Anon wrote:We actually shouldnt be speculating or discussin about anything else (roles, abilities, etc) We dont want to give scum more information than they have. Its pretty clear one of Chrono and bv is not Saito since there cant be two Saitos in the game. We should lynch one of them.
I agree, This may be a bastard-y game, but two of a single character is excessively bastard.
Anon wrote:I'm willing to believe more bv than Chrono because he counterclaimed and I dont see scum counterclaiming someone they know is town (why get in a 1 on 1?). But Chrono's role feels sincere. Arg, let me think about this.
Genuinely puzzled on my part too, why would a scum member cc a claim? Especially as it forces a 1:1, with the flip of one confirming the other. In this case confirming BV as scum / Myself as town.
--
My crumbs:
Iso #1 wrote:Nash, The (first) Architect, may be a
traitor or
Usurper
Iso #5 wrote:Because If I'm right, one of those roles on the list is [redacted]
<Relevant to my own>
, people should have observed that I was prematurely setup speculating, and think, "He's Setup speculating on D1."
ofc I want Scum to see it and think "OSHI, he may be right on the Usurper" and kill themselves off.
As I can turn one of the mafioso's into a usurper, and Flavourwise Nash makes sense... (In the movie, early on, while Nash is architect, he sells out the team to Saito)
--
-P.Edit: No indication that this may be a dream. Therefore I believe that, as per the OP, which indicates that
Some
already know that this is a dream (And that they're the ones we need to get rid of), that BV is lying scum, as he claims his role PM indicates that he should remember that This is a dream. More BV Votes.-
OP wrote:"It was all a dream"
You all realize you have no idea how you got to the hotel. Hell, you don't even know where the hotel is. The realization that you are all in a dream hits you like a shotgun to the face. Coincidentially, a shotgun to the face is the first solution many of you think of. But you can't be sure dying won't send you straight to limbo, so you figure it's best to stay "alive"
Of course, some of you already knew you were in a dream.
And you all agree that getting rid of those people must be your first priority.
[/quote-