Mini 1106 - No Exit Mafia

The Jester · Post Post #675 (ISO) » Thu Feb 10, 2011 6:13 pm

It's just odd DGB is asking for something, when she has trouble answering some of the questions I've asked her.

Vote-hopping, asking who she should vote for, freaking out over flavor of the game. I still like a DGB lynch today though.

Ghostlin · Post Post #676 (ISO) » Thu Feb 10, 2011 6:58 pm

LynchMePls wrote:
palmertrou wrote:There isn't a lot of focus at the start of today. I'm feeling the same. There are only a few people that I won't be voting for (Darox, Zazier, Ghostlin) unless something major happens. I'm kinda torn between three people; Dark horse, LMP and Jester. However, I want to find out more about AntB, Veridis and DGB (blood from a stone, lol). So I guess that is my scum list at the moment.

Zazier Darox Ghostlin

AntB DGB Veridis

Jester LMP Darkhorse

...and now that's me
V/LA until monday
. Although I guess most of that will be spent wooing my woman (valentines day).
And hey look, a convenient V/LA from palm after he is coming under scrutiny. We haven't sen that before.

Cite when this happened before, for the rest of us in the audience?

LimMePls · Post Post #677 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 4:12 am

*waits for more palmertrou votes*

LimMePls · Post Post #678 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 5:40 am

@MOD: Prods?

I got nothing else folks. So please comment on my case or vote palmertrou. Either one is fine.

Ghostlin · Post Post #679 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 6:16 am

LynchMePls wrote:
@MOD: Prods?

I got nothing else folks. So please comment on my case or vote palmertrou. Either one is fine.

I did ask you a question.

LimMePls · Post Post #680 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 8:59 am

Ghostlin wrote:
LynchMePls wrote:
palmertrou wrote:There isn't a lot of focus at the start of today. I'm feeling the same. There are only a few people that I won't be voting for (Darox, Zazier, Ghostlin) unless something major happens. I'm kinda torn between three people; Dark horse, LMP and Jester. However, I want to find out more about AntB, Veridis and DGB (blood from a stone, lol). So I guess that is my scum list at the moment.

Zazier Darox Ghostlin

AntB DGB Veridis

Jester LMP Darkhorse

...and now that's me
V/LA until monday
. Although I guess most of that will be spent wooing my woman (valentines day).
And hey look, a convenient V/LA from palm after he is coming under scrutiny. We haven't sen that before.
Cite when this happened before, for the rest of us in the audience?

Well he didn't V/LA, but he lurked. Look around Jan 11 to the 15 and then from 15th to like the 22. Read the game whole, not in ISO. When he was under fire before, he lurked. He's under fire this time and he's now conveniently away. Lets see when his V/LA is over how he plays it from there.

DrippingGoofball · Post Post #681 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 3:41 pm

Let's lynch Jester first.

You should have listened to me yesterday.

Seacore · Post Post #682 (ISO) » Fri Feb 11, 2011 11:28 pm

Vote count 3.3

palmertrou (2) -

LynchMePls, Ghostlin

The Jester (2) -

Dark Horse, DrippingGoofball

Dark Horse (1) -

Darox

Not voting (5) - Thor665, The Jester, AntB, ZazieR, palmertrou

With 10 alive, 6 votes are needed for the lynch

Deadline countdown viewable here.

ZazieR has been prodded.

DrippingGoofball · Post Post #683 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 10:26 am

We could lynch ZazieR.

Thor665 · Post Post #684 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 10:29 am

Up through Page 11, and have assorted wild and crazy theory to spew about.

The short summation is mostly - palmer town, Jester town, Ghostlin scum, DH scum, and a side helping of I hate everyone but say it in whimsical ways to seem polite.

Spoiler: Brilliant(?) thoughts

I will be done with this before end of day Sunday. I'm not sure I'll promise much more from me tonight though, as I'm already bored of the re-read. But tomorrow is laundry day and that's a good 2 hours or so to whitter away and I might as well spend it here.

