Mini 1042 - Skillville - GAME OVER!

[DemonHybrid]

*skims*

Way to go guys.

*sigh* I just don't feel this game anymore. If you want to lynch me, go ahead

Okay. We'd be happy to.

[vollkan]

*skims*

Way to go guys.

*sigh* I just don't feel this game anymore. If you want to lynch me, go ahead, but be prepared to take what goes with it.

I guess I'll just read when I come back.

Why don't you 'feel' this game anymore?

I find it very hard to believe that a townie would lose interest in a game after a D1 godfather lynch.

[Skill006]

First Vote Count for Day 2:

Maemuki (2) – DemonHybrid, Zachrulez
Scott Brosius (2) – Alduskkel, Untrod Tripod

Not Voting: drmyshottyizsik, Reckamonic, Scott Brosius, Socrates, Maemuki, vollkan

Deadline is Saturday, Septmeber 25, 10:00 pm CST.
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch!

Happy Scumday, Alduskkel!

[DemonHybrid]

vollkan's not voting ^^

It's okay, you're getting the hang of this =)

Ugh, thanks. I wonder if I'll ever have a perfect vote count

[Untrod Tripod]

MAEMUKI WOULD YOU LIKE TO AT LEAST ATTEMPT DEFENDING YOURSELF?

[DemonHybrid]

MAEMUKI WOULD YOU LIKE TO AT LEAST ATTEMPT DEFENDING YOURSELF?

This post is fishy.

She already said she doesn't care...are you coaching her?

[Untrod Tripod]

No, I just think it's really lame of her to just throw up her hands and give up. I don't think Maemuki is scum (as I said), so I would really hate for us to end up lynching a pro-town slot out of her own stupidity.

Does the content bug you, or the all caps?

and can we replace Maemuki if she's uninterested in playing?

[DemonHybrid]

The content.

And yes, that would be a shame, but that's clear and legitimate AtE when a good case was presented against her. Lets lynch her and get it over with and not dick around with a replacement.

[DemonHybrid]

EBWOP: ".....was presented against her. I don't think she's town, so lets lynch her and get it over with..."

I'm multitasking with homework, a lot of the stuff I say isn't going to make sense.

[Scott Brosius]

Vote: Scott Brosius

.

I'll probably skim the game tomorrow and look for connections. Iso horrordude, too. Maemuki case looks good, but I'd prefer to iso her myself.

Unless drmyshottyizsik really was drunk (he's 16, I'm a bit skeptical) then I think he's deliberately playing dumb. Or at least, I hope so. Maybe he has just seen a few too many vengefuls?

You vote me without a reason, yet mention 2 other people you seem to view as scummy.

I think its less likely for scum to bus a GF (rather than a simple goon/non-scum PR WIFOM alert). So I think we can find scum in the people not voting HD. These are Ald, UT, shotty, Maemuki.

Shotty is playing his usual scummy game, I'm sticking with my vote from yesterday.

Vote: drmyshottyizsik

[DemonHybrid]

I don't like the speculation that scum wouldn't bus a godfather.

How is shotty scummy and just not confused?

Why did you quote Al and suspect his post, but not explain more and go off on other people?

Unvote, Vote: Scott Brosius

I'm confident of a Maemuki/SB scum team.

[Untrod Tripod]

You vote me without a reason, yet mention 2 other people you seem to view as scummy.

This is from page 13, he's been saying you're scummy since then.

Unvote
Vote:drshotty

Solves policy, and Esp was scummy anyway.

So, why was Espeonage scummy? He lurked for out of game reasons. And is shotty even scummy to you?

I really haven't seen much scum hunting from you, Scott (except maybe for iso #8). Also, calling people scummy for lurking (i.e. Espeonage) is pretty hypocritical. Have you seen your posts and # of posts?

Confidence is not a scum tell, it just means he is sticking to his guns and not jumping all over the place like oppertunist scum(aka zach)

And how has Zach been opportunistic?

Now this is almost fishing and it kind of makes me mad.

What do you mean by fishing, exactly?

Yes in a RVS supporting it is a great thing. Scum want the RVS to die quickly so no convo's will really start. And if you are so anti-RVS(which you haven't been in other games) why did you RQS? You just sat there and insult him for trying to do something.

You're pretty much taking the opposite stance on theory here vs. Zach. He says that scum want the RVS to be prolonged so that real discussion takes longer to get going. Why is he wrong, and why is that scummy?

