Time Travel Mafia (Game Over)

[Amrun]

So? I have him as null leaning scum. I see no lynchable offenses there.

[GreyICE]

Interesting.

[smargaret]

Grey, all I see is discussion of the mechanic - which isn't necessarily a bad thing in a game with a strange mechanic like this - and shutting down RQS discussion which is only slightly scummy. I certainly don't have a town read on Ranger, but he's also not the scummiest player IMO. Am I reading your argument right?

I still think there's something fishy in Amrun/Kcda and would like to see more discussion on that/between them.

[GreyICE]

Oh by no means stop.

I'm just interested in opinions on Ranger of the North right now.

[Mist7676]

Hmm I meant to post here earlier. GreyICE why do those posts strike you as scum?

[Kcdaspot]

OO OO MEMEME

IS IT BECAUSE RotN IS FLUFF POSTING?

[Kcdaspot]

also i'd like to see what he thought of the exchange between amrun and I.

[Doombunny9]

ISO on EXE:

1: AMRUN IS SCUM LOLRVSLOL
2: LOL @KCDA AMRUN IS STILL SCUM.
3 and 4: fluff and fluff
5: questions and fluff
6: KCDA IS SCUM.

do you see the progression here? because i don't.

Its still hasn't been that long since we've seen good discussion so you could say that there's no progression from a lot of people. What makes Exe so special?

I just quoted you all his posts.

In order.

So yeah.

Those look like posts to me! What's your point? All I see is "lololol gusy, look at RotN he's obv scum... But I'm not gonna make a case on him I'm just going to make it LOOK like I'm scumhunting"

As for Amrun vs. kcda; I don't really like Amrun's case as its fairly weak. Amrun also seems to be trying to appease both crowds with statements like these: "I am forced to consider the idea that kcda just didn't think about it, esp with his more recent posts." and "At present, that joke was still the shadiest thing to happen all game and I'll stick with my FoS on himM" which strike me as just someone who wants to try and push a kcda lynch but will back down if he needs to.

[Kcdaspot]

it was a early read.

I can't read RotN yet TBH but I was just noting that greyICE has a point.

i don't think much about EXE i just wish he'd post more.

[Kcdaspot]

i my meaning is that my EXE slight scum thing was temporary, as advertised, though i wish he commented and the exchange as well..


DB9: how do you feel about GW?

[Kcdaspot]

on the exchange*

[Amrun]

Doombunny:

Why would I push for someone's lynch based solely off of one post?

I wanted to note clearly that that particular post of kcdaspot's was scummy.

If, by the end of the day, he has earned enough townpoints to overweigh that scummy post, he won't be scummy overall to me.

How is that a hard concept? It's like basic play.

[Doombunny9]

DB9: how do you feel about GW?

I'm getting pro-town vibes from Ghost right now. He seems to be trying to help the town out. The only issue I would have is that I wish he would post more than one or two sentences per post. What he says is good but he doesn't say enough.

Doombunny:

Why would I push for someone's lynch based solely off of one post?

I wanted to note clearly that that particular post of kcdaspot's was scummy.

If, by the end of the day, he has earned enough townpoints to overweigh that scummy post, he won't be scummy overall to me.

I understand that but you said that as of right now, it was the scummiest thing to have happen and that you FoS him. I understand that its still early for more solid cases but the case you currently have on kcda is weak and you set it up in such a way where you could easily back off from it. I get that by the end of the day kcda probably won't be your top suspect (unless he keeps doing scummy thing of course) but I'm talking about right now.

Also, is kcda the only person you find scummy right now? If not, who else are you suspecting and why?

[Kcdaspot]

Amrun = town ^^^ that's why.

[Amrun]

Right now, kcda has done the single scummiest thing in the game. However, all of his OTHER posts have looked fairly town to me so far.

After him, I would pick Ranger of the North for his post where he basically said "lol i'mma do something scummy but i'm telling you first so it's okay." But that's weak, too.

Overall, I feel we don't have much content to work with, yet; the overwhelming majority of posts have been talk about set-up clarification.

[Tasky]

1. As soon as deadline of a day hits, the game enters nomination phase.

Sorry to be a stickler about this, Mod, but I'm still confused. Even if we vote not to lynch, we'll still go into the nomination phase as usual? I just don't quite understand. If you can elaborate, what would happen in such a scenario? Would there still be a lynch phase?

yes, going to nomination phase is unavoidable.
you can however, when making the lists for nomination include the option "No Lynch". When No Lynch is on top of the majority of lists, no lynch will happen.

[Tragedy]

ME: Insert Obligatory Refusal To Answer Pointless Questions Here
GROUP A: Vote: Ranger for refusing to answer pointless questions
GROUP B: Vote: Group A for thinking not answering questions is scummy

There, now that's done with. Can we get on with the game now?

What?
What pointless Questions?

[Exe]

Sorry, totally forgot this game >.>

Amrun feels wishy-washy, especially with her last post. Not liking that at all.

Something in my gut says that Kcda is scummy, but I can't place what. I do <3 gut reads though.

GreyICE seems obvtown so far, though I've never seen GreyICE as scum so I have no clue how good he'd be >.> His case on Ranger is solid though.

Particularly here:

ME: Insert Obligatory Refusal To Answer Pointless Questions Here
GROUP A: Vote: Ranger for refusing to answer pointless questions
GROUP B: Vote: Group A for thinking not answering questions is scummy

There, now that's done with. Can we get on with the game now?

This is a joke clearly based on an ongoing game, so I can't directly say how I feel about that part, but what I can say is why the hell does Ranger ask for us to "get on with the game" when he contributes nothing that could possible move the game forward?
This single post is massively scummy, and combined with the fact that he barely has posted, I'd say we caught scum #1.

Vote: Ranger

[Kcdaspot]

i was referring to amruns post BEFORE I GOT NINJA'D BY DB.

[Amrun]

How am I wishy washy? You think it's smart to tunnel on someone for one post alone?

[Exe]

Overall, I feel we don't have much content to work with, yet;

^^

You think it's smart to tunnel on someone for one post alone?

Did I in any way say this was the case?

[GhostWriter]

I find it odd that, whilst claiming to want more discussion on Amrun/Kcda, Smargaret does not ask questions of them. Several people have been interested in their interaction, but they usually follow up with questions. She'll be fairly high on my list.

[RangeroftheNorth]

Prodded. Terribly sorry forgot about this game. I'm on my phone this weekend, but I'll try and post something substantial tonight.

[smargaret]

I'm suspicious of the interaction between Amrun and kcd after the doctor claim - it was pretty clear that it was a joke, but I can see Amrun's suspicion as scum distancing.

GW, I want discussion on this point that I brought up four pages ago. Though, if you want me to ask more questions:

1. Kcd, why is Amrun town?
2. Amrun, do you still think Kcd is the scummiest person? I guess I don't understand your reasoning for saying he's scummy if he's done one (really scummy from your POV) thing and every other thing he's done has been pro-town.
3. Exe, do you think Kcd/Amrun are scum together?

[Kcdaspot]

Right now, kcda has done the single scummiest thing in the game. However, all of his OTHER posts have looked fairly town to me so far.

After him, I would pick Ranger of the North for his post where he basically said "lol i'mma do something scummy but i'm telling you first so it's okay." But that's weak, too.

Overall, I feel we don't have much content to work with, yet; the overwhelming majority of posts have been talk about set-up clarification.

this post is why amrun is town

is transparent scumhunting, as in anyone with half a brain can see he is actively hunting scum.