Convict's Revenge!! Game Over (Convict Wins!)

[chesskid3]

Unvote

Vote: Lekdslfjaldsjfasdfj

spotty internet until 1/2/11

[Faraday]

Gud - why didn't you claim your kills at the time?
Also, why did you not change your vote to Faraday when you realized your mistake in 507?
And why did you kill MBF when you thought Faraday was scum?
Did you use a different weapon type for each kill?

er. why would he think I'm scum, it goes against his theory of 1 scum per room (I was with almaster) the clarification was about who was in the room with Alm. Anyway i'm being lazy. gud is pretty obv town btw.

[xvart]

Faraday, that's fine. I'm probably misreading the post but I was just trying to follow his thought process. I thought he said you were scum, not MBF whom he had voted and then killed.

[Faraday]

Yeah, I know, his clarification of what he was talking about is unclear, I'm just assuming he's not going against his own theory immediately.

[Guderian]

Faraday is right, I think there is one scum per room.

Alamaster was in Faradays room
Kitoari was in mine
Mike was in another with ckd who is town and dead. (also flameaxe)
~here be other rooms~

[chesskid3]

so that makes flameaxe scum, according to speculation?

[Guderian]

assuming he is the only other person in that room.

[chesskid3]

but your post implied you knew that was the case

[Guderian]

those are the only people who have reported being in that room. I assume it is eminently possible for people to have not gone into every room they are capable of going into.

For example, you claimed you could go into a room but were restricted somehow. So there are probably more people under the same circumstance or who chose not to.

But if he was the only other person in that room, I recommend vigging him immediately.

[chesskid3]

no I never said that.
I said time to find out if I can go anywhere
asked the mod
and was told I couldn't go anywhere

[Katsuki]

I too am curious how gud got to 6 if he gained the notoriety claimed.

I detailed this already. Are people just not reading my posts?

Considering you only claimed 2 kills of a total of 5 notoriety...

Unvote

Vote: Lekdslfjaldsjfasdfj

Who?

[Guderian]

Vote: Katsuki

Not reading thread. Already explained where other point came from, and xvart independently pseudo confirmed it. Not really caring about detail is not town sided.

Voting posion ivy when I'm almost 100% sure she is town (as should anyone else) is scummy.

Wait what.

There's been 23 pages, and THIS is all you have to comment on?!

What exactly are you commenting on? Not much from the looks of things.

[Katsuki]

I don't see where you said it. Mind pointing it out?

That reminds me, if you've found me scummy for so long, why did you not shoot me? I'm curious.

[xvart]

I don't see where you said it. Mind pointing it out?

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 4#p2697774

[vezokpiraka]

@Guderian: Tel hat strong willed means and then I'll tell you at what i need it. It won't work the other way.

[chesskid3]

Dafish's replacement is lesomething

[PoisonIvy]

vez

Why do you need to know what strong willed is? Surely if it's in your role pm then you could hypothetically pm the mod if you needed to know?

~14 works of work. broken sleep thanks to Rihanna from the flatmates room. Be back properly....... uh............. 1st of January. Getting my drink on from tomorrow~

[vezokpiraka]

I need to know.

And I can't ask the mod about it. If a lot of people have strong will than it means you an tell me. I will tell you after you tell me.

[xvart]

I forgot the vote count had been reset.

VOTE: PoisonIvy

I understand Gud's thinking with at least one scum being able to get into every room but that sort of speculation at this time does little to dissuade me from her scumminess. Seriously, the dodging is getting ridiculous, and she even said herself that dodging questions is a scumtell.

Not going into too much detail on things to light yet. Still awaiting xvart's explanation but work has me flat out. Been called in AGAIN for tomorrow aka my former day off. Now working everyday til Stephens day (26th). Stephens day is my friends traditional ALL OUT BOOZE DAY. But I will however continue to check in.

As far as I can tell she never went into detail on things yet like she said, unless she was overstating her observations to begin with. Also, she's waiting on an explanation from me (before going into more detail?) about something I don't know that I'm supposed to be explaining and then continues to not clarify when directly asked.

[Guderian]

Normally I don't do one of these, but I need to coalesce my thoughts on the players remaining. Will be pretty stream of consciouses-y. feel free to comment on anything, as there has been far to little discussion today, especially for a large theme game.

2. TheLonging

Iso 24 puts him into town category.
Plus the fact he is pretty suspicious of me, I give him town points.
Would definitely like to see some more thoughts from him though. While his ideas have been good, they in no way help guide the town or influence it significantly.

Overall:

town

3. Chesskid3

What is this I dont even...
Sorry, but this iso is disheartening. I don't see anything to make me think he is acting to help town. The good news is he doesn't seem to be acting to help scum either. Still, that doesn't mean town in the slightest.

Overall:

Null

5. PoisonIvy

I like for several reasons.
Pro-town content, not afraid to voice an unpopular decision, and game related helping as well (the tape)
This should definitely NOT be the lynch today, or the foreseeable future.

Overall:

Town

7. Vezokpiraka

Still not sure why he wants to know what strong willed means.
Classic lurking in this game.

Overall:

Slightly scummish

9. Katsuki

Already detailed.

Overall:

Scum

10. Faraday

For now, room theory clears this man.
Plus, several posts scream town to me.

Overall:

Town

11. Flameaxe

I liked this guy, but am slowly drifting away from that view.
Mostly gut at this point, I'll reread his posts to see if i can nail down my feelings.

Overall:

Null

12. Seraphim

Whoa, he is in this game?

Lets replace him.

Seriously. December 23?

Overall:

Null

13. Midknight's Sorrow

Holy batman after an iso read I dont like this dude.
Iso 17 looks to be posting just to post
and for some reason his voting of Flameaxe looks wrong.
Good news is if one of these two (MS-Flame) flip scum, I think the other looks town.

Overall:

Scum

15. populartajo

Like iso 13/14. As more posts come in, so will anylasis.

Overall:

Townish

18. DrippingGoofball

Erm. I actually like her lists. Not sure if I like her.

Overall:

Null

19. leiskyrie

The six posts in this game give me no inclination that this man has town interests at all close to the heart.
No pro town content. Seriously. Nothing in the six posts since replaced in tries to do anything but noise.
And that was six days ago.

Overall:

Scum

20. xvart

Honestly, he looks clean at the moment. If someone pulls out something of interest, tell me. But i'm not seeing anything.

Overall:

Town

[Flameaxe]

Limited until sunday. Might have a chance before any fun tomorrow night.

[Katsuki]

Thanks, xvart.

@Gud:

I still am curious as to why MBF was shot over me though, gud. All you do is make noise about how I am scum, yet you shoot a lurker over one of your "strongest" scum reads?
_______________________

Holy shit did not know seraphim was in this game.

@Mod: Prod/replace?

[Guderian]

Well he was above you when I shot him, obviously. You are smart, I know you must know this. Why would i possibly shoot my second best (or third or lower) scum candidate? Are you just making noise?

[Katsuki]

You've had me top of your list quite a number of times. I find it convenient that everytime you shot, someone just so "happened" to be above me.

I love how you're calling this noise.

[Guderian]

World =/= revolve around Katsuki.

I shot one mafia, and a shady looking lurker. Are you saying you think you've acted so scummy so as to propel yourself above that?

Unfortunately for you, I have no more bullets. However, I would not be against anyone vigging from this time forward.

Do you think I am in the mafia? If so, why? If not, what is the point of your last two posts?