still alive:

01. MrTrow
02. Maxous
04. RedCoyote
05. smargaret
07. Tragedy
10. C-Worl
11. Kcdaspot
13. Exe

With 8 players alive it takes 5 "LYNCH"-Votes to proceed to nominations.
Deadline will fall 11 days from this post.

*I have decided to not change all the posts in the thread according to the new timeline, as it wouldn't add anything to the game and would just be a lot of work.

[Tragedy]

Really, KCDASPOT?
YOU WENT FOR GHOSTWRITER?....
Uhhh...
So yeah, Casual Bystanders (VT) exists.

[Kcdaspot]

no. I killed no one N1.

I killed n2.

i was blocked.

[Kcdaspot]

smarg was my target. now my vig is wasted.

[Tragedy]

When you're blocked, you won't get your vig wasted...

[Kcdaspot]

AND FINALLY. FLIPS!!!! GLORIOUS GLORIOUS FLIPS!

all vt Casual Bystanders thoo.

sooooo.... now what?

pedit: my vig shot is gone mod confirmed that to D2.

when i said vig smarg n2 that shot is gone. no matter what.

[Kcdaspot]

*to me D2.

[Tragedy]

I still think Smarg is scum with MrTrow.

I guess it was a flipped game when someone goes in time travel and kills somebody, I think?

[Kcdaspot]

hang on:

MOD: Did someone ORIGINALLY die D1 or was there a mod error?

[Tragedy]

If someone had originally died, then it would've been a Mod Error.
Unless someone went back in time and shot GhostWriter.

[Kcdaspot]

oh

nvm

scum has time machines.

also again i didn't kill imaginality

[Tasky]

hang on:

MOD: Did someone ORIGINALLY die D1 or was there a mod error?

Everything is correct to the best of my knowledge.

[C-Worl]

I still think Smarg is scum with MrTrow.

I guess it was a flipped game when someone goes in time travel and kills somebody, I think?

QFT

[smargaret]

BAH

I targeted grey ice last night. I got an inno on him too.

I targeted GW n1 because I'm not certain of my ability to read him. I targeted grey because he seemed to fall in that null zone for most of the town.

I'm kind of surprised to be alive, honestly.

[C-Worl]

So ur claiming to have targeted 2 dead players?

[smargaret]

Yep, neither of whom was dead when I targeted them, and one who likely died in response to my claiming the inno. Mafia do that, they kill confirmed innos.

[Tragedy]

Yep, neither of whom was dead when I targeted them, and one who likely died in response to my claiming the inno.

Mafia do that, they kill confirmed innos.

Then shouldn't you have died instead?
We killed that doctor/scum, yet, you're not bulletproof either.

Oh glorious, you even went to investigate a guy

who was going to be modkilled anyways with a flip.

[Maxous]

Even if smaragret is mafia there is no way she could of known about an impendning nightkill...
But eh yeah - looks a bit bad that Grey was the target :p

Why the heck did imaginality die? The only thing I can think of was that the mafia made the action on N1 when imaginality was on most people's town lists. He was a likely mislynch target today.

no. I killed no one N1.
I killed n2.
i was blocked.

How exactly does roleblocking work in this game?
Would the mafia of had to block you N1, N2 or either night to prevent a kill?

So it seems we

do

have a lynch janitor.
Amrun was more than likely mafia because of this. I found her insistence of having one in the game strange.
In my opinion we are dealing with 2 mafia left (under the assumption that we started with 3).
Zinger indeed has a history of self-voting as town.

Still in worst case scenario we are dealing with 3 mafia with 8 alive. Should we no-lynch as a precaution?

[MrTrow]

I'm kind of surprised to be alive, honestly.

So you`re saying you didn`t time-travel your way out of that one?
Which means kcda is either lying or was blocked?

Tragedy does have a point, your claimed result on ghostwriter only confirms him as innocent, if you are.
and mafia (with a bit of common sense) kills confirmed (town) cop over confirmed town of unknown power.

@Max: no no-lynch:
I do believe in amrun way more likely to be scum than zinger
GreyIce`s point about them being unlikely buddies holds true as well.
Result: no-lynching now will land us in a 7-man-lylo likely with amrun alive. (independent on whether or not amrun was mafia)

I also assume you`re talking about the 'modkill' in that first sentence.
Either way your statement makes no sense.
True smarg-scum didn`t know GreyIce was going to be modkilled (something probably happened tonight(the last drop) as i believe the modkill would have taken place earlier), however, she DID know it before she CLAIMED the investigation.

[Maxous]

Oh pardon me.. Yes I was referring to the modkill and I was referring to Tragedy's comment above mine that seemed to be giving out to smargaret for targeting somebody about to modkilled. Should of been clearer :/

I see your point about Amrun being brought back to life. I honestly forgot the stuff about that. Okay, yeah we should lynch today.

About smargaret: As I outlined Day 1, I do have reasons to think she is mafia in this game. However mafia claiming cop would of been a high-risk gambit that she took when Amrun was the likely lynch of the day. Since there was only one person eliminated from the game - which was a claimed VT - it is likely the town has a cop. With nobody counter-claiming I am inclined to think she is telling the truth.
Somebody from the town would of countered-claimed, whereas I could see why somebody would'nt counter-claim Amrun being a doctor. Alternatively Kcd has protection abilities which could be acting as the 'doctor' of the game.

The most curious thing to me here is that Kcdaspot claimed he was blocked with his kill but smargaret was'nt blocked from using her cop power last night.
Could it be one of them is mafia and therefore lying? Another answer would be that Amrun was the mafia roleblocker I suppose..

[MrTrow]

good one: (although i don`t see how having a claimed VT makes the presence of a cop more likely)

Kcda: do you assume you were blocked or do you know you are blocked?

Smarg: could you tell the 'time related details' of your powers? (in addition to previous questions ofcourse)
More specifically(but not limited to), if you believe in the 'Mafia does that, they kill confirmed townies' why didn`t you watch him?

[Maxous]

Wait I worded that wrong again.

What I was meant is that assuming the mafia know the role of the people that are lynched(like janitors normally do), smargaret could not of lifted the ability of a cop because the guy had claimed VT.
A cop is just normally likely.