Battle for Olympus - Game Over!

[Shadow Dancer]

We do not at all want to no lynch anyway.
And yes, the whole timing and circumstances of Moth's replacement request reek of scum trying to lynchdodge.
If we don't get a replacement or extansion, lynching blindly might still be better than giving the slot an easy pass.

And... er.... you forgot your signature, -kt.

[LordChronos]

In http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 995113Post #552 he remarks that MoI is "almost certainly" not scum because of his claim which "insures" his death before LoL. Which just seems silly to say. Like, how do you figure his death is insured? Are you planning to lynch him? Even though you think he's "almost certainly" not scum? He's challenging BS to specify what she finds scummy about him, which is fine. BS was really just waggoning with Chesskid here, and Chesskid never really said much about why he was on LC's case.

He sticks with the vote following BS's claim. Says the Hider ability doesn't fit the role. Which is something I suppose he might believe, but then, in #763 he unvotes. It appears he might be following along with SD, in as much as SD is arguing he believes BS's claim and thinks it + her ability means she isn't scum. Say's he'll revote after a review, but doesn't get back before Gandalf ends the day. GEE GANDALF, THAT HELPED US SO MUCH.

Here he questions a plan of Chesskids (which might not have made any sense), but more interestingly to me, chastises SD to stop "role-fishing" re: Dekes. SD claimed he jailkept Dekes. Dekes claimed he was not jailkept. One would think the conflict between those claims would be of interest, but LC doesn't seem interested about it at all.

#1205 Is probably his longest post of the game. This is where he's going to commit to a second lynch (after the obv. AV). The person he picks is...AGM. His reasoning? "AGM is acting like Ice's result on him is accutare. No protown posting at all."

This whole post is a summary type post. "Gandalf - Chess argument was a waste of space." "AV is posting stuff that is invalid." "Gandalf isn't making sense re:SD SK belief." This post is pretty scummy.

He then follows MoI and says he's willing to lynch Quadz after AGM has claimed Doc. He agrees with MoI about the "third party comment". Nothing more really said until he jumps to me after Quadz treestump. On me, he just says "as I said earlier" he finds me scummy. He reaffirms this by criticizing my post compiling all the claims in the thread (which I had already made, but he hadn't previously commented on).

He has an awful lot of "question" posts in this game. These are typically 1-liners. They are rarely followed up on. I guess he always satisfied by the answer he gets? Too many of those starts to look scummy. It's a way to stay looking interested without having to really comment or commit yourself to anything. He's mostly following along this game. Posting infrequently. Giving a bare minimum of informed opinions.

Re: MoI

If you would like to have a hated townie alive in LyLo, be my guest. Don't blame me when you lose. Ideally, of course, we will lynch all the scum and any third party before we get to LyLo, but we also can't let MoI enter a LyLo situation or the scum will lynch him for the win, yes?

Re: My Unvote of BS

The unvote came after BS used her super to have the mod post that message for her. Maybe you can extrapolate from that why I unvoted then as opposed to unvoting after a hider claim from the goddess of rainbows.

Re: Rolefishing

I thought it was quite clear what Dekes meant. He has some kind of role that generates a result and he got a result when he used it. Further inquiries as to what that role is only draw out more claims and help guide scum.

Re: Summary Post

Of course it was a summary, I was catching up after having been busy. Since then I have been putting more effort in to this game, though still perhaps not as much as I ought to.

Re: Quadz

MoI and I were far from the only ones to mention that comment as odd. Why single me out as "following" him?

Re: Posting short posts

I don't do long walls generally. I make short posts unless I really get worked up about something. I tend to ask too many questions and don't do enough analysis. These are things I am trying to do better at.

[AurorusVox]

I'm back from holiday and still alive? Siiiick.

Do you guys want me to reread however many pages since my last post, or are you just going to ignore anything I say anyway?

=_="

[quadz08]

You're the lynch today.

Take that as you will.

If you're town (which you're not) you should do a re-read and give us your thoughts so we have them to look back on.

[Charon]

Man, I'm really good at this whole remembering-to-do-things thing.

-->I forgot to send out the "I need a replacement" PM to the replacement list, but I did get an offer from someone who's been following the thread THAT closely. lol Waiting to hear back then we're good.

-->I'm willing to extend the deadline within reason. 2 days sound good to you all?

Vote Count

AurorusVox [2]

- Iecerint, MagnaofIllusion

LordChronos [2]

- chesskid3, ooba

mothrax [2]

- Shadow Dancer, Gemini

Iecerint [1]

- AurorusVox

Not Voting [8]

- Chronopie, AGar, AGar, Dekes, AlmasterGM, Axelrod, mothrax, LordChronos

With 15 votes in HELLFIRE, it takes

8

6 to lynch.

Deadline is Monday, May 16th, 2011, 9:00PM PST, at gandalf5166's house. Bring presents.

MagnaofIllusion is V/LA until 5/16.
Dekes is V/LA until 5/15.
Chronopie is V/LA until 5/16.
mothrax is being replaced.

Happy Birthday Iecerint!

[LordChronos]

2 days works for me.

