Battle for Olympus - Game Over!

[AGar]

The fact that he can only be scum if he's the SK doesn't mean he's not scum. What you guys are doing is essentially AtP.

No that’s not happening. At all. Do

YOU

know what an Appeal to Probability is? An Appeal to Probability is saying “The odds that the Town Cop scanned a Miller Day 1 and a Godfather Day 2 are so slim it couldn’t have happened!!!” (taken directly from a game situation.?

You are shouting “SD’s reaction means he is a Serial Killer”.

Everyone is effectively saying “No, it means he may be a 3rd party role”

Do you have anything that indicates that a Serial Killer must be in the set-up other than your gut?

If the answer is No then don’t bother banging that drum again. No-one is really going to care until there is more to go on.

Isn't there some ridiculous tell where early signs of SK hunting probably lead to an SK?

---

L-2 if I've counted right ..

Claim time !!

L-2 = claim time?

Since when?

Barely any difference between L-2 and L-1 in a large game on D1 .. Saves time and speeds up things ..

L-1 should not equal auto-claim, in any game.

L-1 with intent to hammer is when claims should be rising out of the woodwork. There is plenty to be gained from a wagon that steams ahead to L-1 without a claim, it just takes a bit more of a brain than half the people here care to use it seems. Considering there is a competing wagon on diddin, and there are other suspicions flying around similarly, there is no reason to demand a claim at L-2. (BS is at L-1 now, for those keeping score at home).

[MagnaofIllusion]

Isn't there some ridiculous tell where early signs of SK hunting probably lead to an SK?

Not sure about that. My understanding is present thinking runs along the following lines – early game SK hunting as opposed to Mafia hunting is more likely to come from Mafia than Town. Something about not wanting to be worried about a wild-card killing your team off.

[AGar]

Hm.

Problem is I think Gandalf is way too stupid to be scum AND have no votes on him by opportunistic bussing buddies, y'know?

[gandalf5166]

Isn't there some ridiculous tell where early signs of SK hunting probably lead to an SK?

Not sure about that. My understanding is present thinking runs along the following lines – early game SK hunting as opposed to Mafia hunting is more likely to come from Mafia than Town. Something about not wanting to be worried about a wild-card killing your team off.

This is true. ITS ALSO TRUE THAT IF WE LYNCH AN SK WE GET RID OF ONE KILL PER NIGHT

SOMETHING THAT WOULD USUALLY TAKE 3-4 CORRECT LYNCHES

[AGar]

Isn't there some ridiculous tell where early signs of SK hunting probably lead to an SK?

Not sure about that. My understanding is present thinking runs along the following lines – early game SK hunting as opposed to Mafia hunting is more likely to come from Mafia than Town. Something about not wanting to be worried about a wild-card killing your team off.

This is true. ITS ALSO TRUE THAT IF WE LYNCH AN SK WE GET RID OF ONE KILL PER NIGHT

SOMETHING THAT WOULD USUALLY TAKE 3-4 CORRECT LYNCHES

HOW DO YOU KNOW HE'S SK?

HOW ARE YOU SO SURE?

[gandalf5166]

Isn't there some ridiculous tell where early signs of SK hunting probably lead to an SK?

Not sure about that. My understanding is present thinking runs along the following lines – early game SK hunting as opposed to Mafia hunting is more likely to come from Mafia than Town. Something about not wanting to be worried about a wild-card killing your team off.

This is true. ITS ALSO TRUE THAT IF WE LYNCH AN SK WE GET RID OF ONE KILL PER NIGHT

SOMETHING THAT WOULD USUALLY TAKE 3-4 CORRECT LYNCHES

HOW DO YOU KNOW HE'S SK?

HOW ARE YOU SO SURE?

BECAUSE

HIS ACTIONS MAKE NO SENSE FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF ANYONE WHO CAN STILL WIN AFTER THEY DIE

AND HIS "HURR DURR WHAT IF I CALIMED SURVIVOR" CONFIRMS THAT THATS NOT IT

SO HES EITHER SK OR SOME OTHER WEIRD THIRD PARTY THAT WORKS WEIRD

[Shadow Dancer]

Gandalf, for the last time: I am not an an SK. And your damn insistence on that paranoia does not make half the sense you want it to. Blind setup speculations before even N1 has happened are as useful as a wiper on a submarine.
And even if you really believe that stuff you're excreting all the time you should have realized that a me lynch is out of question and that there are actual scum in this game that you should care for.

[gandalf5166]

Gandalf, for the last time: I am not an an SK. And your damn insistence on that paranoia does not make half the sense you want it to. Blind setup speculations before even N1 has happened are as useful as a wiper on a submarine.
And even if you really believe that stuff you're excreting all the time you should have realized that a me lynch is out of question and that there are actual scum in this game that you should care for.

You are fucking scum of some fucking type. There is no way that your posts are coming from town. I don't give a shit if there's only one kill tonight. Maybe you're a lyncher, or you have some mechanic related goal(Gollum, anybody?), but you ARE FUCKING SCUM.

[ooba]

Gandalf, for the last time: I am not an an SK. And your damn insistence on that paranoia does not make half the sense you want it to. Blind setup speculations before even N1 has happened are as useful as a wiper on a submarine.
And even if you really believe that stuff you're excreting all the time you should have realized that a me lynch is out of question and that there are actual scum in this game that you should care for.

