Reckamonic's WoW Mafia (Over)

[GreyICE]

@iPie, Masons, what do you think of Arthas? Between Arthas and GreyIce, one of the two 100% has to be culted/cult-recruiter. Which of the two, if not both, do you think is more likely to be cult-aligned?

i'm way too fucking tired to do this right now

why the fuck is one of the two of us guaranteed cult exactly?

don't fucking quote a page long thing
no more than a fucking paragraph

Well of course the cult doesn't think it's cult, LOLOLOL

[InflatablePie]

You're being thrown off by stupid breadcrumbs that anyone could fake. It's ridiculous, and you're being utterly deceived. Who is the Cult Recruiter if not Katsuki? Arthas? No, he's just a minion, or a recruit who keeps his powers. So who else could it be?

But in the first few pages of the game? Just a few hours after the thread had opened up? True, it's possible (assuming Kats-CL) the mods gave Kats a fakeclaim with the role PM. But I'm not seeing it.

To be honest I'm suspicious about everyone except my Masonbuddy.

If it's not you, Kats or Arthas... Krazy is possible, but he claimed the Fateshot and no one CC'd. Obviously Fonz was Exilon's kill, as per his fakeclaim...

I'm not comfortable with lynching Kats because of the extremely early breadcrumb. Sub/Bunny/AGar... one of them may be cult, but I doubt any of them are the leader. Leader has to be in Krazy/Arthas/Grey via process of elimination.

If Krazy's untouchable... well, see: his question to me.

I'm leaning towards Arthas-CL, tbh, but I dunno for sure.

[InflatablePie]

I have a crazy theory I want to discuss with AKR in private before I reveal my insanity in here, btw.

[gandalf5166]

Exilon flipped MULTIkiller. i.e. he would have had multiple kills.

[GreyICE]

You're being thrown off by stupid breadcrumbs that anyone could fake. It's ridiculous, and you're being utterly deceived. Who is the Cult Recruiter if not Katsuki? Arthas? No, he's just a minion, or a recruit who keeps his powers. So who else could it be?

But in the first few pages of the game? Just a few hours after the thread had opened up? True, it's possible (assuming Kats-CL) the mods gave Kats a fakeclaim with the role PM. But I'm not seeing it.

To be honest I'm suspicious about everyone except my Masonbuddy.

If it's not you, Kats or Arthas... Krazy is possible, but he claimed the Fateshot and no one CC'd. Obviously Fonz was Exilon's kill, as per his fakeclaim...

I'm not comfortable with lynching Kats because of the extremely early breadcrumb. Sub/Bunny/AGar... one of them may be cult, but I doubt any of them are the leader. Leader has to be in Krazy/Arthas/Grey via process of elimination.

If Krazy's untouchable... well, see: his question to me.

I'm leaning towards Arthas-CL, tbh, but I dunno for sure.

Okay, that makes sense to me.

Unvote

Vote: Arthas

[Krazy]

Arthas, it has to be between you and GreyIce, because of GreyIce's claim that they tracked you for no result, and that you claim to have roleblocked me. This is a cross-claim, and thus one of the two of you, at least, must either be culted or CL.

___[The above was Arthas's requested one paragraph]____

The problem with Arthas-cult, GreyIce-town, is that then:

-either Arthas retained his roleblock ability after becoming cult, and roleblocked GreyIce as a culted
or
-GreyIce successfully tracked Arthas, and he had no night ability because he's been culted.

Both scenarios suggest that if Arthas is the cult, he is Culted, and not Cult Recruiter.

The only scenario wherein Arthas can be Cult Recruiter, is one in which both GreyIce and Arthas are cult, in which case Arthas is CR and GreyIce is recruited. Honestly, why they would then cross-each other today makes no sense to me, because this suggests Katsuki is also really a troll, which would mean there are 4 non-recruitables (both masons, Kats, myself). Wouldn't that nearly be cult auto-loss?

