Mini 1099: The Prisoner Mafia. Game Over.

[Zorblag]

Vote Count 1.6

The numbers by the voters indicate the order in which the vote was cast. If two or more players are tied for the most votes to lynch at the deadline the tiebreaker will be the player who has the earliest active vote.

EtherealCookie: 5: populartajo (19), Fate (22), chesskid3 (24), The Rufflig (25), SpyreX (26)
SpyreX: 3: Ojanen (12), Jack (15), Nachomamma8 (16)
Jack: 3: Hiraki (13), Plum (18), EtherealCookie (23)
Fate: 1: Zang (6)

Not voting: None

With 12 players alive it takes 7 to lynch. Currently EtherealCookie would be lynched at Deadline. Deadline is Thursday, January 6th at 8:00 PM EST/5:00 PM PST. Countdown Timer

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[The Rufflig]

You know what? I think I'd rather go with Fate.

UNVOTE: EtherealCookie
VOTE: Fate

[Fate]

Oh what the fuck.


You were doing so well.

You may not know me as I know you, but your chances of getting me lynched today run around 5-10%.

Now back on the MR. RIGHT wagon

[Jack]

COOKIE IS SCUM

MUST REPROCESS

[Jack]

MUST REPROCESS

I actually have no idea what I really meant by this, except something about spyrex being on the wagon.

UNVOTE, VOTE:COOKIE

[SpyreX]

If Jack dies tonight EVEN if its the only death I will shamelessly sheep whomever claims it for the rest of the game.

Promise.

[Ojanen]

jack is not scum. jack is town (or at most some freaky 3rd party).
most of anything he has posted comes across as trolling. it's actually most clear in the throwaway comments because motivation for those is at its most simplistic.

Currently Jack would be lynched at Deadline.

You guys are making a big mistake.

...intentionally trying to seem worried. Jack is not stupid.

vote:Jack

I'm not going to respond to votes with no reasoning to back them up.

...after Fate's multi-page tirade on Jack. Jack is not stupid.
I hate the fact that most scumtells used in any game require scum to be stupid, those make the game arbitrary. There is a low ceiling on how crazy you can get without being lynched or your play backfiring. I don't remember being in a game ever where anyone went so above and beyond in early antics than jack here.
it's not scum.

I voted SpyreX cause I thought a vote with a silent copy of an argument+vote for miller-cc is a better bet for scum than the crazies. and this mindset for wrath stinks

It doesn't make any sense as town.
To be fair, it doesn't make a lot of sense as scum either but.

BUT

Him or me today.

If I flip town, I want him him dead.
If he flips scum, you die.

This is not scum. This is so not a scum post on page 6.

unvote

ugh need to run
scan of bystanders for teh scum in a bit

[chesskid3]

^ this would be why this guy needs to die at some point too

[Ojanen]

chesskid, expand on that.

The Rufflig is also clear town.
Fate is prob-town and would be obvtown if he wasn't a big ego mafia character.
The game start was the most readtastic I've seen in a while. 2 wagons on pretty sure non-scum. Ambiguous, explosive => anyone who posted a lot gets townpoints.

There is 1-2 scum in the Jack wagon subgroup Hiraki, Plum, Cookie. At least one scum took a clear anti-Jack position. I have strong distate for each of their votes.

You base your townreads off people sheeping you, and it makes you fallable, bro.

No, it makes me an unstoppable force that forces scum to do as I say and wagon with me if they want a town read.

The chances of a scum sheeping Fate go down in the immediate future of that post (wagon at that point was Fate, Spy, Hiraki).

Vote: Hiraki

I would vote Hiraki>Plum>Cookie atm.
Cookie is posting total rubbish but the quiet one's are fishier, there's at least one genuine moment of exasperation with cookie.

One of nacho or tajo is prob scum (SpyreX wagon prob is not all town).

Zang is lurking. 8 posts across the site in the night and none here is a decent scumtell in an explosive ambiguous game start, given the right time zone.

[Jack]

I remembered something from lay of leithian that makes me feel better about spyrex.

Cookie is still obvious scum though.

[chesskid3]

yEs hiraki is scum
but we're lynching cookie first bro

[SpyreX]

If Zang was avoiding this game he can go on the death list.