[Shadow Dancer]

@Charon: If you can bring a replacement in immediately and if whoever it is has really followed the thread as closely as you suggest or at least can manage to do the whole 60++ page catchup business in two days, two days should easily suffice.

@AV: If you want to make yourself useful, tell us who your partners are. If you name two of them to lynch today we will wait with your lynch until D3. Promisse!

[AurorusVox]

Your partners are Iecrint and probably MoI.

SC, Iec, MoI scumteam gogogogo. Lynch me D3 instead so I can use my powerful (regular) bonanza and protect someone confirmed town, like Ooba.

[AGar]

This is about his supposed "read" of me in this game. If he's Town, he should know the point he's making is not a valid point. I think MoI is actually very smart. So I am definitely holding it against him here that he's so off base.

But you can't say it's not a scumtell by pointing to a game where scum did it.

@quadz
Pretty sure I did.

- Moi attacks Axel for waffling about people attacking him ("I may just call them scum because they're attacking me")
- Axel says MoI can't use this as a valid scumtell because MoI did the same thing in Clash of Kings
- MoI was scum in Clash of Kings

No, You're still not getting it. I did the same thing in CoK. ME. I was TOWN. MoI KNOWS This (or he ought to). But he's still attacking me for it.

Selfmeta.. badbadbadbadbad.

Your partners are Iecrint and probably MoI.

SC, Iec, MoI scumteam gogogogo. Lynch me D3 instead so I can use my powerful (regular) bonanza and protect someone confirmed town, like Ooba.

Lololololololol.

VOTE: AurousVox
VOTE: Mothrax

[AurorusVox]

Hush AGar. Ooba is confirmed town and you are not. Don't make me switch my vote to you for doubting this fact.

[AGar]

Hush AGar. Ooba is confirmed town and you are not. Don't make me switch my vote to you for doubting this fact.

You're an idiot.

[AurorusVox]

Will you lynch Iec and confirm Ooba as Greek when I flip town?

[Shadow Dancer]

Will you lynch Iec and confirm Ooba as Greek when I flip town?

Yes, if you flip town in this game I will lynch the hell out of Iec But first you flip scum, so I don't need to care about my promise.

@Agar: I still suggest you use your votes to hammer.

[MagnaofIllusion]

AV-scum continues to WIFOM it up in regards to ooba.

The noose is approaching scum ... don't worry.

In other news I'll address Axel's bad "I was Town in a single game so MoI MUST know I am Town here" argument either later tonight or early tomorrow.

[ooba]

unvote[\b] for now ..

[ooba]

Unvote

[gandalf5166]

My vote loss is not the result of my super, and the way the mod presented it to me, I think it was connected to the other thing that happened to me last night, which means that unless Chronopie essentially has two actions, he didn't take away my vote.

[Gemini]

Unvote

Two day extension is fine as long as this replacement gets here quick.

/ignore AuroraVox

[Iecerint]

I'm happy that AV decided to claim scum.

[Charon]

ConSpiracy

has replaced

mothrax

, effective now. (Much thanks and yadda-ya since I had failed to send out any form of notice.) Deadline will be moved back 48 hours, to Wednesday, May 18th, 2011, 9:00PM PST, again at gandalf5166's house. Deadline is still negotiable- within reason.

Vote Count

AurorusVox [3]

- Iecerint, MagnaofIllusion, AGar

mothrax [2]

- Shadow Dancer, AGar

LordChronos [1]

- chesskid3

Iecerint [1]

- AurorusVox

Not Voting [8]

- Chronopie, Dekes, AlmasterGM, Axelrod, mothrax, LordChronos, ooba, Gemini

With 15 votes in HELLFIRE, it takes

8

6 to lynch.

Deadline is Monday, May 16th, 2011, 9:00PM PST, at gandalf5166's house. Bring presents.

MagnaofIllusion is V/LA until 5/16.
Dekes is V/LA until 5/15.
Chronopie is V/LA until 5/16.

p.s. Also watched Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief the other day. 7/10. Not really impressed with the gods, sorry.

[ooba]

@Charon: Haven't watched the movie .. But thought books were good ..

AV - if there are really two scum teams, any info you can give us to help lynch them would be welcome. After all your team will be at a disadvantage after your lynch. Helping us helps you.

[ConSpiracy]

I am here, hi all.

Mod, can you please move the deadline one more day up?

I am very busy the next 3 days.
I may make a proper post tomorrow, however exams go first.

[Shadow Dancer]

But you're there to claim if we just waggon you up, Cons, right?

[AurorusVox]

Ooba, even if I was scum, I think it would be bad form to out anyone from the other scumteam, unless it was to my own scumbuddies to help them appear more protown.

However, I see we have a few days left so I'll read the thread when I can be motivated to, and assist our *shared* wincon by giving you solid reads to trust in when I flip town and after you've lynched Iec. If we have ANY form of a second doctor I urge you to protect Ooba as the confirmed town.

[Dekes]

Ooba, even if I was scum, I think it would be bad form to out anyone from the other scumteam,

Is this confirmation of two scum teams? Remember, outing members from a different scum team is playing to your win con, not bad form.

Can we start voting yet? The day's starting to drag. I expect Conspiracy to keep his promise by delivering his post tomorrow.