Mini 1055 - Return to PEGBAM (Closing Time!)

[Flava Flave]

vote karen

the bitch.

Vote Karen

Buddying.

[Flava Flave]

Oh, and if it wasn't clear, I mean to JDodge, not each other.

[Flava Flave]

Then why did you not put my vote in with em?

Vote: Flava Flave

You were making a joking point about the vote counts while the others were pure buddying.

[Flava Flave]

Vote Porochaz and Ooba

[Flava Flave]

I meant Oman.

Unvote Ooba, Vote Oman

[Flava Flave]

What inconsistencies?

[Flava Flave]

UA, I already explained that your vote didn't look like buddying.

[Flava Flave]

There's the other vote (on yourself) and the fact that no one had done it yet so you weren't just doing what was popular.

What are you getting at anyway? I know you aren't suggesting that I'm your scumbuddy. Unless you think I am distancing from Oman and Porochaz, in which case you should vote them as well as me, I don't see the issue.

[Flava Flave]

You are not distancing from me. We are already distanced. I'm at the cool kids table.

Yeah cuz it's definitely cool when the kid to your left is picking his nose and the kid to your right is taping his thick black rimmed glasses back together.

[Flava Flave]

Porochaz, I was gonna have some fun with that. Thanks for ruining it. Jerk.

[Flava Flave]

I was prodded. Anyone want me to discuss anything specific?

[Flava Flave]

I was prodded. Anyone want me to discuss anything specific?

Hi. Why do we need to tell you what to discuss? You should take initiative.

I'm having a hard time finding anything worth talking about which is rare for me. Probably the fact that we can't lynch anyone. I dunno.

Now's your time to choose, people. I will be executing from one of the following people:

Oman
UltimaAvalon
UncertainKitten
GhostWriter

Weigh in with your opinions, please

Oman - Oh, where to start? There's the blatant buddying to you (JDodge) with his first random vote on you ("Hey buddy, I'm voting you even though you are the only one we can't kill today. Isn't that funny?") and his second vote on "Karen". Then if that isn't enough, he even tries to make "Karen" out to be a real player and votes that player. He's not really contributing, but he's posting. This is worse than straight up not posting because it shows that he is around and just doesn't care to say anything, which instead of acknowledging that, he's throwing around joking comments (Karen stuff, cool kid stuff, popcorn thing). I'd love to see Oman executed today.

UA- He started out voting "Karen", but clearly wasn't buddying. He voted me and questioned me a little. I always like a player who sparks real discussion early. Since then, he's continued to actively scumhunt. I don't like UA as an execution today.

UK - Also actively scumhunting. And the fact that she's not afraid to go after you (JDodge) makes me think she isn't scum fearing her life. I don't like UK as an execution today.

GW - He's posting one-liners and seems to want to stay in the background. And I don't like him sidestepping your questions. Of the names you listed, GW is my second choice for an execution behind Oman.

Unvote Porochaz. Vote Ghostwriter

. I'm already voting Oman, so I'm leaving that.

[Flava Flave]

I believe GW. I don't think this has anything to do with his alignment.

[Flava Flave]

Vote mikeburnfire

His first post was terrible. Not just the fishing, but the "cool" at the beginning of the post. Bad vibes everywhere. Then when he is called out for fishing, he shakes it off as a joke with the doctor comment. Then he seems to be proposing a policy execution and continues with the joking tone with "you or me or somebody else". Next is the awful double voter comment. Then he admits to being scummy, calls Day 1 "boring" which gives him an excuse to do nothing, and sets himself up for a bad fakeclaim later. Next few posts are full of nothing until he calls UK scum out of nowhere and questions JDodge excluding him (MBF) from the execution list.

His first post today isn't much better:

JDodge, thank you for killing the cult leader, apparently. I hate cults. And you were right about UK being town, so kudos there as well. Of course, if you're scum, then it would explain why you're so perceptive about that.

The "thank you" is just weird and off. He seems to be congratulating JDodge, but then says he could be scum, but is careful not to straight up call JDodge scum.

Any idea what the deal is on the missing player? PanzerKarenKittywhatever only made 3 posts yesterday, so it's not like we'll notice the difference, but still... Could be a hider role or a detaining role victim. Not sure what to make of this just yet.

If anyone knows anything about this and thinks it's best to share, they will do so. Asking isn't necessary.

