Scummies 2010 Nominations

[boberz]

Nominate Beefster

for most improved player. i played in his first game, in which he was scum, I nailed him Day One and his play was really bad. Later on I played in a game where I was lycnhed early and he replaced in and he is definetly a better player than he was. He really improved.

Can i see the second game please, i was his partner in first and still feel guilty for the bus.

[Seraphim]

I'm going to

Nominate the Mafia of Mafia 117 for Best Performance Scum Group

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

Absolutely floored the town, killed off two of the game's three power roles on Day 1, with RedCoyote sealing the win on Day 2 by dissuading a lynch on his predecessor. Claimed gunsmith after some shenanigans and got the final LYLO mislynch.

[bv310]

Nominate

Vi

for

Name Should Be In Orange

; mostly for deleting hundreds of spam pages and users on the Wiki for a long time. When I saw the deletion log, I was blown away.

Definitely

seconded

.

Thirded.

Fourthed

[Robocopter87]

Nominate Beefster

for most improved player. i played in his first game, in which he was scum, I nailed him Day One and his play was really bad. Later on I played in a game where I was lycnhed early and he replaced in and he is definetly a better player than he was. He really improved.

Can i see the second game please, i was his partner in first and still feel guilty for the bus.

Newbie 956

Newbie 933 was the one where he is BAD. Like, his play was HORRENDOUS.

Its not an extremely amazing improvement. But its pretty impressive.

[Robocopter87]

I'm going to

Nominate the Mafia of Mafia 117 for Best Performance Scum Group

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

Absolutely floored the town, killed off two of the game's three power roles on Day 1, with RedCoyote sealing the win on Day 2 by dissuading a lynch on his predecessor. Claimed gunsmith after some shenanigans and got the final LYLO mislynch.

Listen, they did own the town. but not because they were excellent players. The town frikkin gave them the win. With all the stupid caps lawk raging and lack of activity and apathy people had it was obv the scum were gonna win. just read the link and I don't like the Nomination. If the town had played better this would be a def yes but...they didn't.

[xRECKONERx]

I'm going to

Nominate the Mafia of Mafia 117 for Best Performance Scum Group

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

Absolutely floored the town, killed off two of the game's three power roles on Day 1, with RedCoyote sealing the win on Day 2 by dissuading a lynch on his predecessor. Claimed gunsmith after some shenanigans and got the final LYLO mislynch.

Yeah, I can't really agree with this, town played like shit.

[mykonian]

Nominate the town of The house of Claudius for best performance Pro-Town team

During N1, 3 of the 4 remaining townies are known to have accurate reads on who the two scum were. Scum didn't have a chance.

[Mr. Flay]

Second

- just skimmed that game. Nice work by Town.

[Stef]

I would like to nominate Kast for Most Cunning Manipulator

in Physics Mafia. He was part of the mafia in a neighbor pair with a townie and he completely manipulated the townie into being almost blindly convinced he was also town. He played very good all throughout the game and he read as town to most people and he used his skills to almost convince me to blindly vote for the townie in lylo. Eventually, he manipulated the other townie so good that no matter what I have said I would have still ended up losing the game.

[Ythan]

I'd like to supplement my mafia catcher nomination with this game.

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=14935

[Nicodemus]

I'd like to supplement my mafia catcher nomination with this game.

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=14935

A self-vote at lylo to trap the remaining scum? Ballsy indeed.

[Kdub]

Nominate: ReaperCharlie for best flavor text in Mini 1000 - The Brave and The Beautiful

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

nth nominatation for LynchMePls for Best Newbie.

I've played a few games with him and he always played very, very well. Look at Mini 1008: Mega Man 1 Mafia, he manage to own the town. His town games are also great.

Nominate: ReaperCharlie for best flavor text in Mini 1000 - The Brave and The Beautiful

Seconded.

[Wraith]

Nominate: Archaebob for Paragon of Mafia Hunters for Mini 1026

Specifically this post: viewtopic.php?p=2461135#p2461135

[hasdgfas]

Nominate: Archaebob for Paragon of Mafia Hunters for Mini 1026

Specifically this post: viewtopic.php?p=2461135#p2461135

Player Awards

• Body of Work
  • Best Mafia Catcher
    - "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award

[Ellibereth]

I think a lot of that previous were based off 1 game?

[hasdgfas]

I think a lot of that previous were based off 1 game?

Nominations or winners? Because if it was nominations, I oppose all of them as well. If it was winners, then people forgot what the award actually means. If it's just for one game, it should be more in "Best Performance". There's a reason we have Body of Work as well as single game scummies.

[Wraith]

Oh, whoops. Silly me.

[archaebob]

@ wraith -

Well I do genuinely appreciate being nominated for a scummy, I've decided that I don't think I deserve one for this game. I made a lot of blunders that almost cost the town everything, and it was sheer luck that you guys blundered right back. Anything could have gone wrong, and I definitely didn't have anything to do with the night actions working out so well for town.

I'm very pleased to have been right about all three scum D1, but like has been discussed, it was mostly a tactical maneuver that wound up paying off enormously. I don't take too much pride in having figured out the scum early either; one was an idiot, one I've played way too much with, and the other was being blatantly bussed by the one I've played too much with. I also took a very reckless approach to things, and it would have cost town the game if I had been wrong about any of you, or if the town had been anymore cynical. I feel like this game was really lucky, and I don't want to win a scummy until I feel like I've actually played a strategically solid game throughout.

So while I thank you profusely for your compliments, I wish to respectfully decline the nomination.

[gandalf5166]

nth nominatation for LynchMePls for Best Newbie.

I've played a few games with him and he always played very, very well. Look at Mini 1008: Mega Man 1 Mafia, he manage to own the town. His town games are also great.

Hey, I pegged him as scum >.> But no one else would listen >.>

[animorpherv1]

no one else would listen >.>

This is the key point right here.

[Ythan]

Finding scum is only part of good town play. It doesn't matter if you find every one of them in RVS if you can't get them lynched.

[pacman281292]

Nominate: ReaperCharlie for best flavor text in Mini 1000 - The Brave and The Beautiful

Second.
I skimmed that game. It was really good.

[Robocopter87]

Nominate: ReaperCharlie for best flavor text in Mini 1000 - The Brave and The Beautiful

Fourthed,

Reaper did an OUTSTANDING job with flavor and the sort. It was also a pretty darn good setup.

[gandalf5166]

Finding scum is only part of good town play. It doesn't matter if you find every one of them in RVS if you can't get them lynched.

That's exactly what happened. I called them both out in RVS, but I thought shotty was the third scum and lynched him because he was an easier case. Then when he flipped town, I kind of lost trust in my reads.....