Firstly, Jack is completely spot on with bobsnox scum. IS being C makes perfect sense.
If that's the case, then:
Leak 15 wrote:C is very spot on with his scum reads. He should be our first NK.
bobsnox was called out as a suspect by IS in
this post, he is all over dana, and the inHim/VV slot gets a lick in
this post. I'm definitely a suspect of his as well, but if bobs is scum with inHim it makes perfect sense for them to want to kill him... But the leaks also suggest bob's scum with Katsuki.... IS's Fate-hate was stronger after the leaked message.
Hmmm. Well, bobs will be dead soon.
Also,
Percy wrote:But seriously SpyreX cancel that nuke on Snake, he's still probably town.
I never understood the Jed-hate, and I didn't understand the Snake-hate, either. I can see SpyreX scum nuking the easy target. I have been getting weird vibes from SpyreX and Fate, and something tells me that SpyreX is playing Fate like a fiddle.
Katsuki wrote:AV seems rather overdefensive over this post HRMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
Scum here.
Bus?
Katsuki wrote:IF INHIM FLIPS SCUM BATTLESHIP FATE IS HIGHLY GUARENTEED SCUM BUDDY
Bus?
Or it could be scum trying to hunt the other team....
Leak 13 wrote:WE SHALL BUS INTO THE SUNSET, AND WATCH THE SKY TURN RED IN OUR GLORY
Important context, pointed out by Jack:
Jack wrote:He posted it during the toog/fate fight.
Still,
Sociopath wrote:I didn't screw around with QT WIFOM the first game, and certainly wouldn't start now.
I believe SP, and I get a town vibe from him this game. I'd say someone like AV, with his self-confessed brilliance at imitating other people, could just as easily be responsible.
@Sociopath
: I understand that my participation in this game has been sporadic, and the scum code is relatively simple. All I can say is that I'm town, and my access has been legitimately affected by RL.
Jack wrote:AV may be town...hmm.
Why did you say this? I don't follow.
Jack wrote:I forgot, with the lower case letters going the opposite, this:
c on the other hand is easily lynched, even though he is also accurate. They should be the first targets we look at, and it will look like cross-killing.
Is them talking about sociopath.
If that's the case, then I can't see why they would describe him as "accurate", unless this was bobs talking, since SP doesn't like him much...
AurorusVox wrote:RE: Snake...=_="
Ironic that the slot that wanted to control nukes is the first to get nuked.
I WANT THIS LYNCH SO BAD
DizzyIzzyB13 wrote:The trouble with the leaks Percy posted is that we can't properly evaluate them with any sort of certainty as to how skeptical we should be of the messages until Percy is confirmed one way or the other. That means he needs to die. The nature of the evesdropped posts suggests that the scum teams are being careful as to the information that is being put in their QT, so they may be quite comfortable with their information or disinformtion being put in the public sphere. They may not decided to kill him. Thus, town has to consider whether it's worth killing Percy ourselves, since as far as I'm aware, that's the only way to be 100% sure of his allegience and thus the context of the messages he's leaked.
It's true that the scum may be happy to introduce WIFOM into the town, and therefore keep me alive. But consider this: neither scumteam can use their quicktopics how they want to; to engage in frank discussion about who they want NKed, about who should be lynched the next day, and so on. The scum will be very relieved when I'm dead, I assure you.
Secondly, there are ways to confirm me other than killing me. For example, you can use the leaks I provided to catch people on both the scumteams.
Finally, I don't see how my death will make you any more certain about any of the leaks.
Could you give me one example of just one leak where the knowledge that I'm town would change your read of it?
Fate wrote:Many people can "FAKE" my play style.
"FAKE" it FUCKING FAKE IMPLIES FAKE NOT REAL IMPLIES FAKE.
THAT DROPPED QT MESSAGE WAS A LEVEL OF MIMICRY OF SUCH HIGH QUALITY THAT
IT COULD"VE ONLY COME FROM A CHINESE CRYPTOLOGIST MASTERPOSTER SOCIOPATH.
Bolded does not compute. I think this is probably town-Fate rampaging through another bad theory.
Jack wrote:bobsnox nuke is awesome.
Yes.
Jack wrote:ok. bobsnox is the one who we KNOW is in the taichi/rogue mafia group. So if he flips russian, then inhim is rogue (targetting fate, etc). If he flips chinese, then rogue is dana. I think he will flip chinese.
This is my conclusion as well.
Jack wrote:CHINESE--BOBS, KATS, DANA
RUSSIANS--INHIM, AV, DIZZY
I can actually get behind this list. I sure am agreeing with Jack a lot, but that's because he is AWESOME.
Still, I think Kitoari is a fucking great suspect. His attitude towards the chesskid lynch was absolutely terribad.
Jack wrote:dana is the aicraft carrier and targetted fate, rogue targetted "e" which is fate. fate needed to be blocked because he was going to nuke dana. so they wanted to lynch fate instead to save the roleblock. There's no similar kind of "need" for doctor on fate who isn't even on the team! And if he was, lynching him wouldn't help.
The bawwwwing about lack of modkill makes me think Fate might be scum. In my experience only scum get that hot and bothered about modkills. And his defensive nuke mode is
These nukes are going to be great, and I still like my vote. No new leaks, will post them if they come.
Summary:
From least likely scum to most likely, it's
{bobsnox, AurorusVox, (DizzyIzzy + Kitoari), danakillsu, chesskid3, Fate, SpyreX, Mina, Faraday, Sociopath, Jack}
...in decreasing order of scummitude. I don't know how chesskid's done it, but I think he's town now. If he's scum then I will be seriously impressed.