Also, looks like I was completely wrong about Vezok/UK. I didn't kill ém, though. UK seemed like a pretty contentious player, not one I would expect scum to target. But she was also one of the most active players. The scum must have wanted her dead because her efficient posting was a threat. Otherwise she would have been kept alive because she was barking up the wrong trees (I know I'm town, and currently do not believe JDodge is scum).

Why are we looking at the NK(s?)? UK was probably killed by scum because she looked so town and Panzer probably had something weird happen. It's really not important right now and pretty obvious I think.

Not sure where to start hunting. JDodge, why do you think scot is scum? A quick ISO of his posts shows that he reading the game and keeping up with the events, but only seemed to post when I was incorrect about something. This shows active lurking to me.

Really don't like the "not sure" when there are 10 pages of posts to digest. Then going to JDodge for help with reads. Why?

As for GW's role, I believe his one-shot Night 0 role is a null-tell. He's probably telling the truth about that ability, but it doesn't signify alignment one way or the other.

This was already established.

Then the last post speaks for itself. Can we lynch this scumbag now?

[Flava Flave]

I'll give you the 'fishing' part, but are you really attacking me for saying "cool"?

I am. It shows happiness at who was selected as king and slight buddying. Thanks for conceding the fishing point too.

Heaven forbit I joke around during the RV phase.

When you are joking about actual accusations made towards you, yeah. That's scummy. And are you saying you were joking about the vezok execution? Because that went on for quite a while. If you were seriously proposing it, you can't call it RVS. If you want to call it RVS, explain why it went on so long.

I will admit that my play was bad, but that doesn't mean that I'm scum.

Bad play wasn't my point. What I actually said was "Then he admits to being scummy, calls Day 1 "boring" which gives him an excuse to do nothing, and sets himself up for a bad fakeclaim later. "

UK is Vezok, whose lynch I've been calling for all day. It isn't out of nowhere.

Ok, fair. But you seemed to be pushing either policy or a joke. Neither should lead to a serious vote on UK.

You're attacking me for saying the words "cool" and "thank you". Think about that for a minute.

Yes. It's all buddying.

Which part of that do you have a problem with? Do you think he can't be scum, or that I should directly call him scum without a reason?

You should either call him scum and say why or call him town. Don't do the whole "I think he's town, but maybe he's scum. I dunno, that's my read I guess hurhurhur" thing.

What is your problem with me talking about current events?

There is no purpose. It's fluff.

Do I really have to answer this question?

Yes.

As I said earlier, most things stem from Vezok, and he's a blight on games because everybody wants him dead.. And I'm talking to JDodge because I wanted to know why he voted Scot. Dur.

Ok, let's all let JDodge scumhunt for us.

Unvote MBF

. JDodge, who should I vote?

The events of Day 1, As they pertain to UA:
Found FF scummy. Pursued. King Dodge didn't care. Backed off
Got into a minor argument with UK. (Turned out to be more worthless that FF's, but whatever floats your boat Scot.)Felt she was wrong but Town. She wouldn't back down. Self-voted to end argument
Analysis: Subject began day with minor leads, but quickly gave up when he realized he'd be unable to convince the one person who mattered. Cruised for the rest of the day.

Do you plan to do anything today? Why the self-vote?

Regardless, trying to say that my lurking is a scum-tell is a deeply flawed argument.

No one is attacking you for lurking. You brought that up yourself.

Vote: Flava Flave

.

Reason please.

BTW, I'm leaning toward Flava Flave side, his case is not as bad as MBF makes it out to be.

He seems to want it to look bad so nobody follows it.

The thing I don't like is FF's playing curve: lies low when a wagon starts on him, makes just average play afterwards, then come back in day 2 with a full case on MBF whom he hasn't mentioned once on day 1.

Yeah, the kind thing made it hard to get into the game. Then JDodge gave a list, so I felt more like I could participate by commenting on his options. Day 2 turned back into normal mafia, so I can play my normal game.

[Flava Flave]

I agree that Flava Flave needs to be put on the grill. Flava, again, why did unvote MBF, while still pushing his case?

VOTE: Flava Flave

JDodge gave us a list to choose from. He also said he wouldn't execute MBF.

[Flava Flave]

Flameaxe/mykonian, is there a chance I could have the spot back?

[Flava Flave]

beibeing busy for a week isn't flaking.