Mini #1081 - SitMOA Mafia (Endgame... Congrats, winners!)

[chesskid3]

Mmkay not sure I like that, but at least you're attempting.
Place a vote on your top suspect, please.

How do you feel about Vren and RBT, both of whom have yet to post besides confirming? (and in RBT's case one other post in which he votes for a player who is not in the game)
While you have a point about Andrew and Vezok both not providing both content, Andrew and Vezok recently both expressed opinions on recent events, and Vezok hopped on the Malthus wagon.

Thoughts?

[Narsis]

Mmkay not sure I like that, but at least you're attempting.
Place a vote on your top suspect, please.

How do you feel about Vren and RBT, both of whom have yet to post besides confirming? (and in RBT's case one other post in which he votes for a player who is not in the game)
While you have a point about Andrew and Vezok both not providing both content, Andrew and Vezok recently both expressed opinions on recent events, and Vezok hopped on the Malthus wagon.

Thoughts?

VOTE: Vezokpiraka

meant to do that in my last post.

Vren and RBT just havent contributed period. which although i dont like i find less scummy then Vezok and andrew who have been posting and obviously following the game but haven't really put in a worthwhile contribution of any kind.

[chesskid3]

Why Vezok over Andrew?

[Snow_Bunny]

ThAdmiral replaces Vren. Welcome to the Academy! Have fun!

[AdumbroDeus]

Also for someone who asserted that they wanted Ambro to post (may have been someone else, if so disregard), you seem awfully unconcerned with the fact that he unvoted, didn't put his vote anywhere, but started asking other people for scum/townreads without giving any himself.
That's called sitting back, waiting for a bandwagon and then joining after it's got momentum. Scumtastic. I will not be adressing any requests he made of me until he does them himself. If you have a problem with that, there's something wrong with you.

If by dumb you mean "deals with scumtastic attacks while still doing an excellent job of scumhunting" then sure, I agree with you.

In other news, WAY TO ASK PEOPLE FOR SCUMPICKS WITHOUT GIVING ANY OF YOUR OWN. Hypocrisy much?

@AdumbroDeus

: Who are your top scumpicks and townpicks, and why?

Ok, dumbtown read confirmed.


Your question is legitimate but your implication about it being scummy is... dumb. You were not accused of anything you were merely asked for stances, you know, producing information.

Your reasoning for why it's scummy is a textbook example of putting a scummy spin on actions without explaining why they're INHERENTLY scummy (hint:asking for stances pretty much never is inherently scummy). Maybe if I actually did immediately jump on a wagon after your answer but... why ask you then?


So anyway, my reads so far (from scummieness to townieness)

Scum:

leaning scum:

Primarily neutral:

Gandolf (his 10 (viewtopic.php?p=2620324#p2620324) feels weird, and his contribution seems designed to seem more then it is)

vezokpiraka (lurkerscumish vibes

Everyone else (don't have a read on everyone yet)

leaning town:

Chesskid (dumb, but pattern definitely leads dumbtown over dumbscum).

Katsuki (good contribution, good questions, seems town so far)

Town:

@Riceballtail:

Where you at? Some contribution please, what are your town/scumpicks?

[AdumbroDeus]

EWOP: Didn't mean to submit that yet.



Overall, a few leaning town reads, no clear scum reads, and a couple of people on the wrong side of null.



So, now you can answer my question.

[andrew94]

i have about 2 days v/la please.

i gotta say, wagon on chess looks oppurtunistic

Lol congrats, you can defend your scumbuddy.

no, because u were so sure of me being scum, then u hop on the chesss wagon, which his actions is normal(i think) as i sometimes spam accusations in all direction

[andrew94]

vezokpiraka, why do you feel the need to vote matlhusis when your vote is ALREADY on him? are u trying to create the impreession of a bandwagon?

and what games have u played with chess

[vezokpiraka]

Some ongoing and some I don't remember.

Best example is SE1

[vezokpiraka]

I mean LOST Seaseon 1.

[gandalf5166]

He doesn't act this way as town either. The fact is, chess makes a point of making himself impossible to meta by being a different kind of ridiculous every single game.

[Narsis]

leaning town:
Katsuki (good contribution, good questions, seems town so far)

i'm not quite seeing how Katsuki's contribution has been particularly good so far.

[gandalf5166]

Narsis has a point.

[andrew94]

appaerntly becos he has 16 posts

[Narsis]

Why Vezok over Andrew?

i see Vezok's active lurking as worse then andrew's.

[andrew94]

how am i active lurking, i said v/la. its lucky i am posting now instead of studying exam which is in 2 days

[Narsis]

how am i active lurking, i said v/la. its lucky i am posting now instead of studying exam which is in 2 days

perhaps i should have used quotation marks on active lurking...

basically you are both posting and are showing that you are up to date with things but the posts have had very little worthwhile contributions. i find what you have been posting to be more worthwhile/being an attempt at something more worthwhile then Vezok's, hence my vote on Vezok.

[ThAdmiral]

Confirm. I'll read up and post.

[chesskid3]

Town:
chesskid3
Katsuki
andrew94
vezok

Null:
Errybody else.

[chesskid3]

Also I'm going to be agressive this game, so if you ask me to do something before doing it yourself, I'm going to call you scummy for it. Just save us all the time and answer any questions you ask others, or indicate that you will answer after they do.

[Dark Horse]

Also I'm going to be agressive this game, so if you ask me to do something before doing it yourself, I'm going to call you scummy for it. Just save us all the time and answer any questions you ask others, or indicate that you will answer after they do.

Avoiding questions are scummy, no matter what your excuse is.

[chesskid3]

I answered his question AFTER he answered it himself. Asking questions to people that you aren't going to answer yourself is actually what's scummy. Thanks for playing, though.

[Dark Horse]

I didn't just mean that. You saying "I'm not going to answer questions" is scummy.

[chesskid3]

except that's not what I said by a long shot.

[Dark Horse]

When you said "i'm going to be aggressive", it was pretty obvious you where talking about adum's question. Hence why it can be inferred that you were using it as an excuse for initial refusing s of questions.