Mini 1057: Unsubsidized Mafia (Game Over!)

[drmyshottyizsik]

Thor most definatly

[DemonHybrid]

Thor was the person who I thought probably-to-must be scum if Redtail is not. I cannot logically see Shotty or Equinox as scum, and if either are, I will slam my head into my desk.

So, I want to give something a try here.

Unvote, Vote: Thor

Equinox, what do you think about a Thor lynch?

[DemonHybrid]

Also, Equinox, no. I don't know your stance on Thor, because you haven't mentioned what you thought his alignment was yet.

[Thor665]

So...the case is I'm scum because saporovirus isn't here to be scum instead? I hate you guys.

[DemonHybrid]

That wasn't my case at all.

[Thor665]

Well, to be fair you didn't say your case other then PoE or so, so allow me to at least mock shotty's bad case on me in the meantime.

I can still choose to hate you for buying into it though.

Do you have a case you care to present as such? Hopefully one without sarcasm as a scumtell?

[DemonHybrid]

I didn't vote you because Shotty convinced you, I voted you because there's absolutely no way I can find shotty and Equinox as scum, and if Redtail isn't going to be today's lynch, then I don't mind that you are.

What's it matter to you? Like Equinox brought up with really heavy evidence, there is a great chance that this is a 2 scum game. Redtail grilled singer moderately hard anyway. Nhammen basically ONLY argued with her, and I don't see your motivation for wanting his lynch in the first place.

Plus, I want redtail to choose who dies today. This is critical.

[Thor665]

Plus, I want redtail to choose who dies today. This is critical.

You're running me up so that redtail can choose the lynch?

I do hate you.

[DemonHybrid]

Do you not trust him?

I don't want him to have a one-outer here. The information for what he chooses will be invaluable.

[drmyshottyizsik]

wow DH,,, uhhhh... you want the person whom you findd the scummiest to choose who dies?

unvote
vote DH

[DemonHybrid]

Yes.

If we are not in LyLo, don't you think that information is by far WAY more valuable then having someone like you get killed?

[DemonHybrid]

Please re-vote Thor. I'll explain my results tomorrow after Redtail chooses between you and Thor.

Either way, I'm pretty sure we've caught scum, but I need you to re-vote him to let him choose.

[Equinox]

I'm not moving my vote, period.

@Equinox - is it that you now find shotty scummy, or are you honestly voting someone you think is town because it will help you catch scum tomorrow? You don't need to explain the plan if you think it will help scum, but arguably having 2 lynchs from your pool of suspects would be preferable to one lynch and one scum kill, yes?

I'm lynching someone who I think is town because it will help me catch scum tomorrow. Obviously, I can't unveil my whole idea here, but I strongly believe what I'm doing here is going to help me (and the rest of you) win this game. While I agree that eliminating someone within the bracket of {DemonHybrid, redtail896, Thor665} would reveal a lot more information, I don't think I'm ready for the fall-out if we mislynch and it's someone other than drmyshottyizsik today. You guys saw what just happened; he suspected a dead player and then had no idea if we were in LyLo or not. I'm sorry, but I'm not going to put an entire game in the hands of someone who isn't paying attention. Scum would love you to do that, of course, in the guise of "We're not lynching town today! Ever!"

Also, Equinox, no. I don't know your stance on Thor, because you haven't mentioned what you thought his alignment was yet.

Oh, did I forget to mention Thor665 after my first read?

Aside from the fact that Thor665 is forever obvtown, the way singersigner threw crap at him doesn't feel like scum partners distancing. Sarcasm as a scum tell, seriously? That, and he's been logical and analytical, and so far I've seen no gaps in logic from him -- and logic is pretty much what defines Thor665's town meta. Re-read changed nothing.

[DemonHybrid]

I'm not moving my vote, period.

That's fine. I'm still waiting for Shotty to change his vote back; I'd really like Redtail to make the decision tonight and I think that no matter what he chooses, we'll find scum in someone, whether it be him, Thor or even Shotty, though I doubt it. I have my methods.

[Equinox]

If redtail896 picks Thor665 and Thor665 doesn't flip scum, and then we lose the game tomorrow because of a loose cannon, I will rage.

[drmyshottyizsik]

DH let me get this straight... in a game with one scum left you want to send us into lylo by letting the, in your opinion scummiest, playerin the game choose who dies?

[DemonHybrid]

YES.

We're letting a scummy player make a key decision. How can you not find that valuable? It's better than lynching you AND thinking you're town at the same time.

[DemonHybrid]

Let me see if I can put this in a way that you'd understand.

Scenario 1: Redtail has a choice between his own survival and lynching you. What does he choose, and why?

Scenario 2: Redtail has a choice between lynching Thor or lynching you. What does he choose, and why?

[drmyshottyizsik]

why don't we lynch the scummy players?!
Redtail is not scum so therefor him choosing who to kiss means nothing

[drmyshottyizsik]

why don't we lynch the scummy players?!
Redtail is not scum so therefor him choosing who to kiss means nothing

[DemonHybrid]

Then it should be fine for you, since you think he's town, it shouldn't be such a concern.

[drmyshottyizsik]

right but say you think he's the scummiest!

[DemonHybrid]

I get information, you get piece of mind knowing that town (in your opinion) is making the choice.

No one is losing here, shotty.

[DemonHybrid]

*peace of mind.

And I wondered why I lost so many spelling bees first round in middle school...

[Equinox]

drmyshottyizsik: What changed between your previous vote on redtail896 and today to change your stance on redtail896?