Mini 1035 - Devil's Town - GAME OVER

[TDC]

And I don't really remember you being particularly suspicious of Dr. P at the time, could you elaborate what exactly it is that bothers you so much about him?

I thought he was being especially stubborn and confrontational. Also him replacing out did nothing to help how his alignment looked. I don't think he looks like obviscum, but thought he was playing somewhat anti-town.

So he wasn't actually "acting like scum" as you claimed before?

[Tazaro]

Good gracious, how slow is this game?

[PranaDevil]

Zodiark13 has been prodded

Vote Count:

Zodiark13 (2) - LynchMePls, Tazaro

Not Voting:

ConfidAnon, Untrod Tripod, podium123456, TDC, Zodiark13

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch!

Deadline: 7am GMT on Wednesday 22nd September.

[Zodiark13]

Prod recieved. I was going to post last night, but it was 1AM by the time I got round to it.

The way I play is that if a person makes a scummy post, my suspicion of that person rises, and if a person makes a not-scummy post, my suspicion of the lowers. That the first few posts made by TDC wern't overly scummy made my suspicion of him decrease, and then Albert came along and made massive waves on my scumdar. Also, that this is the biggest point of discussion kinda shows how bad a position we are in.

Zodiark, trying our hands at identifying, on day two, the killer based on edmund's death is basically a Wifom dead end.

It's also a distraction; what we need to try is to get a handle on Confid Anon's and other people who haven't posted on day two's input and then talk about posts, that are not a matter of wifom, but of interpretation.

That you seems so eager to put out this idea that you feel it nessecary to post twice seems rather fishy. Added to the fact that you were the first one to ask what todays topic is, stampted out the first serious answer, and have since done nothing but say "Lynch Zodiark plox kthxbai" and complain at the slow pace of this game is really poor play. Added to that my previous theory of your predecessor and Dr P., I'm thinking you for today.

Vote: Tazaro

I forget that people on this site have a tendancy to scream "WIFOM!!!" whenever I even suggest using NK data for scumhunting. How about I rephrase my earlier request. Rather than use the fact that ed was the one who was NK'ed as a foundation to lynch someone, how about we draw a list of suspects based of who ed suspected yesterday, or else try to identify if he made any PR breadcrumbs.

[podium123456]

Zodiark you have ignored me twice... is it intentional?

[Zodiark13]

Only if you ignoring my last post was.

[TDC]

The way I play is that if a person makes a scummy post, my suspicion of that person rises, and if a person makes a not-scummy post, my suspicion of the lowers. That the first few posts made by TDC wern't overly scummy made my suspicion of him decrease, and then Albert came along and made massive waves on my scumdar. Also, that this is the biggest point of discussion kinda shows how bad a position we are in.

I quoted the only two posts I made between your drastic change of mind. One is expressing some suspicion of you, and the other has no content at all.
You make it sound as if someone could claim scum in one post, then post ten contentless posts and he'd be back to neutral for you? I could agree if we were talking about posts that give you some sort of town feel, but how you take "non-scummy" posts and have them decrease the validity of earlier "scummy" posts is totally beyond me.

I forget that people on this site have a tendancy to scream "WIFOM!!!" whenever I even suggest using NK data for scumhunting. How about I rephrase my earlier request. Rather than use the fact that ed was the one who was NK'ed as a foundation to lynch someone, how about we draw a list of suspects based of who ed suspected yesterday, or else try to identify if he made any PR breadcrumbs.

As has already been pointed out, he was suspicious of you.

[podium123456]

Only if you ignoring my last post was.

your attempt at sarcasm fails... this is what i would like addressed:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 5#p2504125

[podium123456]

I just noticed something while reading something in the wiki:

A Normal game should have at least one Mafia faction, and

no more than two

.

I didn't know about this rule... so that means we have a maximum of 2 mafia, which is good to know.

[PranaDevil]

ConfidAnon has been prodded

[Tazaro]

Zodiark, I'm scummy for thinking you should be lynched? You should be, as far as what you've done is concerned.

[LimMePls]

I didn't know about this rule... so that means we have a maximum of 2 mafia, which is good to know.

Oh goodie, now I'm glad to know there aren't 3 mafia in this mini game...

That was completely pointless. Why did you even bring that up podium?

[LimMePls]

Oh wait, Podium, you do realize that they mean a maximum of 2 mafia GROUPS, right? Not 2 mafia members.

[Tazaro]

I just noticed something while reading something in the wiki:

A Normal game should have at least one Mafia faction, and

no more than two

.

I didn't know about this rule... so that means we have a maximum of 2

mafia

, which is good to know.

By the word "mafia" that I underlined, do you mean mafia member or mafia group?

[podium123456]

never mind, i didnt see the word faction.

[LimMePls]

The activity in this game makes it unplayable.

[Tazaro]

VOTE FOR ZODIARK, PEOPLE!

[podium123456]

it's been a while, so i'm assuming that zodiark read my last post and chose not to respond... so

VOTE: Zodiark13

For refusing to discuss the problem with me, and to move the game along. If he responds, i can reconsider. That puts him at L-1.

[PranaDevil]

Untrod Tripod has been prodded

[Untrod Tripod]

Yah, there's a certain timing element to Zodiak's vote, and from this I see Zodiark's game play as suspect.

Vote: Zodiark

I really don't get what's so scummy about Zodiark. I didn't find his vote all that suspect and I don't think he's scum.

I would, however, say that there's "a certain timing element" to Taz's vote on ABR. He jumps in and puts a quick vote on ABR and now is calling Zodiark obviscum. If Zodiark gets lynched and flips town, I think Taz jumps to the top of my scumlist.

Insofar as there really hasn't been all that much said, I don't really have much else to say. Taz is twitching my scumdar and I'm still iffy on TDC because of his slot.

[LimMePls]

Wow, I'm just going to have to get used to hating your posting style I guess. More wishy-washy words like "I

think

Taz jumps to the top of my scumlist" and "Taz is twitching my scumdar and I'm still iffy on TDC...". Do you ever commit to anything? And do you have a link to a recent scum game for me?

[LimMePls]

Oh, and what does it mean when someone "twitches" your scumdar. Is that more than a ping? Lower than a tap? Inbetween a flip and pull?

[PranaDevil]

Looking for a replacement for ConfidAnon

ConfidAnon now replaced by Incognito

[Incognito]

Hi. I'm here and reading. I'm gonna try not to lol too hard at my predecessor's sig considering the fact that he, uh, ya know, replaced out.

[Incognito]

Replacement gig #13. That's gotta be kinda lucky, right?

All right, so I've given the game a good once-over already. I'd like to read the game at least once more to do some targeted reads on certain people before I vote anyone or give complete reasons as to why I think certain people are scum.

First, a bit of housekeeping: Since this game began with 9 players, I'm almost positive that we're dealing with a scum team of 2 people due to balancing reasons. Watcher is a pretty strong town role especially for a 2-man scum group to handle, but I'm still thinking 2 scum due to the numbers.

Secondly: Do you guys remember how you lynched ABR without a claim? Yeah. We won't be doing that anymore, got it?

Quick initial thoughts: podium <-> Dr Pepper looked really town on town to me, especially after Dr Pepper went so far as to "rage-quit" out. I was shocked that people thought his so-called rage-quitting was scummy. podium's posting throughout the game in general has struck me as townish, so I feel even more confident about this determination.

Early bad vibes coming from Untrod Tripod and Zodiark. I feel like I need to reread those two along with LynchMePls and Tazaro though to place them into the whole big picture. Will do ASAP.