There are other problems with your case on Zach that have been noted already. I won't go into them.

I noticed in post 340 that you don't address any of vollkan's points except for the meta one. Why? Digging up those links has got to be harder than responding to his other points.

Vote: Scott Brosius

.

lrn2read

[Reckamonic]

Update... couldn't actually get around to catching up in our games tonight. Fairly busy day today/Tuesday with exams and whatnot, but should be able to get up to snuff Tuesday evening.

[vollkan]

Lets lynch her and get it over with and not dick around with a replacement.

Please give me even one reason why having a replacement is undesirable.

I think there is a good likelihood she is scum losing disinterest due to sunken morale; but even so, I'd rather have a replacement who I can further analyse than be left with the limited information we have on her so far.

I think its less likely for scum to bus a GF (rather than a simple goon/non-scum PR WIFOM alert). So I think we can find scum in the people not voting HD. These are Ald, UT, shotty, Maemuki.

Not being on HD's wagon is NOT a scumtell. However, there is good reason for paying closer attention to those people.

Shotty is playing his usual scummy game, I'm sticking with my vote from yesterday.

The above post is misleading. The second clause suggests that he is voting consistently with his actions yesterday, but there is an impotant difference. Yesterday, he didn't give any reasons for thinking Shotty was playing scummily. Ie:

Solves policy, and Esp was scummy anyway.

So, @Scott, why is SHOTTY scummy?

[drmyshottyizsik]

Just saying that I played one game with scott, and I'm pretty sure i was town

[DemonHybrid]

Please give me even one reason why having a replacement is undesirable.

I'm pretty confident we've caught scum in Maemuki from her behavior and logic so far and I'd rather not have a smooth talker come in and feed us bull and just make things harder to get the lynch happening. A different person does not a different alignment make.

[Zachrulez]

I think Maemuki needs more pressure, replacement or not.

[vollkan]

Please give me even one reason why having a replacement is undesirable.

I'm pretty confident we've caught scum in Maemuki from her behavior and logic so far and I'd rather not have a smooth talker come in and feed us bull and just make things harder to get the lynch happening. A different person does not a different alignment make.

Define "feed us bull"

[DemonHybrid]

Stuff like tunneling people and looking town by pure aggression. Really long wall posts. That kind of thing. Town has a terrrrible habit of completely forgetting about the player pre-replacement and what they did and going off of what the new player has done.

If Maemuki's spot is looking scummy right now, then it should be done away with right now or get ready for a ton of distraction.

[Socrates]

Horrordude took some perverse interest in an offhand comment I made about Mae. There really isn't any part of the Mae case than I find problems with.

Then again, 468 really sounds like scum not wanting a replacement to ruin their mislynch.

:/

At least DH and Mae aren't scum together.

[Zachrulez]

Maemuki is posting elsewhere, and just replaced into another game today.

Come on guys.

[DemonHybrid]

Maemuki or Scott. I don't see any other logical lynch, so pick one, everyone. Both terribly lurky, both with scummy connections and both extremely wishy-washy/unsure with often null reads.

[Zachrulez]

I'm honestly not finding Scott all that scummy. From what I know of his meta, he's always lurky.

[Reckamonic]

Wow, not that bad of a re-read at all. Our thoughts are pretty short and sweet: Maemuki seemingly giving up is admittedly scummy, but DH passively pushing for a quicklynch (468) instead of waiting for a replacement doesn't sit well with us.

On an unrelated note, SB's vote on DMSIS (459) is also pinging our scumdar a bit. First off, SB admits that this is how DMSIS

usually

plays, so why does his usual play make him any more likely to be mafia? Secondly, DMSIS is ripe for an investigation/vig kill/track/whatever to confirm him. Otherwise, he's just an easy mislynch for scum, which is partially why SB's post seems so opportunistic.

[DemonHybrid]

Reck, I've seen plenty of games where a scum slot has done the following:

1. Person A gets role PM (the scumslot)
2. Person A looks scummy as hell. Is about to be lynched. Has a lot of suspicion against him.
3. Person A gives up and passes it on to Person B.
4. Person B tunnels people, makes himself look town and completely turn the tables. Yay, scum win!

Have you forgotten what happened in Vanillaside, Reck? RedCoyote totally turned the Korts suspicion around. (I'm assuming I -am- talking to Reckoner)