Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[PeregrineV]

@Thor- Oh yeah.
Happy Birthday

(Saw your movie. Umm..the comic was better.)

[ChannelDelibird]

@CDB- You seemed to have a lot to say day 1, and said you had more, but would like to hear more.

I apologise profusely, been a little bit busy over the last few days but I intend to pay back that posting debt I owe you guys very soon. If you don't hear more from me this weekend, lynch me.

[mikeburnfire]

Magua, why should I answer your questions when you don't answer mine?

Peregrene, the reason for my vote should be obvious. Magua's recent behavior of blatant bandwagoning somebody he doesn't believe to be scum, coupled with his refusal to explain himself.

Everyone, I have certain reasons why I believe Ragnarok is likely to not be scum. I can't say why, and I'm not 100% certain, but if you think that I'm town, I would appreciate taking him off of lynch-1 and finding a different target today.

[PeregrineV]

As I wait for on more report to run:
Now:
Ragnarokio (4):

Thor665

,

danakillsu

,

Magua

, PeregrineV
danakillsu (2): Mastermind of Sin, ooba
Magua (2): Ant_to_the_max, mikeburnfire
Ant_to_the_max (1): Ragnarokio
Mastermind of Sin (1): Empking


Not Voting (1) ChannelDelibird

Then:
Energetic Penguin (7):

Magua

,

Thor665

, Ragnarokio, ooba, ChannelDelibird,

danakillsu

, Ant_to_the_max
danakillsu (2): mikeburnfire, Mastermind of Sin,
Mastermind of Sin (2): PeregrineV, ReaperCharlie
ReaperCharlie (1): MarchHare

Notes:
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is Thursday May 12 at 11:59 PM (EST)

Energetic Penguin: Lester Patel (Vanilla Townie) Lynched Day 1.

[PeregrineV]

@MBF- I'm OK with that, but he needs to get in here or replace out or get lynched.

UNVOTE: Rag
VOTE: EmpKing

@EmpKing
Can you share with us your current town, scum and null reads, and possibly why?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Interesting voting block there. Dana being on both wagons only reaffirms my vote on him. I'll take a look at Thor and Magua soon.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Ok. I am a bit busy right now to properly sit down so

Mod: V/LA until Sunday night

But to chime in on one thing brought up. I picked those three strait out of a RC post. I was going to double check them with how Thor felt about those three near the end of day one. Going under the assumption of Thor being town, maybe they killed RC over Thor because he wasn't the immediate threat. That is what stood out to me as a possible lead.

[Magua]

Magua, why should I answer your questions when you don't answer mine?

Because your questions have so far been stupid with incredibly obvious answers. "Are you scum?" Jesus christ. What a pointless question. Ask some questions that aren't incredibly obvious, and I might answer them.

Peregrene, the reason for my vote should be obvious. Magua's recent behavior of blatant bandwagoning somebody he doesn't believe to be scum, coupled with his refusal to explain himself.

Everyone, I have certain reasons why I believe Ragnarok is likely to not be scum. I can't say why, and I'm not 100% certain, but if you think that I'm town, I would appreciate taking him off of lynch-1 and finding a different target today.

For the record, I think Ragnarokio is town, so we agree on that. Now, I re-ask my question: Do you think I'm scum?

[Thor665]

Gah, fine MBF. SHe's still useless though

Unvote: Ragnarokio
Vote: Danakillsu

[mikeburnfire]

Now, I re-ask my question: Do you think I'm scum?

Do you think that I think you're scum?

If so, what would you do about it?

[danakillsu]

For the record, I think Ragnarokio is town, so we agree on that. Now, I re-ask my question: Do you think I'm scum?

But according to Thor, you're still voting her. Why?

@ mbf
I do think you're town, but not necessarily that you're right. Your information doesn't exactly seem cut and dried, even if I assume you're confirmed town.

[Magua]

Do you think that I think you're scum?

I don't know, hence my asking you about it.

If so, what would you do about it?

Wouldn't do a goddamn thing about it. But it'd be nice to know. Mostly, it would depend on why you thought I was scum. If you thought I was scum for taking a game that was dying a slow death due to inactivity and doing *something*, then I'd write you off.

But according to Thor, you're still voting her. Why?

Did you read when I voted her in the first place?

And I haven't gathered the vast amounts of mental energy it needs for me to sheep Thor again, because now I've gotten what I've wanted, which is people talking.

Would you prefer that I sheep Thor on his vote on you?

What do you think about Ant? What about ooba?

[Thor665]

Would you prefer that I sheep Thor on his vote on you?

[Ragnarokio]

Sorry about the low activity today, It should start picking up again soon.

