smargaret wrote:Baby Spice wrote:
Since Ani wasn't in that game, chances are good he got a role from it, firefighter being such an unusual thing. ie: The reason he knows of ifirefighter is most probably receiving a role from the game it was in.
Can you explain this a little more? Why do you think Ani is more likely to have received a role from a game he wasn't in, since roles are theoretically assigned randomly?
Well, if it was a fake claim, how would he have known about the role? Sure he could have crawled through SC's wiki and found roles, but as someone said if that was the case why claim what is in effect a limited doc, why not a real doc. Remember he was at L-1 and a likely lynch.
Since it's unlikely he chose the role by pure brute searching, logically he must actually have a role that was in that game, and again, if he was going to fake claim, why that one. Especially when we had a fire type kill N1 (Napalmed)
Now TS.
Twistedspoon wrote:
too willing to believe claims Imo
I've already talked about looking things up and doing the research behind the claims so far, this this first 'reason' in bunk. Or perhaps you are referring to TL's claim, which since I voted for him at the time, would kind of indicate that I didn't believe that one too easily either.
Twistedspoon wrote:now that ani's claimed and quoted, Baby Spice is the most suspicious of those not on the Jindori wagon
If anything she tries to protect our pal Jindori
Two parts here. First, since you seem to believe Ani's claim now (Otherwise why shift your vote) how do you explain that it was largely my comments on it that made it believable?
Secondly, in what way do I try to protect your pal? I've said before that I don't like policy lynches, nor rapid lynches (The time that comes to mind I can't quote, live game)
Twistedspoon wrote:I never said I believed ani's claim did I?
I just don't think he should be today's lynch over yourself
So you don't believe Ani's claim, which means you think he's obv scum and are not voting for him? Instead you try to start a wagon on someone else. Remind me why you are voting me again? That's right:
Twistedspoon wrote:Amrun wrote:
What IS your case on babyspice? It seems like you can't decide.
didn't vote obvscum jin
sorta objected to his lynch too
Now, I admit I'm known for thinking differently to what people might call normal, but that looks like you're voting me using the same logic you said I was using. Your calling me scummy whilst doing the same thing that you call scummy.
Twistedspoon wrote:Baby Spice wrote:
Neither did you. VOTE:
1) I did. He was scum and I would have voted him whatever
2) just because i (supposedly) didn't doesn't clear you
Twistedspoon wrote:jindori wrote:Lol same as me i was trying a slayers gambit in my game with twisted spoon (It's over so you can look into it.).
yeah, were you the one who hammered me, cop, page 5 without letting me claim?
this player is a true hazard to the town
VOTE: Jindori
jindori wrote:The info was not useless. I just didn't understand which game you were talking about. I want to know what your talking about Thank you.
Unvote vote jindori
Meh i'm not important anyway and a policy lynch on me might help find scum.
self-voting is a scum tactic to appear less important and humble and other such nonsense
We have a vote for a reason outside of the game, that at best can be called policy. Then called something a scum tactic as an added extra.
Now if you actually thought he was scummy, you would not have started with the policy bit would you? If this was really a policy vote I doubt you would have called the self voting scummy. Your vote here is a foot in both camps. Pointing out something vaguely scummy in case Jin was lynched, and laying a policy foundation so you can walk away if the wagon folded.
The key point here though, is that you never called Jin obvscum until after the flip.
This vote of yours is pure bussing.
Strong evidence of Bussing. Strong evidence of trying to force false cases. Ignoring questions. Bad logic.
Twisted spoon is scum, and the sooner we lynch him the sooner we can find his buddies.
Bobsnox, why are you sheeping so badly? More to the point, why are you sheeping scum? I would love to try and show why you're vote is wrong, but it's kind of hard when you give absolutely no reason whatsoever. Indeed, you only mention me once.
Bobsnox wrote:VOTE: Baby Spice
Surye, firstly, I'm having trouble even with the high school french (in the 1980's) and google translate but.
Baby Spice, on the other hand, commented on the wagon. Trying to slow it down
WTF and an (incorrect as it turned out) vote count is not much to base a vote on nor is it much of a comment, and as I've said, I don't like rushed lynches, rushed policy lynches.
His odds on TS is not a contradiction. This is a false attack.
Please explain.
TS makes a random seeming vote with some rubbish reason, I ask if he wants to try justify his random seaming vote again, he says no, then he tries to re-justify his random seeming vote with some more rubbish reason.
That is pure contradiction on his part.
His two addresses to its car are rubbish, I do not like his "political lynching" push on any lynching scum boyfriend. Lynch was a good, if not too fast, but he was on obvscum. She tried to derail it last minute, could not, and limiting the damage.
Please show how "this player is a true hazard to the town" as the basis for a vote is not policy?
Please show where you, or TS, thought jin was obvscum, before the flip.
Please show how I sought to derail the lynch at the last minute?
You can't.
Oh, and Surye, please quote your role PM because the only french post restricted role I can find linked to SC was a greek mafia goon in SWN II. (Ani and Parama were in that game too it seems)
Empking wrote:Vote: BS
- (excluding myself) I think BS comes out the worst of the not-voters and I don't like his recent post at all.
Care to explain why, address anything.
Of the not voters, I'd personally look at anyone who hadn't posted. My, limited, experience says that any scum not voting would have not posted to avoid the whole thing. Otherwise I'd look for bussing, oh hello TS and his amazing bus post..
