Ok i`m finally caught up:
list (in order from scum to town):
Amrun: a lot of '
no i didn`t
' isn`t giving a good feel (however this can be the 'just an easy lynch'-part)
things that i do consider relevant though:
- You used the 'why are we both on the scumlist if we`re not both scum' quite often for someone who agrees on the 1-1-tradeoff is a good thing.
- can`t find the clues you left to RC (and scum), care to explain?
- this:
Amrun wrote:That updated read post bumped smarg up to my #1 scumread, to me implying she knows I will flip town, and at the very least, backing away from her "distancing" theory, her only assertion in the game.
That is rich coming from you, though, Grey. Your more subdued aggression is making me doubt you, but my scumread on me smarg makes you town for now.
P-edit: so it's possible I'm town, now?
- missed the corresponding 'if'?
- How does Smargaret-scum result in GreyICE-town?
- Why do you consider GI town based on the above, only a day after you agreed on 1-1 tradeoffs being a good thing?
Chrono: nothing to add on this matter. Opening post was good, rest is terrible: last chance call seconded (don`t expect it will convince enough people though)
I do have 1 'setup speculation'-question: your assumption- the mafia`s power lies in the number of time-machines is based on 'what'? (i don`t see how having more timemachines makes the mafia that much stronger)
The rest of this 'probable semi-last chance' should probably not be setup-based.
GreyICE: Doesn`t provide much reason behind his reads.
Quite actively avoids giving them actually ('page 4 bookmark it','i have my reasons').
against putting TvS on top 2 (to the point where dayvigging those who disagree becomes an argument).
The point of 'how was it preplanned', is also quite weird as the conflict started in confirmation phase a full day before the actual start of the game.
between 'the joke that started it all' and the actual start of the game, amrun posted 9 times, Kcda 12: it didn`t have to be preplanned.
The last reason to not nominate Amrun/Kcda strikes me as off.
Although the reason is quite good, it does provide a way to keep the biggest discussion completely out of the vote + if getting content out of everyone was the objective, this argument should have been made around game-start.
The 'if all suspects are easy lynches: check again' argument had me sold on town-greyice earlier: but now i`ll have to agree on 'scum with Amrun/Kcda' is a reasonable possibility
KcdaSpot:
Attacking GreyICE for defending him and Amrun, while he`s been going by that defence for uhm... the entire game.
Why?
Ranger:I liked the RQS-shootdown, didn`t see that much else to comment on
The late 'hop on the wagon'(while under pressure) perhaps.
Tragedy: hard to read, some strange choices of words. very small scum-read.
e.g. #65 poor town.
Doombunny: My issues with the RQS are already pretty clear.
However the responses to 'my case', i liked:
- no attempts to ignore the point completely (which is quite easy to do when 'up against' a poster as frequent as myself (i`ll do better from now on) )
- didn`t get a scum-vibe from the 'reactions under pressure'.
RedCoyote: I like the structured aproach and the 'not letting go @ Amrun', the 'burden of hving a title to your name' however makes me want to 'relocate' the null-bar.
Pushing mist towards replacement on the other hand does this (scum would want a townie or 2 not paying attention at all). unless (mist)imag flips scum RC is town to me
Mist:hard(near impossible) to read + Imaginality: the biggest thing to go on is his opening-list, i might get into that list later, but the smargaret-read caught my eye:
- The 'in reading the thread- not looking so good': true (at least true enough to leave as a mislynch), going into iso to clear a (non-obvious potential) mislynch, is not something i would consider pro-scum. So far I like
Smargarat: very little to add here
only the flip-clarification-request:
If that was role-specific, the question would probably have been asked by PM, to scum 'info upon death' is always role-specific. Leaning town.
Ghostwriter: Active hunting + not afraid to admit he`s willing to lynch town for the greater good
Exe:
well what`s there to say?
doesn`t do distractions.
does do scumhunting.
************************************
@Kcdaspot: so you`re considering me scum because i`m not as active a rolefisher as i was in web?
@imaginary:
what`s inconsistent about:
- We have to be carefull with our votes, due to timetraveling scum, these situations (al be it incorrect due to not having completely understood the rules yet) should be avoided.
- If we list all dead(confirmed) mafia on top of every list, we are somewhat protected against mafia-revival tricks.
- Those nominated only have 1 post, this shouldn`t be wasted
calling one of these 3 (in this order, shortly after each other), more likely to be joining in for town-credit?
@GW, i wish, it`s so we can`t redo the days.
By the way, your mum says hello.
