I'm too tired to finish my response to Plum, so before I go to bed, I'll just summarize my inchoate reads.
hitogoroshi, you've seen Faraday as scum before, right? Do you think he casts unexplained votes more often as town? See, from some players, I'd understand your POV that it might draw attention to them, but this is a complete null tell with Faraday.
I don't like that my reasons for my hito vote have changed since I cast it, but I'm still uneasy with him. I find hito sometimes has odd theories as town, but I still REALLY dislike his back-and-forth with AGM trying to paint him as scummy for a role decision. I agree that mothrax wasn't the number one choice, but the bickering in this topic has proven that AGM and mothrax have bad blood together. It's not as though NS is SOOOOOOO much better that anyone who DIDN'T choose him is obvNSbuddy.
Duplicity's two posts felt like wishy-washy passionless scum filler. Also, boo for parroting hito on his AGM point. Might move our vote there, although it feels a bit easy.
Okay with the quadz wagon, but I might be biased because he, Seraphim and Plum are all scum for voting for me.
People piled on him quickly, so I'll look elsewhere for now.
Nikanor already discussed our read of AGM. And I'm certain that AGM didn't make up the idea of his role, at least. Just to nitpick: I'm considering a mothrax lynch unless I get a stronger town read on him. From my PoV, AGM vigged mothrax on N0, and we have the choice of stopping or allowing the kill.
My other head thinks Seraphim is scum, but I'm more null on him. I didn't get what Seraphim was driving at re: domains, so I missed why everyone is convinced he's obvtown. Will be very interested to see his posts tomorrow.
Meh, I'm sure there's someone I'm forgetting, but this is long enough.
quadz08 wrote:However, NM's recent post solidifies my position on them. Vote stays for now.
Ugh, I hate it when people go, "Yeah, X's recent post totally solidifies my confirmation bias" without explaining why
particularly when X is me
.
Your position on us was that we were asking an obvious question for town cred. That was a fair enough attack early in the game (although easy, since I was already drawing heat). But the post you said solidified your read was basically just me questioning Faraday. Um...
what
?
Hey, singersigner, when you get back here, I'd be interested in hearing
your
read on quadz. You know why I'm asking this.
Faraday wrote:Although I guess I don't see Mina-scum asking the question about Evil Aligned players. But then your refusing to answer my question is scummy. I dunno.
This is also to Plum, but are you saying you expected a serious answer to that question? I'm just curious, how do you think scum would react to that question, and how would town react?
If it makes you happy,
no
. I'm not scum. I feel ridiculous for even posting that.
Had something for Equinox here, but she's looking very town now, so I'll drop her off the Players to Aggressively Spam With Questions List. Won't list my other town reads.
-Mina