Not been intentionally lurking. This week has been a screwed up one for me, but I'm about to go through quite a few players, starting with the case on Sotty7.
Incidentally, you can go through a single players posts with a drop down menu? AWESOME. That makes looking over plays a lot easier.
My case on Sotty relies primarily on DrippingGoofball.
She gave scum reads on Sociopath (328) and Thor (319).
She gave town reads on Llamarble once, (post 183), Equinox once, (305) and Sotty7 THREE TIMES(post 166) (post 178) (post 183).
Would scum really try to clear town for no good reason?
The argument was made earlier that one scummy thing done by Dripping Goofball was to make the 'alt' argument against me. I agree with this.
On that note: Sotty's post 20:
Vote: Chris B
Alt detected.
With regards to Sotty7 being the fifth voter on DGB. I've never liked the argument that scum are more likely to bus on a certain number vote than another one. So I'm not comfortable wth the reverse either, and the fifth vote being the obviously town position. There's still time in there to climb down on a vote.
She also makes the point in post 272 that:
I had forgotten about DGB's V/LA which sucks because now the power wagon lags as we wait for her to come back. Not cool.
Which strikes me as slowing down that vote.
Complete WIFOM in post 538 which can be summed up as 'Scum wouldn't vote DGB like I did'.
On top of that, she's ignored posts of mine twice now. This post here isn't the first time I've pointed out that the 'alt detected' vote. Also, I've already addressed the scum daytalk thing.
So yeah, it's enough for me to be unconvinced by the town argument.