LimMePls · Post Post #685 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 10:40 am

DrippingGoofball wrote:We could lynch ZazieR.

On my reread Gud was one of my most solid town reads. I'm not down for a ZazieR lynch.

Dark Horse · Post Post #686 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 11:16 am

Thor, couple of problems:

1.a)Jokey to serious ratio concern?

On the first page

?
b) what about my response to gud's questions? Are those "Not serious"?

2. a)You claim that ross cop-out vote is "inane" logic. I would like you to elaborate on this.
b) What's more, you say my vote-hopping is a scumtell, yet it doesn't seem like you considered that my original vote on vezo was RVS, and my vote on ross wasn't. Second, you claim that I was simply parroting. Does agreeing with DGB any more parroting then agreeing with someone else?

3. Puesdo-clearing yourself? Seriously?

4. Your general lack of evidence. Most of your reads have next to nothing backing them (I.E Vezo and later Ghostlin)

5. Basing your overall reads when you've only read up to page 11 doesn't help

Dark Horse · Post Post #687 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 11:17 am

EBWOP:

and to the end of five: "It's as if you wanted to have reads ready so you wouldn't have to bring up reasons just when you're about to bandwagon on someone

Thor665 · Post Post #688 (ISO) » Sat Feb 12, 2011 11:37 am

@Dark Horse - you see problems and I see none at all.

1. a) Yes. Your point?
b) And yet your ratio was still weak, your point?

2. a) You mean to tell me that when you parroted DGB's "case" you fully understood its nuances and agreed with it? Why didn't you vote for him earlier than? Yes, it was inane.
b) I would like you to quote where I said vote hopping was a scumtell. Untill you do all i hear is "meep, meep, meep" which is the sound of made up accusations. And, yes, you were parroting DGB; here's the timeline...

TIMELINE

Player A - Hey guys! (scumtell X)
Dark Horse: Vote: Player B!
DGB: X is a scumtell, Vote Player A!
Dark Horse: Unvote: B, Vote Player A!

Do you see the parrot in there? I do.

3. I'll guess I've replaced someone I had a town read on - did you have a scum read on that player? If not, why does this worry you?

4. Meta and Gut respectiuvely - I consider both of my cases to be equal to or superior to every other case presented in the game up to the point I'm reading. Which cases do you think were better?

5. HAHAHAHAHAHAHA....oh wait, are you serious?

Appended 5. HAHAHAaaaaaha...ha... oh gawds, you are serious. ::head shake:: Do you even understand what catchup wall posts are for? If you get confused by them how about you just wait till I'm all caught up, then your head will hurt less

Thor665 · Post Post #689 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 7:19 am

Picking up again at page 12 - and it is relatively meaningless.
Page 13...
Still hate Darox but his first wall post does contain a Pratchett reference which tends to leave me a bit more favorably disposed. That said, he spends an awful lot of time mocking people for drawing no/weak conclusions and then fails to actually draw a conclusion worth a durn from the whole wall - he also fails to generate even one town read instead setting for Undecided --> Ugh --> Dislike --> Scum (I'm putting those in presumed order...though maybe Ugh is a town read? Wow, a useless wall post, thanks so much for playing.

Isn't Xalxe the Day 1 lynch? How does that happen from this mush?

Post 316 by veridis when he notes that everyone is playing with a VI/jokey/hey I'm kooky/goofy playstyle is pure win and correct on so many levels I'm calling him town right now just so I have another solid platform to place a foot on in this drippy mess.

Oh, we lynched Xalxe because he didn't support the Ross lynch...mmmkay. It is frightening to see everyone sheeping DGB this much.

I love Darox on Dark Horse violence. Let's lynch them both and make me happy.

Oh gawd. Ghostlin vs. Darox is not amusing at all and just sort of hurts to read. I'm skimming, oh lawd I am skimming all of this.

Okay, I might be obligated to start liking Darox for the drubbing he's giving Dark Horse. I don't want to, but there's a siren call in his slinky posting method of going 'U R SXumZ!' at DH over and over and it dramatically turns me on (in a manly way). Somewhere in here we don't lynch Dark Horse and lynch Vezo...that will be interesting to see.

