Open 269: Multirole Mafia: Over. Town Win

[drmyshottyizsik]

scum WOULD say that!

Enjoy the Wifom.

[Chronopie]

Apparently it's Shotty's birthday. Have a good one.

(If I'm early, it's due to timezone difference.)

--

The Second Vote Count of Day Five

Shotty

(1): mothrax

[L-1]

mothrax

(1): Shotty

[L-1]

Not voting (1): Sleepless Assassin

With

3

alive, it takes

2

to lynch. (No Lynch also requires

2.

)

This VC is still valid btw.

[drmyshottyizsik]

yep it's my B day! well in 2 hours where i am.

[Chronopie]

Sleepless Assassin has been prodded. mothrax will be due for prodding tomorrow.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Sad face andrew was right. I really thought SA would be scum over moth.

[Sleepless Assassin]

I'll be looking at some ISOs and things tonight.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Ok, take your time.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Ok, first thing I want to look at is the chess lynch.

Chesskid3 (7): Andrew, Akira, Chevre, Chaotic Neutrality, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Sleepless Assassin, gandalf5166
Chevre (1): implosion
implosion (1): ThAdmiral
JesseSheffield (1): chkflip
Akira (1): Chesskid3

Gandalf's hammer has been brought up a few times. However, Chaotic and Chevre were both on the Chess wagon and although scum are often on Day 1 mislynches, it's rare to see all of them on there.

VOTE: chesskid

I realize he's on vacation, but if he has time to do that, he has time to explain his opinion-flip.

I really don't think he realized that this vote was the hammer.

Looking at Chevre's ISO, I see this:

Nah, gandalf is town in this one.

I think Akira needs pressure though.

Unvote

Vote: Akira

Fixed so that Akira may have actually been pressured.

Unvote; vote chesskid3

This is only the third vote and comes with a quote where Chess had just called Gandalf town. Seems like scum would be less likely to vote someone right after they call a scumbuddy town. Especially without even acknowledging that part of the quote.

Vote: drmyshottyizsik

I know you cannot answer for gandalf, but no one can deny what he did yesterday was scummy. He hammered yesterday without and a claim and with questions still left unanswered, and then replaced out yet still posted in the thread after being replaced.

This is a bullshit attack from scum. I don't read it as bussing.

I wanted to see Chk's stance on the chess lynch, but he seems to avoid being around it.

Next, the Akira lynch. Chk and Shotty both ended up on that wagon. Chk danced around it a little while, but eventually voted with a promise to explain later on. However, we never got that due to his emergency VLA. He seemed fine putting Akira at L-1 though and did so with confidence. I read that as pretty townie... Except one thing. The L-1 vote comes after he was called on misreading 4 days as 4 votes. That in mind, it looks like a people pleaser vote. Shotty put a lot of effort into making sure his vote was explained. I see town intent there.

unvote

NO I DIDN'T VOTE NO LYNCH!

Voting the mod is the same thing. ^.^

This is the strongest tell I see so far. This has a townie "OMG NO THATS NOT WHAT I MEANT I DONT WANNA LOSE" vibe to it rather than a scum "OMG THIS IS GONNA MAKE ME LOOK BAD, FIX IT" vibe.

As far as the claims...

If Mothrax is scum, he has the RB/Rolecop abilities. Claiming Cop/RB is pretty much standard procedure. The claim does nothing for me.

So yeah, I'm leaning Moth as scum. Moth, give me reasons why I should see you as town and reasons why Shotty is scum.

Shotty, give me some input here.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Why'd you ISO chevre? Moth replaced Chkflip

[Sleepless Assassin]

Chevre was scum.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Oh so you were looking for connections? Ok.
Well, um SA I thought you were scum so I don't really have any reasons to why Mothrax is scum other than I'm town.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Moth, I'm voting you in my next post unless you give me good reason not to. If you are town, save the game for us in your next post.

[mothrax]

Sorry, work bit me in the rear.

As for why DMSIS is scum, see my last post.

As for why I am town that is an inherantly difficult question to answer.

I would point to where I replaced in to start. I immediatly went along with the claims, and when I was asked to I full claimed without issue, something scum would be hesitant to do. Yes there was pressure from andrew, but there wasn't any real pressure.

The next day I followed andrew's controlling of PR. I did not roleblock anyone. Mainly because I picked up on his tells easily. I knew he was conf town before he came out and said it. I roleblocked last night because I knew after ThAd flipped doc, one of the two of you is scum.

Also, look at today: Why would I have put the game in your hands if I were scum. We are both aware of shotty's reputation on site no? He also discussed previous suspicion of you. Why confirm you as town?

[Sleepless Assassin]

You make it sound like you claimed before catching up. Wrong.

You make it sound like you are town for using your RB how andrew told you to. Wrong.

My personal favorite. You make it sound like you CHOSE to confirm me as town. DEAD WRONG. I confirmed myself AFTER
YOU VOTED THINKING I WAS ALREADY CONFIRMED.

DROP THAT HAMMAH MC!

vote mothrax

[mothrax]

Um, ou did miss a spot, you were confirmed town the second I voted for shotty. But hey, I will accept this blemish on my scum record. Replacing in under that much pressure was redic...
I knew I should have gone for you instead of shotty.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Sweet!

Good game. That was NOT easy lol. Everything just pointed to town for shotty and scum for you.

That was fun.

[chesskid3]

worst town ever

[chesskid3]

no offense, but when you need andrew94 to shoot your scum
you know you suck

[drmyshottyizsik]

Chesskid Andrew is a lot better than you.
AND YAY! I WIN!

[mothrax]

I am actually impressed with the town play, especially Andrew. I will be honest I didn't expect to last as long as I did. Sorry Chevre and CN. I couldn't pull it off.

[drmyshottyizsik]

I'm very surprised I wasn't lynched. Not only for being me, but for that stupid stupid mistake that Gandalf made.

[chesskid3]

Chesskid Andrew is a lot better than you.
AND YAY! I WIN!

you shut your fucking face or I will shut it for you.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Psyduck uses psybeam it is super effective!

[gandalf5166]

Congrats to andrew. Your play has really improved recently, and I'm glad I didn't run you off in SCIENCE mafia.

[gandalf5166]

However, I have some words to share with the mod. When you can't even get the D1 flip right, you have a problem.