This pretty much leads me to believe it has to be:
-Kats as CR with recruited Arthas [liking this one the most, personally], the main problem here is that it 100% requires Kats to have received a fake-claim from the mod.
-GreyIce as CR with recruited... someone? I have no idea who GI's recruits would be, honestly. There isn't really a problem with this, but if this scenario is true, then there are only 2 cults and we can afford a mislynch anyway, because I seriously doubt, at this point, that Arthas and GI are culted together.

or one of these extremely improbable scenarios:
-Substrike as CR with a bus on D4... and a uncc'd fakeclaim that makes a hell of a lot of sense... this scenario seems close to 0% likelihood.
-Masons being recruited would have required the mason having been culted early on, which would also require Substrike being culted early on since he copped iPie. This would mean: Substrike, and both masons are recruited, and vezok died. Since there still has to be cult between GreyIce and Arthas, I think that this scenario is 100% impossible for about a half a dozen reasons, largely due it requiring there to be too many cults in too short a period of time between days 1-3, on top of some truly ridiculous luck in terms of culting masons.
-Bunnylover, and the save on Tragedy D-whatever being completely fucking mysterious.
-Me as CR, and Fate dying from who the fuck knows what.
-AGar as CR, and he just happens to also have a vig ability. LOLNO

[Krazy]

EBWOP: "Honestly, why they would then cross-each other today makes no sense to me, because this suggests Katsuki is also really a

night-elf

, which would mean there are 4 non-recruitables (both masons, Kats, myself)." Sorry, I keep thinking of night-elves as alliance trolls.

[Arthas]

wait
greyice tracked us when
last night?
and got no result?

[GreyICE]

Which is why I know you roleblocked me.

[Arthas]

except you know

YOUR PREDECESOR CLAIMED TO BE TARGETED BY MAGIC NIGHTS 1 AND 2 AND GET NO RESULTS WHEN WE ROLEBLOCKED HIM

EXCEPT NOW YOU GET NO RESULT BUT WERE'NT TARGETED?
I
DONT
FUCKING
THINK
SO

unvote

VOTE: GREYICESUCMMMMMMMMMMM

[Substrike22]

That and the fact that the mechanic in the game you linked is 100% fucking different from what GI indicated in that post I quoted earlier. GI seemed to imply that the cult has a choice this game, in the zombeh game the zombehs simply got the ability to NK after the CR was dead. 1 =/= 2. Sorry.

Moar votes on GI people. Nedz lynch.

[Substrike22]

And yes I read most of that game. More like skimmed it but I got the general principle.

[Krazy]

GreyIce, who did you track last night again?

[GreyICE]

Haha, oh I'm sorry, I tracked RayFrost.

[Arthas]

youre a fucking dumbass

[GreyICE]

Sorry, I meant Krazy. I forgot because I was roleblocked.

[Arthas]

unvote

this is greyice jestering it up in thread to get lynched as cult recruit

>_>

[Reckamonic]

Plushie: "I feel like stabbing people!"
Big Daddy: "o...k..."

GreyICE (1): Substrike22
Arthas (1): GreyICE

Not voting: Krazy, Bunnylover, Katsuki, InflatablePie, AGar, AKnottedRope, Arthas

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

[GreyICE]

I have no idea what you're talking about.

[Krazy]

But would a recruit be so obvious about jestering it up? I'm actually starting to think GI is super-desperate recruiter doing anything he can to get another recruit in tonight so it's at least conceivably possible there's a cult-win.

GreyIce:

If you are the recruiter, you will get one recruit in tonight. Saying we mislynch Kats today, and you are the CR, this would mean that tomorrow, there are exactly three culteds. There will also be three confirmed non-cult: both masons and myself. Also, if Kats should flip town, and Arthas is town, he will roleblock you. This means there will be 2 cult recruits: vs. 3 confirmed unrecruited town. This is cult auto-loss.

All that being said:

GreyIce, would you like to concede?

[GreyICE]

Vote: Reckamonic

[Arthas]

Greyice
in walking dead
"I'll try and work on that one.

If she doesn't, she's scum, if I role claim jester tomorrow, I'm scum. It'll be playing to my win condition somehow."
blahblahb if iget recruited i'll jester it up to get lynched and it's still PtW

blah blahblah

no krazy
greyice is recruit not recuirter

[Krazy]

GreyIce, please confirm your cult recruiter roleclaim

[GreyICE]

The fools believe they have a plan
That I would be less obvious
My machinations are my strength
My minions are everywhere.

They storm my frozen slopes wishing to slay me, only to learn that the difference between opposing me and joining me is razor thin. Soon, they shall come to understand that logic and reasoning are meaningless in the icy grip of madness. Soon, they will learn that nothing is as it seems. As they fight and turn on themselves I shall watch, and laugh, from this Frozen Throne. None dare to oppose me. None dare to destroy me. For in doing so they would merely doom themselves.

Let this be your first lesson: I have no love for you or your people. On the contrary, I intend to scour humanity from this planet, and make no mistake: I have the power to do it.

[Krazy]

That's great and all GreyIce but how exactly did you get the no-result from Exilon on N3?