I really should mention by this point I still have no read whatsoever on AntB. He is Mr. Slide under the radar this game. He needs to be a Doc and protect people so I can get a town read on him

DGB does need to reexplain that town read on DH - I want to hear that thing.

AntB is doing a lot of side line commentary that is not actually commentary and appears to mostly be avoiding the Darox/DH debate. Darox is looking pretty solid town for how much he's making himself a central focus and is picking a fight with everyone who looks at him sideways.

I continue to disagree with basically every read DGB posts. I'm going to have to call her scum just for that.

At least she now thinks palmer is town, which is better than thinking him scum.

Zazie is here - best point is the pickup on Ghostlin re: accusing Darox of something Ghostlin had said was nobody's fault.

I'm at page 21 and I have to stop for the sake of the children in my head. I will finish this later, but right now I need to step away. See you this evening with finished thoughts and also a vote (huzzah!)

Dark Horse · Post Post #690 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:19 am

Thor665 wrote:@Dark Horse - you see problems and I see none at all.

Then you are blind

1. a) Yes. Your point?
b) And yet your ratio was still weak, your point?

THe first couple of pages are usually RVS (such as in this game), where people joke around. THe fact that you are attacking me for that is like attacking an RVS vote for not being serious.

2. a) You mean to tell me that when you parroted DGB's "case" you fully understood its nuances and agreed with it? Why didn't you vote for him earlier than? Yes, it was inane.
b) I would like you to quote where I said vote hopping was a scumtell. Untill you do all i hear is "meep, meep, meep" which is the sound of made up accusations. And, yes, you were parroting DGB; here's the timeline...

Thor, ross had wanted to vote for DGB for "Information", yet he had

never

specified what. The vote was probably less of a "Vote for information" moreso a vote to try and get DGB lynched, with "Information" as a cop-out reason. Unlike other types, I cannot directly see the information the could happen with that vote

3. I'll guess I've replaced someone I had a town read on - did you have a scum read on that player? If not, why does this worry you?

Essentially trying to clear yourself. YEs, I do have a problem with it.

Veridis and antB were flying under the radar, and I had them interchangeably pegged as the last scum. When I would try and remember what the two said, I would remember less of antB. After I said I thought that antB was the last scum, his reaction was horrible (Appearing out of no where, and asking nothing more than questions). However, you're starting to fall under my scumdar a bit more.

4. Meta and Gut respectiuvely - I consider both of my cases to be equal to or superior to every other case presented in the game up to the point I'm reading. Which cases do you think were better?

You probably know the answer to this.

Xalxe was lynched because he refused to vote ross when we were near the deadline scrambling for a lynch. It seemed that Xalxe was ross' scumbuddy, either trying to save ross or cause an nl.

Thor665 · Post Post #691 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:39 am

Dark Horse wrote:Then you are blind

Dark Horse wrote:THe first couple of pages are usually RVS (such as in this game), where people joke around. THe fact that you are attacking me for that is like attacking an RVS vote for not being serious.

I do attack RVS votes for not being serious. RVS is low information, it is not license to make jokes and act like all your actions have no meaning in game. They do have meaning, even the jokes...especially the jokes that people choose to defend as "hey, c'mon, I wasn't being serious, you can't hold that against me!" ESPECIALLY those.

Dark Horse wrote:Thor, ross had wanted to vote for DGB for "Information", yet he had
never
specified what. The vote was probably less of a "Vote for information" moreso a vote to try and get DGB lynched, with "Information" as a cop-out reason. Unlike other types, I cannot directly see the information the could happen with that vote

And yet you dodge the accusation of the sheeping and the following. I never indicated I had an issue with DGB's case on Ross, yet that's what you're defending here and acting like it's a defense to the accusation I made about you sheeping that case in unusual and scummy ways.

Dark Horse wrote:Veridis and antB were flying under the radar, and I had them interchangeably pegged as the last scum. When I would try and remember what the two said, I would remember less of antB. After I said I thought that antB was the last scum, his reaction was horrible (Appearing out of no where, and asking nothing more than questions). However, you're starting to fall under my scumdar a bit more.

