Mini 1113 - Brotherhood of the Wolf Mafia

[CooLDoG]

Okay, I'll kill kat. Any objections to that?

[Untrod Tripod]

I don't think UK is the best use of your shot, CD. Ideally a vig shot doesn't make the town want to lynch the vig immediately.

Zang or Kats would be better.

ninja'd by...a lot of posts
the flavor thing is...interesting. For the record, a daykill does NOT prove CD's alignment one way or the other (as per the rules post), and him vigging a player who is by popular consensus pretty town is a really stupid move on his part whether he's town or scum. Just saying.

2nd edit

OH GOD THE POSTING. OH GOD.

3rd edit

CD - DON'T FUCKING SHOOT UK IT IS A TERRIBLE PLAY IF YOU ARE TOWN

4TH EDIT

ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

yeah, I could get behind a Kat vig

[UncertainKitten]

Where the hell did that come from?

Also, intriguingly enough, I'd more suspect HF over Kat.

Basically, when I made my initial guess, I forgot that HF had also been poking me with bad logic.

As it stands, I'd put HF/GreyICE as the team, with Kat as an outlier. Kat is just probably wrong.

[CooLDoG]

Okay, so you change your scum team huh... interesting.

Any objection to an hf vig?

[GhostWriter]

I'd prefer HF as well. Kat is still an easy lynch to make. People support his lynching more than those that support HF's, it feels.

[UncertainKitten]

EBWOP: I'd like to note that this theory REQUIRES CD to be scum. That is far from clear at this juncture. The flavor makes it a valid theory, in my opinion.

It would likely be better just to shoot someone who by general consensus is scummy. Like UT, SC, HF, etc.

@CD: I didn't change it. HF and GI are both within HF/Kat/GI

And HF would be a wonderful shot, actually. I wonder if you'll actually do it though.

[GhostWriter]

And HF would be a wonderful shot, actually. I wonder if you'll actually do it though.

You've been called out, you have to do it now.

[Untrod Tripod]

Where the hell did that come from?

Also, intriguingly enough, I'd more suspect HF over Kat.

Basically, when I made my initial guess, I forgot that HF had also been poking me with bad logic.

As it stands, I'd put HF/GreyICE as the team, with Kat as an outlier. Kat is just probably wrong.

IMO, it came from CD realizing that daykilling doesn't make him look town so he needed to not vig a popular-consensus-town-player so he won't get lynched, so he picked a low-impact kill

I forgot about HF too. Must be all the not posting at all. Hell, I think he deserves daykilling for the Midol comment alone. JK.

Edit 1

I also prefer HF to Kats.

[UncertainKitten]

Not necessarily. The town still has to agree to it in something resembling a consensus of more than two people.

[Mariyta]

No objection to an HF vig here... if I get ever get past all the ninja posts...

[CooLDoG]

hmmm... hf sounds good to me, would like some other people to get in on it.

[LimMePls]

Actually, given UK's response, I think you should shoot UK. See

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=15549

For a similar freak out from scum UK.

[UncertainKitten]

SK UK, actually. And different circumstances. Do you have a town meta of me in a similar situation, LMP?

[UncertainKitten]

The problem with meta is you have to have examples of ALL alignments before you use it. So, please, LMP, try not to be dumb about this.

[CooLDoG]

I'm gonna read into it... As I have said I haven't pmed yet. And I still have the gun "loaded".

[LimMePls]

when I say "scum" I mean it in the general "not town aligned" sense. Yes that was SK you, but the point still stands.

All I'm saying is that your freak out now does not seem town like to me. It seems bent on survival.

[UncertainKitten]

In fact, let's make this easier for people

Here's the post right after Nacho claims he got an (erroneous) guilty cop result on me

In fact, I'd say this supports me being TOWN, LMP. Since I "knew" Nacho was lying and reacted as such.

Well, what you're saying is pretty much a pile of bollocks and effectively useless. META DOESN'T WORK.

[UncertainKitten]

And yes, I would like to survive, LMP, now that the gun isn't guaranteed trained on me. I'm not a good vig shot. I'm not a good lynch. There is a list of people who would be a LOT BETTER DEAD than I am. Excuse me if I know this and ain't afraid to say it.

[UncertainKitten]

EBWOP: But at least if CD HAD shot me out of hand things would have been clearer to everyone.

[CooLDoG]

still reading, however your play seems similar...

[UncertainKitten]

Sure. But I was also an

investigation immune

SK. Nacho should not have gotten a guilty result on me. As it turned out, the mod fucked up.

In that instance, my play would more mirror my TOWN play than my SCUM play.

[CooLDoG]

I have to go out at 3:30 (cst) and thus I won't be able to post. Have a good time arguing over my vig kill while I'ma gone.

[CooLDoG]

@uk, nija edit, sounds like shit justifications to me.

[UncertainKitten]

That's great. The thing is you're also a self admitted fucking moron. So I highly doubt you'd know a shit justification if you dropped one in the toilet.

[GreyICE]

CooLDoG... I'm just not going to comment. I posted two logical reasons you should be town (no scumbuddy defense, tracker claim) and you just made me rethink both of them. Don't threaten people, that's anti-town.

They're right, you're called out for that horrible play. If you're both town (although I don't like the odds on UK) it's going to be garbage if you shoot her, then we lynch you, and eliminate two town instantly. Lets see how one of UK's scumreads flips. I know I'm town, so if Fitz flips town, that "two of these three are scum" shit is going to look even more garbage than it already does to me. He thinks UK is scum too, so he's fucking obvscum as well, right UK? Your OMGUS chip on the shoulder is ridiculous.

For the record, my head is still overruling my gut on CooLDoG, although my gut is wavering. I think he's town.

PEDIT: Suddenly, a barrage of posts! Lemme read.