* Exactly, 'if chev flipped scum'. There was almost no actual reasoning behind CKD himself being scum, it was all 'plausible connection' the whole way. I myself have 'linked players' before either one of them flipped sure, but never without each player having their own reasoning for being scum and never in order to push one of their lynches. (i.e. well player X and player Y might be scum partners, so that's another reason to lynch player X...) Iam never actually directly did this, but as the only real thing he said about CKD tends to come to a close at "If Chev flips scum..." it does seem to imply CKD is only scum/should only be looked into after we lynch Chev, thereby furthering her lynch.pokerface wrote:IAM did link ckd and chevre but that case makes sence as CKD obviously didn't take time to read chevre's long as heck post and yet CKD still BS commented on it. Had chevre flipped scum I can see how that link could have made sence.
As far as IAMUSER's placement of CKD on his day 2 scumlist, CKD was not the only one he did not go in depth into why they were high on the list.
As far as I'm concerned only way IAMMUSER is scum is if Spyre X is also. IAMUSER was the most towny looking player about the time me and you and DGB? were going after SpyreX. If IAMuser was scum and SpyreX wasn't, I think IAMUSER would have put alot of effort into rallying the rest of the players to vote SPYREX as it would have been a very good opertunity from his viewpoint. So IAMUSER being scum and SPYREX not being scum would be ilogical to me.
It should be noted that I am not making a case that SPYREX being scum would garauntee IAMUSER being scum. It would make it 'possible' for IAMUSER to be scum but I don't think its likly atm
* No but CKD is the only one to so far come up scum. That seems like a sufficient reason to warrant his explanation wouldn't you agree? especially considering his lacking attitude toward reviewing CKD after the flip, you would think having him placed higher on the scum radar would mean he would have already had something on CKD, yet failed to see it/mention it when reviewing him?
* Why do you always get set in your ways when it comes to Spy? Also, how is it you know what Iam would do in that situation or what his viewpoint would be? This game follows a pattern, it stalls out until deadline approaches at which point the people jump on whatever is available. Any work put in by the scum short of a week or two away from deadline is essentially wasted effort. I would be so bold as to claim it nearly impossible to 'rally' this town, or even a fraction of it's player base, with anything short of impending deadline or confirmed role results... if Iam really was so townie looking at the time, why put in the effort and risk loosing that cred just for one potential mislynch? (Hypothetically implying Spy as town for sake of argument, this does not reflect the opinions of Korlash or Korlash affiliates and their sister company 'Bender, Bender, Bender, Rodriguez, and Flan.')
As far as the Bob thing goes I think both sides are being stupid. DGB is the only one actually pushing the Cyber vote/attacks for the correct reason while everyone else piddles about in conspiracy theories that would make even steadfast bigfoot believers shake their heads in utter disappointment; meanwhile Bob keeps falling back to the bottle as if it actually makes a difference in what he said. Instead of constantly repeating that, how about explaining why you made the statement "DGB would not lynch KMD" because that seems to have come from no backing at all, inebriated or not.