Am I veridis or AntB? I'll guess AntB. So you found him scummy for lurking under the radar and then he flaked out of game? I'll get back to you when I notice the scumtell there. Hold your breath.

Dark Horse wrote:
4. Meta and Gut respectiuvely - I consider both of my cases to be equal to or superior to every other case presented in the game up to the point I'm reading. Which cases do you think were better?
You probably know the answer to this.

Xalxe was lynched because he refused to vote ross when we were near the deadline scrambling for a lynch. It seemed that Xalxe was ross' scumbuddy, either trying to save ross or cause an nl.

Which makes it a better case how exactly?
Not to mention now we know it was wrong...we don't know that about my case on you though, so my case could either be just as good or better than that case - win for me!
And you really want to hold up the xalxe case as win on a stick? You must have an exceedingly low opinion of my case then, and that makes me mad/sad about you in equal amounts.

I will say, short of DGB roleclaiming scum or something in the next few pages, your reactions here have fairly cemented where I'll be wanting the lynch to happen.

Thor665 · Post Post #692 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:51 am

Darox wrote:5 bucks says everyone shambles around pissing about saying nothing of import until the last minute and then suddenly vezok gets last minute wagoned.

Prove me wrong.

I take back everything bad I've said about Darox - he is awesome and makes reading this thread worthwhile.

The Jester · Post Post #693 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 11:45 am

The vote Ross made on DGB, do you mean post 26? He clearly states "because I want to apply some pressure in order to hear more about this weird role that's being tossed about".

Where was he not specifying why he was voting?

Thor, you replaced veridis. AntB is still in this game.

Dark Horse · Post Post #694 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 12:39 pm

He did not specify

the information he wanted to hear

.

I said nothing about lack of reason for his vote.

Thor665 · Post Post #695 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 12:57 pm

The Jester wrote:Thor, you replaced veridis. AntB is still in this game.

To-may-toe to-mah-toe, let DH bumble through his own little scum accusation on his own, I see little reason to help him - though find it hillarious he's calling me out for being veridis and then spends the bulk of that paragraph digging into AntB - lulz.

Only really great thing in last few pages.

Like Zaz less and LMP more.

So now we're caught up to game state and have a lot of suspects and, thanks to fail scum (to tag team with fail town) still plenty of lynch attempts to work through.

Vote: Dark Horse

Seriously now, why didn't this wagon happen yesterday?

LMP is town.
Darnox is town.
Palmer is town.

Undecided on most of the rest of you people whom I hate in horrible ways but I could happily lynch a couple of you, secondary preference is probably still Ghostlin but I could actually go for Ant the lurker, though if people want that one they better explain some sort of brilliance about how DH isn't scum first.

Ghostlin · Post Post #696 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 1:21 pm

Dark Horse wrote:He did not specify
the information he wanted to hear
.

I said nothing about lack of reason for his vote.

You know, splitting hairs like this leads credence to the idea you're scummy: if you have nothing to hide as town, you'd volunteer the information if it was correct regardless.

Darox · Post Post #697 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 1:33 pm

I like Thor, he is a man of class and sophistication.

I agree with everything he said about Dark Horse, Darox, and Pratchett.

Darox · Post Post #698 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 1:34 pm

Oh, and let's get Ghostlin after DH for coaching.

Seacore · Post Post #699 (ISO) » Sun Feb 13, 2011 1:44 pm

Vote count 3.4

palmertrou (2) -

LynchMePls, Ghostlin

The Jester (2) -

Dark Horse, DrippingGoofball

Dark Horse (2) -

Darox, Thor665

Not voting (4) - The Jester, AntB, ZazieR, palmertrou

With 10 alive, 6 votes are needed for the lynch

Deadline countdown viewable here.

AntB has been prodded.
ZazieR has not picked up the prod, I'll let the weekend end before looking for a replacement, but it looks like we have yet another flaker. Sigh.

5 days to go.