Reckamonic's WoW Mafia (Over)

[InflatablePie]

Fuck it. My vote's not doing any good being nowhere. Blatantly bandwagoning until I can straighten everything out.

Vote: Substrike

Anyone wanna make a night action map? Or at least a list of claims? I did it in MPM but this time I'm lazy. :<

[inHimshallibe]

Is Chronopie confirmed?

I want to know how Serpent Sting, a DoT, is a roleblock ability.

vote: Chronopie

[AKnottedRope]

AGar and Chronopie need to explain their votes for sath in posts 1155 and 1156. The speed in which sath gathered votes today bothered me.

Vote: AGar

Of the two, he's scummier

[Gollum]

From a balance standpoint, what alignment would make sense for those who are redirection-immune and those/IHSIB who can redirect?
I am also confused, but mainly how vezok being redirected to Fate would steal his power.

[Gollum]

So who else here is a Shadow Priest and can confirm they redirect or something other?

[Gollum]

Unvote; Vote: inHim

Until/unless there's some clarification from others.

[Reckamonic]

Plushie: "So..."
Big Daddy: "Broadcasting can't talk!"
Plushie: "I'm going to-"
Big Daddy: "BROADCASTING!"
Plushie: "Post a votecount and prods."

Sathoris (3): Chronopie, AGar, Toogeloo
Toogeloo (1): Arthas
Chronopie (1): inHimshallibe
inHimshallibe (1): Gollum
Substrike22 (2): bunnylover, InflatablePie
AGar (1): AKnottedRope

Not voting: mothrax, Sathoris, vezokpiraka, Substrike22, Katsuki, Krazy, Tragedy

With 16 alive it will take 9 votes to lynch!

Prodding Substrike22 and Katsuki!

[Toogeloo]

Is Chronopie confirmed?

I want to know how Serpent Sting, a DoT, is a roleblock ability.

vote: Chronopie

Same way Water Shield is apparently a reactive doc ability (self mana regen in game)... I've given up trying to meta the roles as being legit.

[Tragedy]

LLD (13)

: Fate, Katsuki, Arthas, drmyshottyizsik, AGar, Chronopie, Bunnylover, Baby Spice, Substrike22, Starbuck, InflatablePie, AKR, Benmage

Baby Spice (11)

: Toogleloo, Fate, Katsuki, Gollum, AGar, Chronopie, AKR, Benmage, Arthas, InflatablePie, Krazy

Common People on Those Wagons

: AGar, AKR, Arthas, Benmage, Chronopie, InflatablePie, Katsuki

--

AGar's Case

- Voted LLD [Sheep Vote]
- Voted BS [Hop-On-The-Wagon Vote?]

AKR's Case

- Voted LLD [Horrible-Scumminess Detected from Her + Hammer]
- Voted BS [Fate threatens him]

Arthas' Case

- Voted LLD [LLD's Fucked Up Claim]
- Voted BS [Really Convinced in a Raging Way]

Benmage's Case

- Voted LLD [Hop-On-The-Wagon (Hammer)]
- Voted BS [Hop-On-The-Wagon Hammer]

ChronoPie's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on Contradiction]
- Voted BS [Convinced of Lynch by Fate]

InflatablePie's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on AtE]
- Voted BS [Convinced of Lynch by Fate]

Katsuki's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on LLD deflecting attention of 'Scum DayTalking']
- Voted BS [Non-confirmed Reason]

--

I find this ironically ridiculous that Fate convinced practically everyone with his epic reasoning.
I still don't get why Benmage's suddenly bandwagoning yet not really looking suspicious. I find this awkward.

[Bunnylover]

AGar and Chronopie need to explain their votes for sath in posts 1155 and 1156. The speed in which sath gathered votes today bothered me.

Vote: AGar

Of the two, he's scummier

I don't opposed to this vote.

@Gollum: Well it was obvious that a redirected was in the game, but that doesn't mean they would be on opposite side.
Although I do like what you were thinking.

[AKnottedRope]

Tragedy: Your point by making that is...?

Bunny: I do opposed to your grammar, though.

[Bunnylover]

I need to retake my English classes =/.

[AKnottedRope]

I feel like we've had this conversation before, but is English not your first language?

[AKnottedRope]

I still don't get why Benmage's suddenly bandwagoning yet not really looking suspicious. I find this awkward.

Do you think benmage is scum?

[Bunnylover]

lol I think we did, and sadly yes it is.

[Gollum]

*cackles*

unvote; vote: substrike

[Substrike22]

I need time to catch up on this game before I get a post together, I'm stuck back where we had Tragedy pinned for that scum slip with her gender on the Role PM and don't honestly know what's happened since then. Week from hell for midterms. When you see me "log on" it's from my phone and I don't post from it because touch screens annoy the fuck out of me. I'll have something up by tomorrow evening, money back guarantee.

