1119: The Might of Mordor: Game Over

[ReaperCharlie]

My little sheep on what, MS?

Also, no, it's pretty much impossible to hurt my feelings.

[MasterSpy]

My little sheep on what, MS

Yes, Obv. Did you suddenly forget how to read for context?

I was asking your opinion on Gandalf (your slots little Sheep) and how he was clearly lying out of his ass and how that intersects with your Lynch All Liars statement above.

[ReaperCharlie]

What lie? Please quote it.

[gandalf5166]

MoI, you think I'm scum?

Hmmmm.

Must have missed that.

[MasterSpy]

What lie? Please quote it.

I already did quote it at the BOTTOM OF THE LAST PAGE. STOP BEING PURPOSEFULLY LAZY. But since you seem to enjoy acting like the poster child for ADHD …

You know what I think is funny? Literally all the people who think I'm scum have hardly ever played with me(SpyreX is the only one who has even played with me at all, IIRC). Somehow I doubt that that's a coincidence.

I explained in detail why he knew this was bullshit (he acknowledges my replace in with a comment about our shared history and when he was Town in said shared history).

--

MoI, you think I'm scum?

Hmmmm.

Must have missed that.

Yeah you tend to miss a lot when you don’t actually read the game but just sheep and post fluff like KEKEKEKEK.

You are in my pool of people who look scumtastic, but aren’t getting the rope today with SS and lurker Sevei. Once we deal with Plum and HoHum you can rest assured I’ll be looking more seriously at you.

[gandalf5166]

MoI, I'm not going to lie, I skim your posts sometimes. I probably missed wherever you called me scum.

I don't see how I acted differently in LOTR though, other than that I was maybe a little more independent. There's a reason for that though. That game, I had to take it on myself to get the game out of RVS(nobody had any serious suspicions until I did my jokeclaim), so I had to form my own opinions because nobody else had any yet. This game, Edge did that. So I'm playing a different role, although I did take some independence in my argument with SS.

[VasudeVa]

Three people I'm willing to lynch today:
AGM, SpyreX and MasterSpy.

AGM: What I've said during the last time I was here. Recent play is unconvincing.

SpyreX: Scum-read due to past meta. All I've seen so far are bad things. SpyTown = obvTown. If Spy isn't being obvTown, the chance of a scumSpy is very very very high. See my other post where I commented on him being weird, and recent posts are too lynch hungry and active lurky for me to be comfortable with.

MasterSpy: Upon review, esurio was pretty bad. Her self-imbue without much explanation in ISO 1 is p. bad, the transition of her thoughts between ISO 4 & 5 to 6 don't make sense. At first she spends some time defending Plum, and she was willing to believe that Plum's memory was faulty...but then finds a way to slink into the wagon by accusing her lurkiness. Makes no sense, nope.
And, holy fucking shit. He's deliberately bringing back "OMG YOR LYING ABOUT PAST META!!" discussions with his #473. This shit already happened with Plum and you're bringing it back again?

Lesee here...eeeenni, meenii, mineee, mo!

vote: MasterSpy

(Plus, I have an MoI D1 lynch streak going on and I dun wanna break it. >:D)

---
I'm a bit more comfortable with quadz again recently, so...

imbue: quadz

@Gandalf:

What's your take on MasterSpy right now?

[AlmasterGM]

You know what I think is funny? Literally all the people who think I'm scum have hardly ever played with me(SpyreX is the only one who has even played with me at all, IIRC). Somehow I doubt that that's a coincidence.

So what are you saying? That you are always act like a scummy moron and we should thus give you a free pass?

[AlmasterGM]

Three people I'm willing to lynch today:
AGM, SpyreX and MasterSpy.

This is a bad list of three.

[VasudeVa]

Three people I'm willing to lynch today:
AGM, SpyreX and MasterSpy.

This is a bad list of three.

Why?

[gandalf5166]

You know what I think is funny? Literally all the people who think I'm scum have hardly ever played with me(SpyreX is the only one who has even played with me at all, IIRC). Somehow I doubt that that's a coincidence.