Cookie first.

[chesskid3]

my list is looking pretty damn good now isn't it eh?

[The Rufflig]

You may not know me as I know you, but your chances of getting me lynched today run around 5-10%.

So how about I improve the odds a little by expanding my case a bit? You were all over the map on this fake miller claim.
Everything from ridiculing Jack's claim, lynch Jack for his fake cc, earnest repudiation of Jack's claim to Jack's claim rings true. I think a little explanation is in order and I'm unlikely to move my vote much in the meantime.

Fate claims miller in post #25
Jack cc in #28
Fate #39 "lol Jack claimed miller." "LOLZ"
Fate #40 "Jack claimed powerful PR AND MILLER??" more LZOLs
Fate #42 "LYNCHLYNCHLYNCHLYNCH"
Fate #72 "Nacho once everyone posts I'll give you a surprise"
Fate #104 "The problem with Jack is that he didn't claim miller post 1."
Fate #107 "I'm not a miller."

[SpyreX]

Fate #72 "Nacho once everyone posts I'll give you a surprise"
Fate #107 "I'm not a miller."

[EtherealCookie]

You need to speak for Fate?
That's odd.

[SpyreX]

Yes I need to its imperative or else I explode.

OR, JUST MAYBE, I'm showing captain town what at least that piece is.

Like I said Fate is dead if Jack is scum.

But, you managed to outrace a miller super pr for the scum prize so well done.

[Nachomamma8]

Spy, is our date still on? <3

84:

It was one of those "gambits" that had no downside.

The kind of thing I expect from fresh young bucks ready to go, fighting in the big leagues.

Yeah, I agree. If he was scum and trying to fish out prominent numbers, I doubt he would've added "Some numbers became the new number 2. Some numbers betrayed number two and helped number 6." That sounds more like town tempting scum to claim someone like 313, 1112, or 415...

[SpyreX]

Our date has to be postponed (I have to be PRETTY for you)

Of course, handsome, you can help by voting EK now.

[Zang]

Zang is lurking. 8 posts across the site in the night and none here is a decent scumtell in an explosive ambiguous game start, given the right time zone.

I am not lurking for not posting in one night. I was on after i first posted but I didn't post because I have bigger commitments than a game that just started that day and I had no intention of reading and responding to 5 pages at 11:00 pm. But I'm reading now.

[The Rufflig]

Fate #72 "Nacho once everyone posts I'll give you a surprise"
Fate #107 "I'm not a miller."

You missed the one in between.
Fate #104 "The problem with Jack is that he didn't claim miller post 1."
Why start a new line of argument about Jack's claim being untrue because of the timing of his claim just two or three posts before arguing that Jack rings true as a townie? Especially if Fate was setting up to reveal that Jack's claim was likely true. It doesn't fit.

[Jack]

Two miller claims already? Mmmm.
UNVOTE: Plum

Either of the two millers wish to put a number with their claim?

Why did you say "two miller claims already?" and what were you thinking with the "mmmm"?

[The Rufflig]

I was considering the possibility that both claims might be true and that there might be more such claims.

I asked Zorblag point blank in the confirmation stage whether this was a bastard game or not - considering the source of this theme, I thought such a thing would not be out of place. Zorblag stated that whatever he wrote was true, but would make no other guarantees. He also said that he had the Prisoner flavor in mind while creating the roles. So, it is quite likely that we do not have a "standard" setup.

[Fate]

Rufflig my thought process should be pretty clear.

You're misinterpreting my "problem with Jack" as me thinking he's scummy for it. I just think it was poor play, anti-town, hence my "problem" with it.

As for the rest of my Jack pushpushpush, it was more to see who hopped on the wagon with me.

[Fate]

Zang is lurking. 8 posts across the site in the night and none here is a decent scumtell in an explosive ambiguous game start, given the right time zone.

I am not lurking for not posting in one night. I was on after i first posted but I didn't post because I have bigger commitments than a game that just started that day and I had no intention of reading and responding to 5 pages at 11:00 pm. But I'm reading now.

Wait a second...

Unvote:
Vote: Zang

ALWAYS IN GOOD TASTE.