[Krazy]

LLD (13)

: Fate, Katsuki, Arthas, drmyshottyizsik, AGar, Chronopie, Bunnylover, Baby Spice, Substrike22, Starbuck, InflatablePie, AKR, Benmage

Baby Spice (11)

: Toogleloo, Fate, Katsuki, Gollum, AGar, Chronopie, AKR, Benmage, Arthas, InflatablePie, Krazy

Common People on Those Wagons

: AGar, AKR, Arthas, Benmage, Chronopie, InflatablePie, Katsuki

--

AGar's Case

- Voted LLD [Sheep Vote]
- Voted BS [Hop-On-The-Wagon Vote?]

AKR's Case

- Voted LLD [Horrible-Scumminess Detected from Her + Hammer]
- Voted BS [Fate threatens him]

Arthas' Case

- Voted LLD [LLD's Fucked Up Claim]
- Voted BS [Really Convinced in a Raging Way]

Benmage's Case

- Voted LLD [Hop-On-The-Wagon (Hammer)]
- Voted BS [Hop-On-The-Wagon Hammer]

ChronoPie's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on Contradiction]
- Voted BS [Convinced of Lynch by Fate]

InflatablePie's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on AtE]
- Voted BS [Convinced of Lynch by Fate]

Katsuki's Case

- Voted LLD [Based on LLD deflecting attention of 'Scum DayTalking']
- Voted BS [Non-confirmed Reason]

--

I find this ironically ridiculous that Fate convinced practically everyone with his epic reasoning.
I still don't get why Benmage's suddenly bandwagoning yet not really looking suspicious. I find this awkward.

Tragedy, thank you for this wonderful post, but doesn't a lot of your work here somewhat rest on the presupposition that scum are more likely to join both town-lynching wagons rather than just one or the other? I mean among people who are still alive, people who were only on one wagon or another is limited to me, Gollum, and Bunnylover (unless I'm missing someone, which I probably am). It seems like to avoid being called as a scum-pair, scum would want to resist being on both wagons for precisely wagon analysis like this.

[Krazy]

vote Gollum

Something about Gollum's posts just really bother me. I feel like for two of them, their posts feel very restrained. They do make some points (like the "He" vs. "They" in role PMs... which I actually was thinking myself but have yet to make up my mind on). It's also interesting that his first post is like "Here are some thoughts! N STUFF!" and after that he's like... I dunno, slinky. There's nothing I can really bullshit and try to pin him to because nothing he says is all that unreasonable... which just bothers me more. Not sure if this vote is really going to do much but it's my thoughts for the moment.

[AGar]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Tragedy

IIoA hardcore.

Lurking it would seem.

And AKR - total sheepage throughout. Have a townread on Chessdalf.

[AKnottedRope]

And yet you sheeped Arthas' vote yourself? My vote will remain.

[AKnottedRope]

Tragedy:

I still don't get why Benmage's suddenly bandwagoning yet not really looking suspicious. I find this awkward.

Do you think benmage is scum?

[AKnottedRope]

Wait derp tragedy hasn't posted yet. I thought krazy was him. Ignore me.

[Tragedy]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Tragedy

IIoA hardcore.

Lurking it would seem.

And AKR - total sheepage throughout. Have a townread on Chessdalf.

And then there's others?
I can still say that Benmage is leaning more scum as a Neutral bastard.
But then again, AGar's pretty much feeling a bit more scummy after analyzing thathis votes were mostly sheeping, but not for decent reasons.

I would still call for the lurking part to be 'seeing' reactions from some of the people I've listed on the cases.
AGar -> Neutral Scummy-face.

[Toogeloo]

AGar, you vouched for Tragedy's claim. The Gender specific targeting is something you guys have in common. I think you guys are fine atm, but there are a lot of confirming, or reasonable doubt causing roles and actions in the game thus far.

Of course, this is why I hate cults too, you guys are probably fine at the beginning of the game, but it will be entirely too difficult to know as we get down to the wire. But given I like you both now, we can worry about recruits after we eliminate the Cult Leader, if either of you even has been recruited.


I still think we are dealing with a Serial Killer (maybe two unless Cult can kill) and a Cult Leader.



Of Tragedy's list, I like Katsuki the least. She has been more or less a non factor of presence since Day 1 ended, and much of Day 1 was mostly just bandwagon fluff and typical Kat behavior null-tell of alignment. She has posted that she has computer problems and finals both consuming her computer use time, but it's also given her an excuse to slip through the cracks of the game.

I would also consider Substrike a possibility. Substrike didn't appear serious of the game (and still doesn't). He popped on last night saying he was going to catch up after he got yet another vote that tied him with the lead. We will see what his content is tonight with his "guaranteed" post though.