Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[ooba]

Vig me N1 then! You'll only look like an idiot when I flip town.

Why EP and not dana?

dana is a town-read for me.

[ReaperCharlie]

Do you not agree that what he said was insanely scummy?

[ReaperCharlie]

And why do you think your current scum read is scummy?

[ChannelDelibird]

Vote: Energetic Penguin

Reread will have to wait an hour or so. The vote can't.

[ReaperCharlie]

Reasoning?

[ooba]

Do you not agree that what he said was insanely scummy?

Nope (I just answered this like the last page, RC!)

Well, obviously we're (as in the town) not going to consolidate on your lynch. It's a call between between dana\ep - ep is currently null for me - but better lynching a null read than a town read.

[ReaperCharlie]

crap. I didn't realize we had a deadline looming. that changes things considerably.


...so why do you think EP is better than dana?


I personally think dana is much scummier than EP. Can I ask you to trust me and vote dana instead?

[ReaperCharlie]

Also, if the scum team is MoS/MBF/Magua or something similar, they should have an easy time lurking through the game, while at the same time never being in too much danger of being lynched. I am going to push for one of them to be lynched tomorrow (not necessarily Magua, but the other two). They are shifty and I'm gonna rip them a new one.

Also, once dana flips we get that much more info out of him than if he were left alive. Conversely, if EP flips, we get next to nothing, and scummy-dana is still alive, whether or not he's actually SCUM (which I believe he is). Consider that in your calculations of who to lynch, ooba.

[PeregrineV]

Last re-reads are
Rag- first 38 posts are one-liners or individual interaction respones. More fully developed posts don't arrive until 38. Then there are a few and it trickles back down. Null to slight scummy.

ReaperCharlie- Big push for an alliance, but it's currently made up of 2. Slight town for now.

Thor- Seems town, but for Thor there is a bit less interaction than I normally expect from him. That takes him from a hard town to soft town. And total Thor beard intimidation tactics? Current count= 0. Even more odd. Going down to null, with quick potential to move either way.

[PeregrineV]

Unofficial vote count, deadline in about 8 hours.

danakillsu (4): PeregrineV, mikeburnfire, ReaperCharlie, Mastermind of Sin
ReaperCharlie (1): MarchHare
mikeburnfire (1): danakillsu
Energetic Penguin (5): Magua, Thor665, Ragnarokio, ooba, ChannelDelibird

Not voting (2) : Energetic Penguin, Ant_to_the_max

[Mastermind of Sin]

I still don't see what the case on EP is. dana's post about jumping on the EP wagon was pretty scummy, which is somewhat of a town tell for EP in my book.

[ReaperCharlie]

What does everyone think of Ant_to_the_max?

[ChannelDelibird]

That reread might not be able to happen tonight after all, I'm afraid. Apologies for not getting it done while it was still looking like a straight choice between Ragna and EP.

MoS is still wrong on that dana post, I hope RC has changed his mind on it now that he realises the deadline is about to hit.

I've already said what I think of Ant.

[ReaperCharlie]

I think CDB may be scum too.

[ChannelDelibird]

So you've mentioned.

[mothrax]

Deadline will be extended by 24 hours since I won't be around to do anything tonight.

[Mastermind of Sin]

The only thing I don't like about Ant this game is how much his vote has bounced around. I'm pretty sure he's voted half the people who aren't him by this point.

I also noticed that he makes a lot of huge wall posts, which is not inherently town or scummy, but a lot of the time it is an alignment-based playstyle thing, though. I am not really familiar with him. Does Ant usually bounce his votes around and make a lot of huge wall posts when he is town?

[Ant_to_the_max]

*psst*
I have only played town, so...yes
real post coming next

[Mastermind of Sin]

Went back and looked at EP. His early game seemed fine, the only thing I took issue with was him trying to lump me and MBF together in his attacks, the rest of it is probably just playstyle differences between us.

I also don't like this response:

That's a safe bet, RC.

In other news, I just looked at the player list and was surprised to see someone I did not even realize was playing this game. Then I went back and looked at his posts, and I saw my definition of active lurking.

Unvote, Vote: animorpherv1

Stop pretending to contribute!

Nice Hypocrisy scum.

Not only does this seem to be an easy response to make (I'd expect town to be a bit more forthcoming about

why

they have a problem with my vote), but it's also categorically wrong. For my vote on animorpherv to be hypocrisy, I would have to have been pretending to contribute. EP, are you arguing that my early posting in this game was intended to look like contribution?

