Post #9: The first of many Antihero posts that strikes me as scummy. I don't have a tangible reason for this one, my gut just says that this post feels wrong.
Post #17: Gut scummy feeling about this one too; saying "I'm going to ignore nocase's post restriction" is a contradictory statement, clearly, and it feels really self-conscious to me, like he's trying to pre-emptively deflect any "why didn't you say anything about nocase?" questions. If you're going to ignore it, then just ignore it. This just comes off like he's waiting to see how the town at large feels about nocase before he takes a side himself, which is hella scummy.
Post #37: fuckin love this post. i want to marry it.
Post #38: I would not expect SpyreX to be this dense, but I can't see what he stands to gain from it as scum, so it's just weird.
Post #49 &
Post #57: Combination scummy. "It's fun to watch scum fail", to me, heavily implies that some kind of slip has occurred. Certainly something more concrete than "craptacular post disguised as content".
Post #69: Last sentence here makes Seraphim look town, though.
Post #72: I remember reaching the conclusion that Chevre is obvtown at some point yesterday, but this post looks kind of scummy, actually. Specifically the "Certain philosophies would have you lynched under that statement.". It's like she wants to call for a LAL policy lynch, but she just doesn't have the guts to go through with it.
Post #99: dutch one so town it hurts. I probably said this before, but I want to reiterate.
Post #119: DGB suggesting that dutch one is scummy looks bad. I would expect her to be one of the first to realise how obvious town he is.
Post #128: Read the first line of this post, seriously wondering where the hell I got the idea that Chevre was town from. The rest of the post does nothing to remind me.
Post #140: OK, DGB was just a little slow on the uptake, not scum. That's fine.
Post #164: i still can't read it
Post #170: I'm not convinced that CKD read it either. If Chevre turns out to be scum, I'm pretty sure CKD should take a bullet just for this post.
Post #175: Serpahim's reaction looks a heck of a lot more natural.
Post #176: Antihero's reaction says nothing at all. "Made my day", what does that actually mean?
Post #177: Good points about this post - points out that Antihero is Scum of Scum Hall.
Bad points about this post - FoS not vote, warns Antihero to "think carefully before you answer". Maybe some bussing going on here.
Post #183: Making a note to remember this. I have a feeling Antihero will contradict it later, but I don't remember for sure.
Post #193: That's twice now that Runner has made a point of saying "I am not sure what to think of DGB. I will call her neutral
for now
." Looks really contrived, and the 'for now' is either an admission that his reads are artificially constructed, or implies that he is psychic. Or at least thinks he is.
Post #198: "I see the case on farside, Gorrad, and Antihero, Seraphim." The 'and' stuck in the middle there is intriguing. Logic would suggest that it means Seraphim's name was added as an afterthought. I don't know if that means anything significant though.
Post #207: hey guys sup i'm just going to casually shift gears from 'i'm voting dutch one so he'll stop ignoring me' to 'dutch one is scum' and hope no one notices
Post #225: Seriously, seriously wondering where the hell my town read on Chevre came from. What the hell, man.
Post #257: Antihero asking inane questions of Seraphim that signify nothing. Continues to look like a distancing argument between the two of them.
Post #260: I noticed that DGB gave farside town status for "bothering to meta only to change her own mind", which I agree is a pretty strong town tell, and I think Korlash deserves the same credit here.
Post #348: Feelin' this, actually. I don't know where my head was yesterday, like none of my town reads actually look very good on reread.
Post #353: ...except for dutch one, that is. DON'T START THIS AGAIN DGB
Post #385: Agreeing with the last part of this post. DGB and Cyberbob are both high on my town list, and Chevre is not, but it's like they've let Chevre get away with all kinds of murder and arson and what not, and now they've discovered him dodging taxes and they're like "ah-HAH!"
Post #409: That's a pretty solid list. Antihero's at the wrong end, but otherwise, good calls.
Post #434: Oh, maybe that's why I was so against the Chevre wagon. Inverse guilt by association.
Post #453: Antihero completely forgets where his vote is. Usually lightly scummy, but in this particular instance, it's supersized. So Antihero's been drumbeating for a Chevre lynch for ages, then all of a sudden he reads a werewolf post that makes him think that werewolf knows Chevre is town, so he switches his vote to werewolf. You'd think that such a radical re-evaluation of his top suspect might stick in his mind, no? Unless of course his 'suspicion' of werewolf was completely contrived.
Post #473: "I'm here but my claim will have to wait an hour" - WHOA. How is it that DGB has even considered lynching anyone else since this post?
Post #482: Hey it's a wall post that I was actually able to read. Hey that's an awful lot of of effort to go to just to put a bit of WIFOM out there about your buddies.
Post #494: This is pretty lol because he could be describing his own werewolf vote.
And that's all I've got time for. Dang. Here's where we stand after 20 pages:
DrippingGoofball
Cyberbob
Dutch one
inHimshallibe
nocase
Korlash
Seraphim
Xtoxm
Jerbs
yabbaguy
SpyreX
Runner
Weatherman
Kmd4390
Katsuki
PokerFace
RedCoyote
curiouskarmadog
Chevre
Antihero
See you in a week. Sorry I didn't manage the whole thread before I left.