You are fucking scum of some fucking type. There is no way that your posts are coming from town. I don't give a shit if there's only one kill tonight. Maybe you're a lyncher, or you have some mechanic related goal(Gollum, anybody?), but you ARE FUCKING SCUM.

- Given the fact that SD is under so much scrutiny right now, there's no way that he'd survive till the end of the game as third party
- He constantly keeps hinting that his super will confirm his town status in some way so lets see how that pans out
- You've made your point - By harping more on SD (a lynch which is not going to happen on D1), all you're doing is distracting us from figuring out who we need to lynch now ..

[Baby Spice]

QFT.

But since MoI seems to be keen to retroactively change what his beef was about, and incapable of reading threads ...

With something like two or three pages preceeding refering to LC as Chronos, it is an easy mistake to make. Especially as at least one other has admitted to making it.



Iec. SA3 is a bad example to quote.
In that game I was trying to be a lead wagon a lot of the time, without being lynched, so the cult team had a chance at grave dust as if you remember the town wanted the leading wagons to do the grave robbing.
What should be mentioned/investigated is the difference in MoI from that game to this one. In SA3 he was town.


Oh, for Plums benifit, my role name is in different colours. Many different colours.
Iris, goddess of rainbows.

(Oh, my role PM had a correction sent to me, specifically adding that I was aligned with the greek pantheon. I assumed being a greed goddess that I was anyway and never questioned or noticed that the line was missing. Combine that with SD's reaction to Charon's message and SD is def not town.)

[Iecerint]

Wasn't he planning to go Murderer in SA3? I remember him having funny insanities when he was lynched.

Nothing wrong with the name claim.

[ooba]

Oh, for Plums benifit, my role name is in different colours. Many different colours.
Iris, goddess of rainbows.

I like the multicolored role name bit .. Normal power please ..

[chesskid3]

Oh, for Plums benifit, my role name is in different colours. Many different colours.
Iris, goddess of rainbows.

I like the multicolored role name bit .. Normal power please ..

I don't see how that's going to help.

BS is obv town can we like not force a whole bunch of claims today kthx?

[chesskid3]

Also can we get a replacmeent for RoTN lastpost 6days ago?

[quadz08]

You are fucking scum of some fucking type. There is no way that your posts are coming from town. I don't give a shit if there's only one kill tonight. Maybe you're a lyncher, or you have some mechanic related goal(Gollum, anybody?), but you ARE FUCKING SCUM.

- Given the fact that SD is under so much scrutiny right now, there's no way that he'd survive till the end of the game as third party
- He constantly keeps hinting that his super will confirm his town status in some way so lets see how that pans out
- You've made your point - By harping more on SD (a lynch which is not going to happen on D1), all you're doing is distracting us from figuring out who we need to lynch now ..

QFT. Seriously. Shut up, Gandalf.

Also, what ooba said (again) about BS' claim. I want to hear her normal power.

[Iecerint]

I think BS looks pretty good unless the fakeclaims in this game come in the form of "full" PM fakeclaims. That, or BS is a clever enough scum that I'd be willing to let her live a few days on principle.

Do we know scum daytalk status? That would be a significant interfering factor.

[Iecerint]

II) All groups with Quicktopics (QTs) will be able to converse during the NP.

It looks like the rules imply no.

[Shadow Dancer]

(Oh, my role PM had a correction sent to me, specifically adding that I was aligned with the greek pantheon. I assumed being a greed goddess that I was anyway and never questioned or noticed that the line was missing. Combine that with SD's reaction to Charon's message and SD is def not town.)

I am just curious: What does Charon supposedly forgeting a line your role PM have to do with my reaction on his rule change and my reaction to it leading you to the conclusion I was not town?

[quadz08]

I don't see how that's going to help.

BS is obv town can we like not force a whole bunch of claims today kthx?

No.

I think BS looks pretty good unless the fakeclaims in this game come in the form of "full" PM fakeclaims. That, or BS is a clever enough scum that I'd be willing to let her live a few days on principle.

Fuck no.

I am just curious: What does Charon supposedly forgeting a line your role PM have to do with my reaction on his rule change and my reaction to it leading you to the conclusion I was not town?

Surprisingly, yes.

[chesskid3]

Unvote

Vote: Quadz

Hey Ieceeeeeeeeeee

[AGar]

Unvote

Vote: Quadz

Hey Ieceeeeeeeeeee

No.

And no, BS isn't "obvtown." I want to see her active as well.

[diddin]

Although --

diddin, is there a reason you identified several people as scummy-by-way-of-dekes, but never really pressured dekes himself?

I feel that the people who sheeped Dekes are more likely to be scum than Dekes himself.

BS needs to power claim.

[chesskid3]

What is a power claim going to do for you

what if she claims
tracker
watcher
cop
1-shot bp
neighborizer

what good does it do

ITS A NO VANILLA GAME FOJIDSIFJIODFJISDFJSODIFJSIOFJSFODSIFJSDF

[LordChronos]

I think BS looks pretty good unless the fakeclaims in this game come in the form of "full" PM fakeclaims. That, or BS is a clever enough scum that I'd be willing to let her live a few days on principle.

Do we know scum daytalk status? That would be a significant interfering factor.

Why does the Iris name claim make her not scum exactly?

[Iecerint]

Your word is my command.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Quadz

Now I will iso quadz.