Road to Wrestlemania: Game over - WWF wins - BANG BANG!

[sottyrulez]

chess, where have you seen VP as dumb town?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Yeah you're right VPB I misread it the same way that VV did and you're right I think without that point it falls from being the best lurker case to just another lurker case. And why jedi/furc over BS/Empking?

Preview Edit: Ironic that Sotty/Zach then chooses this moment to jump on the GMan wagon.

[chesskid3]

oh and my god acting like i Haven't been after EA for AGES?
WHAT THE HELL DUDE
EA suspicion did not come out of nowhere to save IS. NICE MISREP DUDEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

PEDIT: every time he's town.

[Nero Cain]

YOU misrep me. I said BOTH YOU AND IS CALLED EA SCUM BUT IT WASN'T UNTIL AV AND VPB VOTED THAT YOU TWO DID.

[chesskid3]

BECAUSE BEFORE THAT THERE WAS NO GODDAMN WAGON AND I WAS LEAVING MY VOTE ON DDD TO PROVE A POINT

[Nero Cain]

Thats not town. sorry.

[VP Baltar]

@Sottyrulez- I'm not 'attacking' Vas' case so much as I'm saying his best point is inaccurate. The reason lurking for GMan doesn't move me is because other people are doing it and worse. Pretty simple that if you're attacking lurkers it should be the worst offenders, right?

In terms of IS, idk. I think he's spazzing out, but I don't know if that's his normal MO or not. He seems pretty illogical, but that's how a lot of people are rolling in this game, so...

re: chesskid - if you're trying to troll me, you may as well give up because I don't really care. I'm quite confident that I'm better at mafia than you, and you being petty about that doesn't bother me. so, shrug.

@DDD - jedi has bothered me since the royal rumble stage on an intuitive level, though I really need to formalize a case at some point so people will see what I've felt. Put it on my list of things to do today. Furc is famous for his lurker scum. He's had a few bursts this game where I've seen town-furc fire, but it's not very consistent. That makes me pretty wary of him.

[chesskid3]

VP Baltar said: Think I care?
Yup. Sure do.

[sottyrulez]

RE: GMan. We have meta on him in a similar vein as we have on Jason. GMan came to these boards though us and we have played with him several times off site. He is normally way more proactive than this when he is town. I'm not even getting the genuine sense that he is lost or overwhelmed, he is just lurking and avoiding major issues in the hopes of laying low. It jumps him to the top of my list easily.

Fair enough VP, I just saw you picking at Vas a little when IS really only turned to EA on lurking to start with. Not commenting on the later gives me pause.

[VP Baltar]

So you bad-meta Jason and your next main suspect is based on meta again.

[sottyrulez]

Err no. Yes we had an early Scum read on Jason, but we back off as his posting picked up.

[Lowell]

I can be swayed onto the Gman wagon if for some reason the ugliness man Scott Brosius isn't going down.

Eye gouge Gman

. See?

Upon realizing my read completely missed him, I ISOd. Pointless. Get him talking or get him gone. If I have to choose one opinion to parrot, I'd rather it be sotty than chesskid.

[VP Baltar]

lol, why is the GMan case gaining steam after the best point was shown to be an error? I don't get it.

[sottyrulez]

Oh god... this game

What error is that VP? Point me in the general direction of a post please.

[VP Baltar]

Post 1013 by Vas

He makes the point that GMan agrees with Thor, then proceeds to vote Thor. It's based on a misreading of Gman's post. GMan was actually agreeing with your read of Thor's play toward BS. It is understandable because I misread it as well, but it's an error just the same. I think this was the best point against GMan and without that the case is pretty meh.

[GMan]

While it is true that in games played offsite with Sottyrulez I have been typically proactive as town, it is also untrue that I typically lurk as scum. In fact, I once got caught by zachrulez for being far too aggressive. I think this meta on me is crap.

I will make an extra effort to try harder to keep up though. I have football tonight, but I'll post some reads when I get back.

[Locke Lamora]

Move Count 2.4!

GMan - 6 (VasudeVa, Debonair Danny DiPietro, Scott Brosius, Gobots, sottyrulez, Lowell)
Internet Stranger - 5 (Kise, Nero Cain, Empking, Kublai Khan, GMan)
Erratus Apathos - 4 (AurorusVox, Internet Stranger, chesskid3, bristep123)
jediknight - 2 (Hoppster, VP Baltar)
bristep123 - 2 (Erratus Apathos, vezokpiraka)
Lowell - 1 (Baby Spice)
Empking - 1 (Furcolow)

Not voting - 2 (Primate, jediknight)

VV: this is me blatantly not answering that question.

Deadline is Friday 25th March at 10:00AM GMT. A countdown to that time is here.

Word counter: here

[Internet Stranger]

Mwahahaha, Nero is still trying to twist my words. I already explained it Nero. I ran out of suspects, found the ISO and built my case. Do you realize how desperate you look trying to frame me Nero? Amazing.

I'm in Vegas getting drunk and whoeing, so V/LA until Sunday.

[jediknight]

VPB- Something about "bothered me on an intiutive level" and "formalize a case at some point so people will see what I've felt." It's this exact thing that makes me say again...i don't trust you.

IS- playing the way I've always seen him play...course its based on reads from five years ago. And he played the same as town or scum back then. Almost a reckless...who cares what you think mentality.

EA-there's too many people discussing this to get it all from ISO's (which are truly a godsend in this big of game). I'd have to go back and look at the thread as a whole.

Gman- I do have some thoughts here. I'll have to save them for this evening though.

I'd like to think that there's some valid points in what I've been saying. I don't just come on and say post or prod dodge as I've seen from some. I just have a hard time handling the sheer volume of this.

[Empking]

FOS: Sotty

- He's been on the biggest wagon all day which seems awfully wierd concidering the wide range of wagons. In all honesty I'm just waiting for people to finally realize that IS needs to be lynched.

[Hoppster]

HAPPY SCUMDAY MOD!

jediknight seems to be deliberately ignoring me now. (This is a reminder you haven't addressed my points despite insisting that you have.)


@ Gobots: Why is bad to attack people for scummy behaviour on D1 that was never addressed (as you seemed to imply in your post)?

@ GMan: Apologies if it's already been brought up (and I've missed it), but your vote here confuses me terribly. No criticism of Thor pre-vote or post-vote.

@ Furc: Why are you abandoning the EA wagon?

[VP Baltar]

GMan is criticizing Thor right before that vote Hoppster...this is like an Abbott and Costello routine now.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Third Base!

[Hoppster]

Okay. From what I read, you understood that bit, VPB, could you break it down for me? I am really not seeing it

at all

.

I am horribly, horribly confused. Is he being sarcastic?

[VP Baltar]

See my post 1514 for a thorough explanation of it.