Okay, I've read page 34.
flinter wrote:just follow the link UA used small text, Nhammen found this. As far as I know, this is almost always prohibited: and setting your buddy up for problems with the mod (if you have the choice) is hardly something scum would do.
Nowhere in the rules does it state that small text isn't allowed, so I don't think it means anything.
flinter, when you switched your vote from Mysterio to Singersigner day 1, was that because you found her more suspicious at that time? You voted her, but singersigner never responded, and you didn't seem to care about that either. You ended up switching your vote again. You didn't seem to care about that vote either.
flinter wrote:I'm sorry? Dana is actually one of my town reads (it is a gutread, so I know it isn't worth anything here). I suspect bunny who was wishy washy about Dana. This while logically, bunny's arguments made sense.
You still haven't explained why Xite wasn't worthy of your vote at that time. You had more points against Xite than you did Mysterio.
flinter wrote:And I "ignored" Mysterio's defense, because it in no way adressed his change from "lets stay calm!" to "BANDWAGON!!!". Which is why my vote has been on him the rest of day 1. A revote was far from surprising.
If you were actually interested in figuring out Mysterio's allignment, then why didn't you tell him what you wanted him to explain? If you were town, I wouldn't think you would simply ignore his defense. I would think that you as town would explain why the defense doesn't convince you.
Gorrad wrote:Please tell me you don't ACTUALLY believe this. That kill could have come from:
SK
1.) A second kill from the same mafia (I've given specific mafia members addition one-shot kills in the past)
[2.) Vig
PGO (for those unfamiliar with the role, kills those who target it at night. All in all unlikely given that the deceased is vanilla, but possible)
In a previous Flameaxe game, when two cult recruiters targeted the same person, that person died. Though I'm not suggesting a cult in this game, there could be two such counteracting roles.
Inventor
Reflector
ANY OTHER ROLE that Flameaxe could have made up. Even though this is a normal, BBM is far from your traditional mod. If we don't have some downright extraordinary roles this game, I will be shocked. By Science.]
3.) All that said? Probably SK or Vig. But do not make the mistake of thinking that it could only be a SK.
1.) If the mafia had two kills, then why would they have killed one of their own?
2.) Didn't really think of any of these possibilities. Has he used any of these in a Large
Normal
before? Links?
3.) Why are you arguing with me if you agree with my conclusion? I don't think I said that I was certain that this was the case, and if I did then I didn't mean to say that.
Wraith's case against ConfidAnon brings up 2 or 3 good points, but I'm not seeing the nhammen + ConfidAnon scumbuddy theory. I can't see nhammen strongly connecting himself to him like that. ConfidAnon could be from another anti-town faction however.
Wraith's points against Mysterio pretty much comes down to opportunism. However, I'm glad he brought up his vote for Wraith, because looking at it again it was actually extremely opportunistic: He says Wraith's behavior has been everything but pro-town, yet didn't mention Wraith once prior to the vote.
Wraith's ConfidAnon/Mysterio/Porochaz/nhammen scum group suggestion is kind of reaching. A summary of his case is nhammen is scum, ConfidAnon is also scum and nhammen's buddy, Mysterio is connected to ConfidAnon, so he's scum, and Porochaz is connected to Mysterio so he's also scum. Wraith, you don't need to be jumping to conclusions so soon when you don't know any of their flips.
Also, Wraith, several times you used the point that nhammen agreed with ConfidAnon and Mysterio, so they are his buddies. This is a bad point from your perspective. nhammen agreed with my posts a lot (probably more than Mysterio and ConfidAnon), yet you seem to think I'm town. Also, I'm sure he agreed with other players too.
3 pages left.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take. -Wayne Gretzky"
-Wickedestjr
Is it really unusual for somebody to not suspect a suspicious looking townie? A few months ago I played in a game where there were three players who we were deciding between for a lynch. I wasn't mafia, I believed that they were all town, and I was correct.