Also, not particularly happy that EP has suddenly disappeared right as deadline approached.

Still, more happy with my dana vote right now, though.

[Ant_to_the_max]

I find it suspicious that dana only has one suspect in this entire game.

Yeah, that is not true at all

• Ragnarokio - weak fluff argument but still.
• MarchHare - tried to build a case
• PeregrineV - more stuffz
• mikeburnfire - oh hey! look, we finally got here

And he has also rubbed up against others like RC, so I really feel like this is trying to set dana up here.

My point is that if he's going to compromise, it should be someone he at least slightly thinks is scum. I find it hard to believe that he has one guy he thinks is SUPER scummy and no one else between that an "null tell".

nononononononononononononononononononononononononono
Ok, so what if he compromises for his second scum pick, who doesn't have any votes on them right now? How does that help the town?

Also, once dana flips we get that much more info out of him than if he were left alive. Conversely, if EP flips, we get next to nothing, and scummy-dana is still alive, whether or not he's actually SCUM (which I believe he is). Consider that in your calculations of who to lynch, ooba.

You have a point, but I see things from the opposite. If he flips town, I think MoS and ooba should be looked into tomorrow. I know it is probably to late for wagons on them and out of dana and EP I will vote dana. Honestly I get the same feel from EP as I did last game.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I find it suspicious that dana only has one suspect in this entire game.

Yeah, that is not true at all

• Ragnarokio - weak fluff argument but still.
• MarchHare - tried to build a case
• PeregrineV - more stuffz
• mikeburnfire - oh hey! look, we finally got here

And he has also rubbed up against others like RC, so I really feel like this is trying to set dana up here.

Reread that statement. Here's what I did not say:

I find it suspicious that dana has only had one suspect in this entire game.

Here's what I *did* say:

I find it suspicious that dana only has one suspect in this entire game.

There is a clear difference in meaning between those two statements, but you are acting as if I said the first version. Nowhere did I claim that dana has been zoning in on the same person all game, so don't put those words in my mouth.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Last Post (all times CST):

danakillsu - Thurs, 11:22 am
Channeldelibird - Thurs, 3:44 pm
Ant_to_the_max - Thurs, 11:23 pm
PerigrineV - Thurs, 2:51 pm
Mastermind of Sin - Now

Thor665 - Wed, 3:22 pm

mikeburnfire - Thurs, 5:45 pm
Ragnarokio - Thurs, 7:18 am

Energetic Penguin - Tues, 9:57 am

ReaperCharlie - Thurs, 3:33 pm
ooba - Thurs, 1:23 pm
Magua - Thurs, 10:50 am

MarchHare - Sun, 2:58 am

Some people are suspiciously missing close to deadline...

Fucking Christ, I have no motivation these days.

Will post tomorrow.

Mod: Please replace MarchHare.

The prod deadline is 48 hours, and it's been nearly 5 days now...

[Ant_to_the_max]

Very true. Missread on my part. My second point is still valid though I think.

[ReaperCharlie]

Last Post (all times CST):

danakillsu - Thurs, 11:22 am
Channeldelibird - Thurs, 3:44 pm
Ant_to_the_max - Thurs, 11:23 pm
PerigrineV - Thurs, 2:51 pm
Mastermind of Sin - Now

Thor665 - Wed, 3:22 pm

mikeburnfire - Thurs, 5:45 pm
Ragnarokio - Thurs, 7:18 am

Energetic Penguin - Tues, 9:57 am

ReaperCharlie - Thurs, 3:33 pm
ooba - Thurs, 1:23 pm
Magua - Thurs, 10:50 am

MarchHare - Sun, 2:58 am

Some people are suspiciously missing close to deadline...

Fucking Christ, I have no motivation these days.

Will post tomorrow.

Mod: Please replace MarchHare.

The prod deadline is 48 hours, and it's been nearly 5 days now...

The fact that you are asking this is hilarious.

The irony is not lost on me.

[Magua]

Unofficial vote count

danakillsu (4): PerigrineV, mikeburnfire, ReaperCharlie, Mastermind of Sin
Energetic Penguin (5): Magua, Thor665, Ragnarokio, ooba, Channeldelibird
ReaperCharlie (1): MarchHare
mikeburnfire (1): danakillsu

Not voting (2): Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin

Less than 12 hours until deadline.