We are one head short of a full complement, but with deadline approaching we'll post our reads now. If the other head arrives before the hammer they might input more, but you no longer need to feel the need to spare the hammer, Spyrex.
We believe RC is scum because of role information.
We believe Cooldog is scum with him. As said previously, Cooldog's certainty of Exe town was odd. His interactions with Katsuki smack of scum trying to denigrate their attacker instead of showing why they aren't scum. His cult suspicions also seem to have been a deliberate ploy to mislead the town with Reaper's help.
We believe that Katsuki, Spyrex, and nopoint are town. The wagon on nopoint seems like a mislynch pushed by Reaper, and a belief that Cooldog is scum would naturually suggest Katsuki is town. Spyrex has been aggressively pushing for clarity and called out Cooldog on his cult suspicions.
We believe Nikanor is likely town, because he posted a very clear analysis showing there is no cult, and it appears that the scum had a plan to mislead town in believing there was a cult.
We also believe that, with Cooldog being very vocal about being off the Exe wagon, the wagon distribution is likely to be two scum on and one scum off.
Exe (7):
Katsuki
, Muffin,
Nikanor
, McGriddle,
ReaperCharlie
,
Copper
,
SpyreX
As such, we think the third scum is likely to be Muffin or Mcgriddle. Our personal preference is Muffin, particularly because of this post:
Muffin wrote:Well I've re-read everyone in ISO and my vote is pretty comfortable on Exe right now, though I have others I'm keeping an eye on.
Not reading the thread carefully
He also seems to be
wavering on who to
vote for.
Exe wrote:LOL nice calling OMGUS. That's terrible scumhunting. Omgus is a crap tell.
Way to use the slight confusion in game mechanics to hide your lack of desire to commit to scumhunting.
Scum are still scum. As far as we know, a lynch is still a lynch. Stop creating excuses and hunt for scum.
Scum AREN'T still scum because if their nightkills don't die, there doesn't have to be any rhyme or reason to their choice of targets, esp. since the players targeted cannot discuss their freed/unfreed status. Stop trying to obfuscate the issue.
hiding behind meta wifom
More
AtE than I can
count.
"If their nightkills don't die" seems to betray an understanding of the setup Muffin shouldn't have.
So, to summarize:
Town: Copper, Spyrex
Likely Town: Katsuki (contingent on Cooldog-scum), Nikanor, Nopoint
Neutral: Hinduragi, TheButtonmen, Mcgriddle
Likely Scum: Muffin
Scum: ReaperCharlie, Cooldog
This account is a hydra. It is listed as male for ease of pronoun use; this has no bearing on the genders of the hydra's heads.