There don't seem to be many real cases going around right now, and I still like my case on ant the best, so I'm going to stick with that for now. Strange that the general impression i got was that there were a lot of people at least somewhat suspicious of him, but he isn't picking up any relevant interest.

@Rag- Any luck with this?

Most of the other people in the game are null, with one or two raising some minor suspicions that I intend to look further into so as to form a solid opinion.

Not really.

[Magua]

There don't seem to be many real cases going around right now, and I still like my case on ant the best, so I'm going to stick with that for now. Strange that the general impression i got was that there were a lot of people at least somewhat suspicious of him, but he isn't picking up any relevant interest.

What about ooba?

[Empking]

PerigrineV:

Town

Magua
Channeldelibird
Ant_to_the_max
Thor665

Scum

Ragnarokio
Mastermind of Sin*
danakillsu

[mikeburnfire]

Magua, you hadn't shown up on my scumradar until you unvoted somebody you suspected in favor of sheeping a vote no somebody you thought was town. There was no need to put somebody that you think is town so close to a lynch. Which is why I suddenly do indeed think that you could be scum.

[ooba]

I think I'll do Magua's posting for him ..

Magua, you hadn't shown up on my scumradar until you unvoted somebody you suspected in favor of sheeping a vote no somebody you thought was town. There was no need to put somebody that you think is town so close to a lynch. Which is why I suddenly do indeed think that you could be scum.

What about ooba?

[Magua]

Magua, you hadn't shown up on my scumradar until you unvoted somebody you suspected in favor of sheeping a vote no somebody you thought was town. There was no need to put somebody that you think is town so close to a lynch. Which is why I suddenly do indeed think that you could be scum.

I unvoted someone I suspected who had 0 other votes, a week into the Day. Game had been stagnating with people making contentless posts and it was going to run into another instance where we were going to get close to deadline and then there'd be a scramble.

That's dumb. This is a very sluggish town. Sluggish towns lose games.

So I did something to get people to post. If you think I'm scum for doing that, if you don't think I've been forthright in naming who I think scum is (Ant, ooba) or giving my reasons for why I think they're scum, then by all means keep your vote on me.

Empking thinks I'm town. Do you think he's town or scum?

[Magua]

What about ooba?

I already know what MBF thinks of you. He thinks you're a nullread, but he goes out of his way to defend you against my "crap reasoning".

[Ragnarokio]

There don't seem to be many real cases going around right now, and I still like my case on ant the best, so I'm going to stick with that for now. Strange that the general impression i got was that there were a lot of people at least somewhat suspicious of him, but he isn't picking up any relevant interest.

What about ooba?

Your case on ooba? The one that's centered around one post?

[mikeburnfire]

Game had been stagnating with people making contentless posts and it was going to run into another instance where we were going to get close to deadline and then there'd be a scramble.

So you decided to abandon your vote and, instead of joining Ragnarok (town-read) in voting Ant (scum-read), you put her closer to a lynch. What kind of discussion did you hope to spark, other than getting people to suspect you for blatant bandwagoning?

Besides, I don't know where you get the belief that the game was stagnating. Looked fairly active to me, and with RC gone there was hardly any chaff to sift through.

Empking thinks I'm town. Do you think he's town or scum?

Big whoop. He's also voted Rag and MoS, so we obviously don't share opinions. Quite frankly, I haven't seen anything useful from that slot all game, even before the replacement.

[Magua]

Your case on ooba? The one that's centered around one post?

The question isn't what do you think about my case on ooba, it's what do you think about ooba.

So you decided to abandon your vote and, instead of joining Ragnarok (town-read) in voting Ant (scum-read), you put her closer to a lynch.

Yes, exactly.

What kind of discussion did you hope to spark, other than getting people to suspect you for blatant bandwagoning?

That I was blatantly bandwagoning. Whether Ragnarokio was a good lynch. Whether anyone would defend her. Who would call me scum. Who would call me town. Who would jump on the bandwagon, who would jump off.

Besides, I don't know where you get the belief that the game was stagnating. Looked fairly active to me, and with RC gone there was hardly any chaff to sift through.

Day started Thursday, the 19th, and is two weeks long. I bandwagoned on Thursday, the 26th, halfway through the Day, and at the point, the Day had been a whopping five pages and nobody had more than two votes. There was no indication that anyone was going to get more than two votes. There was no content, there was people sitting around and killing time.

That's towndeath.

[Thor665]

I agree with Magua that the game was stagnating, I'd even said as much myself prior to his vote switchup.

Dana didn't even comment upon my blatant and awkward vote switch to him - I'm happy with that vote now.

[mikeburnfire]

I forgot about the stringent deadlines. Very well, I'll ease up.

unvote

vote: EmpKing