Open 263 - The Wild Life [Game Over]

[kunkstar7]

:: VoteCount 2x2 ::

andrew94 (1) -

Shattered Viewpoint

parknourie (0) -
smashbro_of_the_SSS (0) -
Scott Brosius (1) -

andrew94

DavidParker (0) -
Shattered Viewpoint (3) -

DavidParker, chkflip, jasonT1981

OpposedForce (0) -
jasonT1981 (0) -
chkflip (0) -
iamausername (0) -

Not Voting (5) -

parknourie, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Scott Brosius, OpposedForce, chkflip

With 10 Alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline for Day Two is Wednesday, December 21, 5:00pm EST.

[iamausername]

I actually thnk SV is likely shotty's partner.

Vote: SV

drmyshottyizsik,

Werewolf

, Lynched Day 1.

we hit warewolf so it was good for us... why would D1 have been bad and depressing for

you

hmmmm theories anyone??

unvote
vote:SV

This is actually a good reason not to lynch him, you guys. We want to hit mafia today. Like so:

VOTE: parknourie

[andrew94]

how do you know park is mafia?

and i said scott is mafia, come on guys TRUST ME.

[parknourie]

Hmm... I don't know what Andrew means by "TRUST ME".
He is clearly a town read but given that he CAN'T BE a seer, makes him UN-trustworthy.
@Iamusername - Okay....? First tell us why it is ME who is "mafia". Not werewolf but Mafia you say? Why?

[jasonT1981]

Park... any reasons why you are ignoring the points I have brought up and asked you to address? thats twice now you came on, said little and left.

unvote
vote: Park

[Shattered Viewpoint]

As promised:

mafia: andrew, parknourie, ScottBro

Werewolf: jason

Reasons: andrew & park are just too scummy, if I really have to explain why, then you're the VI. Scottbro is not playing to his town meta.

jason is being far too analytical for his normal town play; and he voted shotty very early (perhaps to distance himself for later).

[chkflip]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: PARKSCUMMY

Are you serious, Park? You flip-flopped from "I TRUST YOU~~" to "HOW DO WE TRUST THIS GUY". No. Just... just no.

[jasonT1981]

@Iamusername - Okay....? First tell us why it is ME who is "mafia". Not werewolf but Mafia you say? Why?

The same has been asked about you, and you continue to ignore it... only warewolf instead of mafia in your case. Come back and address the issues, Park.

[iamausername]

@Iamusername - Okay....? First tell us why it is ME who is "mafia". Not werewolf but Mafia you say? Why?

You are scum, for the reasons outlined in this post. Your interactions with shotty do not look like scum partner interactions, so you're not werewolf scum. Therefore you are mafia.

[jasonT1981]

I like the above linked Post... Park, come back and answer all outstanding issues please!

[andrew94]

if park flips mafia, sv and scott brosius attempted to bus him yesterday

i think davidparker is the werewolf becauser 1) hes a genius at finding cop/seer
2) he knows how silverwolf plays

[Shattered Viewpoint]

if park flips mafia, sv and scott brosius attempted to bus him yesterday

i think davidparker is the werewolf becauser 1) hes a genius at finding cop/seer
2) he knows how silverwolf plays

You're trying too hard.

[DavidParker]

i'm actually flattered.

nothing more from me.

[kunkstar7]

:: VoteCount 2x3 ::

andrew94 (1) -

Shattered Viewpoint

parknourie (3) -

iamausername, chkflip, jasonT1981

smashbro_of_the_SSS (0) -
Scott Brosius (1) -

andrew94

DavidParker (0) -
Shattered Viewpoint (1) -

DavidParker

Lateralus22 (0) -
jasonT1981 (0) -
chkflip (0) -
iamausername (0) -

Not Voting (4) -

parknourie, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Scott Brosius, Lateralus22

With 10 Alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline for Day Two is Wednesday, December 21, 5:00pm EST.

Lateralus22 replaces OpposedForce, effective immediately. Scott Brosius and smashbro_of_the_sss have been prodded.

[Lateralus22]

Yo, so I've read the thread, still trying to get everything through in my head. Werewolf is probably one of Park/shattered. Andrew is town, chkflip/or IAU is scum.

Will try to get something of substance. Quick note though, does anyone have a list of Jungle republic games? (I've only found about 2-3 in this section)

[Lateralus22]

Final Day 1 Vote Count

drmyshottyizsik

(7) -

silverbullet999

, jasonT1981, OpposedForce, chkflip, Shattered Viewpoint, parknourie, DavidParker [Lynched.]
andrew94 (1) -

drmyshottyizsik

parknourie (2) - Scott Brosius, iamusername
Scott Brosius (1) - andrew94
Shattered Viewpoint (1) - smashbro_of_the_sss

Will refer back this later, put here for easy reference later. At the top of my head I'd say the werewolf buddy bussed and there's probably two scum on the wagon and one off.

