Mafia 42: Italian - Game over!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I understand the tell thing, but this is a bloody game of mafia! not poker! It's not just babyjesus keeping my tell to himself so he can call my all-in later, it's babyjesus using a completely ridiculous reason to lynch me and every1 nodding and saying "yea that's pretty good, i'll roll with it"

We have nightkill information! We have day1 voting patterns! We can examine why there's a difference between number of kills for n1 and n2? Roleblocker maybe block scumbag making kill this time perhaps!?!?

We have a well developped wagon on LB for a ACTUAL reasons!

A game of mafia isn't about one person going hey I got a tell on person B, let's lynch him and every1 nodding and saying, yea that's pretty good let's do it!

Is BJ going to be punished when I turn up innocent? No! It was just BJ trying to get a lynch on his instincts.

Put yourself in my shoes, I know I'm innocent, and am getting chased into the lynching post by something that I have absolutely no way to defend against because I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS! Just think for a second about how ridiculous it is to lynch some1 based on that, something you don't know!

The game of mafia isn't supposed to be played by having a large number of sheep follow some random guy's gut instincts! Surely we're better than just rolling dice?

Seriously, if you guys want to play a game of logic and actually put EFFORT into this game and TRY HARD to win it for the town, then please try, I'm begging you, just TRY. If you honestly don't feel like trying and think it's much better to just follow the wagon based on the word of some1's who's incredibly unhelpful and tries to lead us on random gut instincts, then lynch me.

Because I honestly would not want to be a part of a game where people won't even put in that effort.

But please I beg you, do not let me live if you don't feel like actually putting in effort in this mafia game, because the last thing I want to go through, is a game where no1 feels like putting in effort, when no1 cares.

That game is less than fun to me, it's dead.

[Yosarian2]

You haven't convinced me that he is scum. I'm not going to lynch someone just because you claim to have seen a tell. That may be good enough for some people, but unless you give me more, I'm not buying it. I'll vote for him if I you tell me what the tell is so that I can evaluate it for myself, or if I see signs of his scummyness. I'm not going to accept your tell on blind faith.

ok, guy. We'll rememeber how you defended scum tomorrow.

And we'll remember how you used vauge threats like this to bully everyone into voting for pooky.

[d8P]

Fos : the bunch of people who blindly followed a lead that we don't have

[TonyMontana]

unvote

This bandwagon *is* ridicolous.

Oh what, BabyJesus? Are you gonna "remember how I unvoted a scum tomorrow"?

[BabyJesus]

You haven't convinced me that he is scum. I'm not going to lynch someone just because you claim to have seen a tell. That may be good enough for some people, but unless you give me more, I'm not buying it. I'll vote for him if I you tell me what the tell is so that I can evaluate it for myself, or if I see signs of his scummyness. I'm not going to accept your tell on blind faith.

ok, guy. We'll rememeber how you defended scum tomorrow.

And we'll remember how you used vauge threats like this to bully everyone into voting for pooky.

when pooky comes up scum, I'll look pretty good...

[BabyJesus]

Pooky, if you're so innocent, why don't you just claim....

[zu_Faul]

Vote Tony Montana

At first you hop on this bandwagon, then you leave it after a few tell they don't like it. You don't give any reasons for your voting, besides that you like lynching Pooky. But Pooky can't be scum in every game. You are not searching to find scum. This is sheep-y. Additionally I won't follow BJ, if he doesn't even gives reasons other than gut feeling (at least it seems like this).

[TSAGod]

Now that Pooky has been active, I'll do what I actually was going to do before Baby Jesus was told.

unvote, vote LyingBrian

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Pooky, if you're so innocent, why don't you just claim....

This may come as a shock to you, but sometimes it is better to HIDE THINGS from scum.

[Monty]

unvote: vote lying brian

I hate "tells" I've been wrongly lynched a couple of times on tells (and rightly lynched too), but every time I feel like its just an excuse to bandwagon someone.

[BabyJesus]

Pooky, if you're so innocent, why don't you just claim....

This may come as a shock to you, but sometimes it is better to HIDE THINGS from scum.

except that you are scum here....

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

You´re wrong about that and you have nothing to back ur BS argument up other than a ¨tell¨ that is wrong and you can´t share with us.

Also, note that the first sentence quoted PRESUMES MY INNOCENCE with the ¨if you´re so innocent¨ clause, I´m pointing out what you´ve already stated in another game, you can´t rebutt this with an accusation of scumness in me because your first statement is based on my innocence, frankly your presumption and your rebuttal are contradictions and you´re committing what we call a ¨logical fallacy¨(more commonly known as spouting BS and puffing smoke in the air, quite a common scumtactic)

[Monty]

¨logical fallacy¨(more commonly known as spouting BS and puffing smoke in the air, quite a common scumtactic)

babyjesus being illogical has been known to happen whether he's scum or not.

[BabyJesus]

You´re wrong about that and you have nothing to back ur BS argument up other than a ¨tell¨ that is wrong and you can´t share with us.

Also, note that the first sentence quoted PRESUMES MY INNOCENCE with the ¨if you´re so innocent¨ clause, I´m pointing out what you´ve already stated in another game, you can´t rebutt this with an accusation of scumness in me because your first statement is based on my innocence, frankly your presumption and your rebuttal are contradictions and you´re committing what we call a ¨logical fallacy¨(more commonly known as spouting BS and puffing smoke in the air, quite a common scumtactic)

Pooky = scum

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

nice logic there

BJ = scum

see I can do it too!

[BabyJesus]

nice logic there

BJ = scum

see I can do it too!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Pooky love you long time?

[LyingBrian]

unvote

for now... let me reread the thread & see if i can come up w/ a better lead...

IGMEOY: PookyTheMagicalBear

[BabyJesus]

If you all MUST know, I don't have a "tell" on pooky. I have a game related reason to believe he is scum. That is why I need him to claim. I'm not a cop with an investigation, but it is pretty compelling evidence, depending on his claim.....

[LyingBrian]

vote: BabyJesus

[BabyJesus]

vote: BabyJesus

skimmer.

[Monty]

Babyjesus normally doesn't call someone out like this without good reason. I'm going to

unvote

and wait to hear more from pooky.

[Phoebus]

Vote Count

1 Baby J (Lying Brian)
6 Pooky (Fritzler, Baby J, Peacebringer, Flying Dutchman, Zippy, JSexton)

7 LyingBrian (d8p, StevieT92, Vesuvan, Pooky, Inhim, jajsoccer, TSAGod)

2 Gonzo (zu_Faul, Iammars)
1 Zu Faul (Yosarian2)
1 No Lynch (Gonzo)

13 votes to lynch

[Fritzler]

unvote,vote: lyingbrian

[BabyJesus]

unvote,vote: lyingbrian

attempt to swing momentum away from Pooky is noted....