So what are you saying? That you are always act like a scummy moron and we should thus give you a free pass?

No, simply that anybody who has experience with town-me and scum-me knows that this isn't scum-me.

[MasterSpy]

I don't see how I acted differently in LOTR though, other than that I was maybe a little more independent. There's a reason for that though. That game, I had to take it on myself to get the game out of RVS(nobody had any serious suspicions until I did my jokeclaim), so I had to form my own opinions because nobody else had any yet. This game, Edge did that. So I'm playing a different role, although I did take some independence in my argument with SS.

I read through your ISO in LOTR and I respectfully disagree. No signs of sheeping of anyone to be found. Sparing use of all-caps and little fluffy KEKEKEK crap.

Futhermore the ‘getting out of RVS’ excuse doesn’t really mean much. RVS tends to end very soon.

--

And, holy fucking shit. He's deliberately bringing back "OMG YOR LYING ABOUT PAST META!!" discussions with his #473. This shit already happened with Plum and you're bringing it back again?

I’m sorry I missed the part where I wasn’t able to make observations in the game.

vote: MasterSpy(Plus, I have an MoI D1 lynch streak going on and I dun wanna break it. >:D)

This is further evidence you just are bad at this game, not that half the game doesn’t already know this.

1. Calling 1 game a streak is classic.
2. So you want to continue that ‘streak’ where you lynched me as Town? Yeah, that’s smart

Do us all a favor and lay of the weed. It’s irreparably damaged your cognitive functions.

However I do appreciate you are so willing to park you vote somewhere away from either of the dominant wagons so close to deadline, especially somewhere you have no chance of successfully starting a wagon. Both you and Singer doing that provides good information for future days.

[ReaperCharlie]

Three people I will lynch:

MasterSpy, Plum, Maritya/hohum

[gandalf5166]

Yes, RVS ended early, but I ended it, which put me at a different place in the game........ Whatever.

[Edge]

Three people I will lynch:

MasterSpy, Plum, Maritya/hohum

I AM FATE AND I APPROVE OF THIS MESSAGE

[quadz08]

HOHUM.
HE HAD A LEGITIMATE EXCUSE.
You have yet to provide one that allows you to keep posting in the thread without contributing anything.

I owe you a larger post but I've at least hinted about my intentions at this point. Implying that my posts are contentless is a scum-stretch.

This literally made me laugh out loud. I mean, really. I actually laughed at this post. I am flat out STATING that your posts are contentless, hohum, and if you think otherwise, you're delusional.

Also, I apparently need to re-read MasterSpy. I've gotten a town vibe from him, but everybody and their mother seems to think he's scummy, so I'll take a look at that when I've got more time.

[Andrius]

Day One, Lynch-Count Eleven

Plum (4): AlmasterGM, Edge, gandalf5166, SpyreX
hohum (3): quadz08, MasterSpy, Katy
AlmasterGM (1): Plum
gandalf5166 (1): singersigner
Katy (1): hohum
MasterSpy (1): VasudeVa

Not Voting (1): Sevei

Day One, Imbue-Count Eleven

quadz08 (6): Plum, MasterSpy, Katy, Edge, singersigner, VasudeVa
AlmasterGM (4): AlmasterGM, SpyreX, hohum, quadz08
SpyreX (1): gandalf5166

Not Voting (1): Sevei

Notices

With 12 alive it takes 7 to Lynch and/or Imbue.
Deadline is set at Thursday, February 10th, at 1:00pm PST.

[Fate]

Three people I will lynch:

MasterSpy, Plum, Maritya/hohum

I AM FATE AND I APPROVE OF THIS MESSAGE

....

[ReaperCharlie]

[ReaperCharlie]

Impersonating my hydra buddy FTW

[Andrius]

POST IN HYDRA PL0X.

[AlmasterGM]

Why?

