Mini 245 - Stick Figures Mafia - Game Over!

[Blackberry]

After thinking awhile... I agree with not killing either of them. It is a 100% guarantee that one of them is scum.

I have quite an idea, it will highly increase our victory...

If Cop claims, scum will be forced to kill the REAL doc tonite. That will give the cop protection and some results in the open. Next day we can lynch the fake-doc. Then Cop will probably be killed and with the added results, we'll been in pretty good shape.

Before cop claims, what do you all think of my idea?

[Karo]

Before cop claims, what do you all think of my idea?

[shelper]

If there even is a cop, mind you. There is no rule saying all games

must

have a cop. For all we knew we got given two docs and no cops for balance.

[Changling bob]

I think he is scum....

Why?

@Blackberry: thats some nice telling the town what to do.

FoS

[BabyJesus]

After thinking awhile... I agree with not killing either of them. It is a 100% guarantee that one of them is scum.

I have quite an idea, it will highly increase our victory...

If Cop claims, scum will be forced to kill the REAL doc tonite. That will give the cop protection and some results in the open. Next day we can lynch the fake-doc. Then Cop will probably be killed and with the added results, we'll been in pretty good shape.

Before cop claims, what do you all think of my idea?

I think the cop coming out is a good idea...especially if he has scum.

[Bacde]

@Blackberry: thats some nice telling the town what to do.

FoS

Sometimes if you have a good idea you have to tell them to the town. Let the people rejoice!

[Changling bob]

@Blackberry: thats some nice telling the town what to do.

FoS

Sometimes if you have a good idea you have to tell them to the town. Let the people rejoice!

The way blackberry posted it seemed more like "well my plan's going to go through, but just in case...."

Could just be me though.

[Karo]

Yeah, so once the doc's out of the way, mafia don't have to go through the trouble of guessing whom to nightkill.

We have scum in front of our noses and people are arguing about outing the cop.

[Bacde]

But assuming one doctor is the for-real deal, and that the other is a lying cheating scumbag, it puts the mafia into a dilemma as to whether or not they should kill the real doctor, as it would be almost like putting the noose around one of their own members.

I don't really know if I agree with the idea of outing the cop, because I assume that if we have a cop, that the person doesn't have a guilty investigation right now.

[Dragon Phoenix]

Side note: I may not have access until Thursday evening.

[BabyJesus]

can we focus on lynching mathcam pls....

[mathcam]

I agree. The topic of lynching mathcam deserves a lot more focus. BabyJesus, why don't you take up the charge here and explain why anyone should join you on the mathcam bandwagon. And, if you don't have anything to contribute on this front, then focusing on the mathcam bandwagon

still

has had a positive effect: We'll now have more reasons to lynch BabyJesus.

Cam

[Tyfo]

I agree. The topic of lynching mathcam deserves a lot more focus. BabyJesus, why don't you take up the charge here and explain why anyone should join you on the mathcam bandwagon. And, if you don't have anything to contribute on this front, then focusing on the mathcam bandwagon

still

has had a positive effect: We'll now have more reasons to lynch BabyJesus.

Cam

Touché (I actually do not know what the word means, but it sounded fitting after this).

[LyingBrian]

touché - an acknowledgement of the success, appropriateness or superiority of an argument

[BabyJesus]

I agree. The topic of lynching mathcam deserves a lot more focus. BabyJesus, why don't you take up the charge here and explain why anyone should join you on the mathcam bandwagon.

Because at night, when the rest of us sleep, I think you kill people.

[LyingBrian]

@BabyJesus

i think what we're looking for is what is the core reason why you think mathcam is scum?

has he done/not done something we missed? or are you just working off a gut feeling?

[BabyJesus]

@BabyJesus

i think what we're looking for is what is the core reason why you think mathcam is scum?

has he done/not done something we missed? or are you just working off a gut feeling?

Just not getting a townie feel from his posts. Seems to be planting ideas to see what will stick, even suggesting we lynch people he thinks are clean... I don't usually see townie's ok with wanting to lynch innocents.

So yea, its mostly a gut feeling.

Although Blackberry could get my vote also.

[mathcam]

...why don't you take up the charge here and explain why anyone should join you on the mathcam bandwagon.

Because at night, when the rest of us sleep, I think you kill people.

No, this is why

you

are on my bandwagon. I asked for reasons why

other

people should join your bandwagon.

In any case, your last post was sufficient. I don't see why you have to be prodded 3 times just to make a post that actually contains content, especially since

you

are the one who complains about the pace of the games on this site being so slow.

CB is still my top suspicion, but AI might have to reread day 1 with his claim in mind, to see if it melds well.

Mod

: Can we get a vote count?

Cam

[BabyJesus]

CB is still my top suspicion, but AI might have to reread day 1 with his claim in mind, to see if it melds well.


Cam

Still. no reason to lynch either of them today in my opinion....

[Karo]

Blackberrie's posting 375, in which he proposes to make the cop claim does not sit well with me. I very much doubt this strategy will "

highly increase our victory...

".

My best idea is to focus on those players who were not on the Narninian 'wagon (even though it includes me), as there is a good chance at least one of them is scum.

From those people

Tyfo

is the most suspicious to me. Then there is

CB

, I can't deceide if he was genuinly against this strategy in general or because a fellow mafioso was in danger of being lynched. As I had similar arguments against this lynch, I am really unsure what to think about him at the moment.
Finally there is

Blackberry

, which ranks third for the above mentioned posting.

[Tyfo]

And then there is

Karo

...

[BabyJesus]

unvote, vote blackberry

[BrianMcQueso]

Mod: Can we get a vote count?

No.

[mathcam]

Mod: Can we get a vote count?

No.

Damn. I really wanted to know how many votes everyone had. Oh well. Guess I'm playing today in the dark.

Still. no reason to lynch either of them today in my opinion....

I think I probably agree, and Blackberry might be a good alternative choice.

Cam

[Changling bob]

vote: BJ

Gogo circle-jerk logic.

I do however agree that neither myself nor Tyfo should be lynch, despite the fact that one of us is scum.

I also still have a bad-ish feeling about blackberry, although I'm not too sure about that.