---

Parknourie

Park's obv wolf. Read his Iso, it's all practically active lurking, nothing of substance. Doesn't give forth much effort at all to hunt to for scum yet he spends his time chastising and throwing dirt on others (these players weren't even ones he expressed interest in lynching). Other notable things include contradictions (Original/Contradiction).

Notice his wagoning positioning, early on he votes shotty yet dancing around different wagons giving little input about shotty. The thing he cites a poor reason for switching that isn't even truly explains in an attempt to divert attention from the shotty wagon (Around VC 1.6). He didn't even respond to shotty reply to his accusation showing a lack of care towards his suspects. Didn't even say whether he thought shotty was scum or not after his switch.

Shatter Viewpoint

Poor reasoning for his accusation on jason. Love the selective accusation saying jason's early vote was distancing because that's exactly what Parknourie did. His content level is similar to Parnourie's.

Will read up on other's later, don't feel like doing it now.

Vote: Parknourie

[Lateralus22]

Hiya Smash, since you're reading the thread could you please give me a concise version of your current thoughts? (No spoilers please)

[andrew94]

however scott bro and sv is likely to be mafia

[Lateralus22]

Why do you think scott is the mafia (Can you list the reasons?)? Note, it'd be better off get the werewolf today due to their nk ability would it not?

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

Yep. Let's do it.

Vote: Andrew

Way to jump on without saying anything.

vote scott bro

why? give reasons for your read. If you think your gut is good enough, fine. BUt for everyone else, back it up.

what do you mean gut not enough. gut is enough. i have almost no gut reads, this is like a real gut read. if you dont believe me, you can lynch me then scott bro tommorrow

how will lynching you help prove scott is guilty? Just because a person has a gut read, doesn't mean it's right.

i specifically asked not to CC bro.

2) yes i am that sure scott is mafia. right now, all scott has been doing is posting very carefully, how the hell am i supposed to make a case on him, the only case i have is on eriynes oppourtunistic etc, but everyone just ignores
3) gut
4) scott just buddying up to me hoping that ill rest the case

your #2 says that Scott has been doing a good job. #4 is actually a start. I can see where that's coming from, and I could understand it as support to a case. But gut isn't a case. Scott's posting hasn't put up any flags for me.

Whoa~
Drmyshotty was Werewolf?!
Silverbullet was Seer?!
Guess we are screwed for now...

contribute something more than this.



@Later
Sorry if you're not on now, had this open while i was posting in another thread too. See below.



This game is pretty much just as I thought it would be. between what is people's normal play, and what is scummy. Didn't see shotty as a werewolf, but that's what a bunch of people in the town are for, see what others don't. also, didn't see silverbullet as seer, but still.

SV and park are my top two choices. I've seen Shattered play better than this. he has contributed little to nothing all day, and even if he believes Day 1 is crap, he hasn't done anything of value today. Park has continued to be the same, and I see him as mafia, rather than werewolf. after a quick read of Day2, nothing has changed much for me since my psot about everyone yesterday. Will have to reread Day 1 at some point. Also, the main reason I held back on Andrew was because I though he may have actually been claiming seer. ... apparently not. Need to have him under scrutiny.


Also, we have to decide what we would rather do, lynch who we believe to be mafia or werewolf. Originally, I wanted to say mafia next, giving the werewolf a chance to take out some mafia. But if we leave the werewolf around, we could be losing obv town players at night instead of mafia. In this situation, it would be better to get rid of the werewolf and then only lynch people who are scummier, rather than losing an obv town player. It all comes down to who we think the Werewolf will kill. What do you guys think? I don't mind going for a Werewolf at this point.


Preview Edit: lol later, good question.

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

forgot to throw this in. It's finals week.

V/LA until Wednesday

I may pop on to make a short post or two, but I want to focus on my studying

[Scott Brosius]

I don't really care who we kill (mafia/wolf), there are benefits to killing either.

For all the reasons yesterday and the lack of anything today

Vote: parknourie

Will refer back this later, put here for easy reference later. At the top of my head I'd say the werewolf buddy bussed and there's probably two scum on the wagon and one off.

There really is no basis for this. I agree with your end result of park being scum but I think using this in an attempt to scumhunt is flawed. I think the only thing that is most likely true is that all 3 mafia weren't on that wagon. But even that could be wrong.

[Lateralus22]

There really is no basis for this. I agree with your end result of park being scum but I think using this in an attempt to scumhunt is flawed. I think the only thing that is most likely true is that all 3 mafia weren't on that wagon. But even that could be wrong.

Hm? I'm basing my data off of this citing there's usually 2 scum on a day 1 lynch (To Scum there isn't too much underlining difference between wolf/town since they'll want both lynched). Atm the current very small set of data I collected still points to that same result.

[Lateralus22]

ebwop: Basing my

theory

[andrew94]

i agree that lynching the werewolf today is the best cause.
park, sv and scott are mafia though. can you not see him attempting to bus his buddy?

who do you think is the werewolf