Because I'm not scum and SpyreX-scum should be dependent on flipz. MasterSpy I am "meh" on in general, have to look at that a bit more.

And serious business time, I don't mind RC and Fate not posting in the hydra put posting in the hydra and then PRETENDING TO BE THE OTHER ONE is waaaaaay too confusing. plz stop.

[AlmasterGM]

thx andrius

[Sevei]

First, I’m assuming that either no one knows what “teaparty” is, even though at least two of you who posted after I asked have USED the term in this game, or that you’re just not reading all the posts. I want to know what it means, so if you know, could you please tell me? Thanks.

Second, I didn’t have Internet or power for the better part of last week, and a lot has happened; I unfortunately also got off to a slow start before that, but, AGAIN, I should be able to contribute more regularly now, barring anymore interference from the weather. (I live in a rural area, in the South, where we are not always prepared to deal with things like snow and ice.)

Thoughts on the Game:

(given as succinctly as possible)

I still believe Plum is scum, for all the reasons that have been listed before.

The cases on Hohum are also compelling. I also don't like that Mari replaced out not only after being pressured, but after having serious and potentially damning questions put to her; Hohum's attitude to today also leaves much to be desired.

It is notable that when MasterSpy replaced in, Mina made a case on Singer (who MoI has mentioned briefly since then, but is not focusing on) and MoI made a case on Mari. Up until this point neither Singer nor Mari had been truly scrutinized (aside from Quadz’s case on Mari which was at a standstill), and now Mari/Hohum is a likely lynch candidate. Also, when MS entered the game and these cases were made, what happened? Attention was taken away from Plum, and she has since relaxed and no longer seems quite as driven by the nervous energy that informed her early play.

***

It’s a bit of a conundrum that MS is in fact a hydra; dealing with both heads (and one that apparently “waffles” a lot) allows for a certain amount of grace for inconsistency that isn’t afforded to the rest of us. MS scum could be getting away with target fishing and fence-sitting solely because of this, which I don’t like—especially since MoI has pointed out how often Mina is waffling in their QT. I often find drawing attention to something like that is a tell of sorts; it’s something he’s worried about, so he mentions it to sort of diffuse suspicions of it. Also of note: Mina’s first post was very sympathetic to Plum; MoI’s posts considerably less so.

He has said this:

Deadline is coming rather quickly – we need to get the Imbue hammered before HoHum or Plum takes the rope.

and this

Once we deal with Plum and HoHum you can rest assured I’ll be looking more seriously at you.

yet his entire “case” on Plum is this:

The case on Plum (calling Edge obv-Town early yet forgetting it actually included Fate) is so-so but Plum’s reaction isn’t what I would expect from Plum-Town. In [REDACTED] the mention by me that she wasn’t obv-Town (not scum mind you, just not obv-Town) was met with an immediate and emotional attack.

Her response to Edge here is much more along the line of ‘Ooops, tehehehe’.

Damning? No.

But inconsistent enough that I think it scummy.

And he doesn't even think it's damning, but he's got her in the top two of his reads, enough so that he mentions her twice in conjunction with lynching.


My top three scum reads are Plum, MS, and Hohum.

The problem with this is that I don’t see how Hohum and MS would work as partners, especially if we also have Plum-scum…why would MS come in and clear one buddy by attacking another (who wasn’t even really in danger at that time)?

MS and Plum make sense as partners to me; Plum’s relief at being removed from the spotlight is apparent. MS is keeping a safe distance from Plum, not totally clearing her but not focusing on her, either. I can also see the Hohum/Plum pairing, but Mari’s early interactions with Plum didn’t strike me that way; I need to do some more rereading for that.

Either way, I can only fit two of these three into a scum equation, and Plum fits in both pairings. I’ve got an “either/or” read on MS and Hohum; still trying to work it out.

Vote: Plum

L-2

Imbue: Quadz

Hammer

[gandalf5166]

It's MS.

Hohum's just an ass.

If it weren't for the fact that quadz is town by PoE, I would have serious words for you guys.