Mini 1038 - Inception (Day One Archive)

[AlmasterGM]

Greetings to bv310, Chronopie, Iecerint, manho, ooba, and Seraphim.

Setup spec in this game is going to be LOL so trying is WOOSH.

Vote: Chronopie

, he'll be scum at some point anyway, so might as well just have that vote down early.

[bv310]

Hello there! I think I've played with all of you besides Tuberkulosis and Data before.

Vote: Switz

[Data]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Blood

My dear BloodCovenant, allow me to state the reasons this vote is elementary!

Aside from the reasons others have pointed out, I find his unvote in his first post to perhaps be indicative of an edited post in which more was initially said, and someone else was voted for. Why would a person unvote in their first post of the game otherwise? Who would most have motivation to edit out a real vote? Scum, of course, would have more of a motivation for this than would town.

Like the great Sherlock Holmes, I seek an answer to this mystery.

[Switz]

Hello, all. Welcome to the dream, etc, etc.

Choosing between ooba and BC was a bit tricky, but misrepping beats a weird early Unvote and a modvote in my book.

Vote: ooba

And maybe I'm just obtuse, but I don't understand Data's point above about BC's post being an edited one. Why would scum be more likely than town to intend to (presumably random) vote someone, immediately unvote, and then vote the mod?

[Seraphim]

Vote: Manho

I find his revote back into the RVS to be the scummiest thing that's happened so far all game.

I'm also rather leery of the alt. Personality/roleplay alts tend to be harder to read because their actions/reactions aren't genuine, they are a personality designed to act in a certain manner. While I have no problem with alts, personalities like Data make it difficult to scumhunt, at least for me. So I'll be watching him quite carefully.

HI ALMASTER.

[Anon]

Sup, people. By page 2, I already found a scumbag:

Greetings.
For those that haven't had the (mis)fortune to play with me before, I'm Chronopie (but you can call me Chrono), one of the constantly and consistently scummy players of MS today. ofc I recall seeing most of the playerlist ingame before.

So basically you are going to excuse all your scummy behavior in your playstyle, right? Nice try, scumbag.

Premature Setup Speculation time!!11!!!
If we have a Vig/SK, it's probably Mal, the shade
Eames, the forger, may be InvImmune.
Nash, The (first) Architect, may be a traitor or Usurper
Arthur, The Pointman, may be an investigative role.
Yusuf, The Chemist, may be a protective role.
Wikipedia link here

I dislike this. First you are speculating about the setup with no solid reasoning, potentially opening a hole for subtle rolefishing. Second, you are trying to be helpful too soon, something like trying too hard, which is what most of the times scum do to have a nice impression.

So yeah, please die.

Vote: Chronopie

[Anon]

Hello, all. Welcome to the dream, etc, etc.

Choosing between ooba and BC was a bit tricky, but misrepping beats a weird early Unvote and a modvote in my book.

Vote: ooba

Switz, Why DID YOU HAVE to choose between Ooba and RC?

[manho]

Vote: Manho

I find his revote back into the RVS to be the scummiest thing that's happened so far all game.

i find ooba's reaction not from scum, so i unvoted.

[Anon]

manho is town for the blatant votehoping.

[Seraphim]

yes but then you voted Anon. Why?

Also, Anon, your logic fails...if manho is town for blatant votehopping, what makes Chrono scum for blatant rolefishing/setup speculation?

[Anon]

yes but then you voted Anon. Why?

Also, Anon, your logic fails...if manho is town for blatant votehopping, what makes Chrono scum for blatant rolefishing/setup speculation?

My logic doesnt fail.

Manho is TOWN because he IS NOT scared of what people think about him. He votes whoever he thinks is scum. He unvotes whoever he thinks is town. He doesnt care if people see him as a votehopper.

Chronopie is SCUM because he IS scared of what people think about him. His first post was dedicated to stablish the precedent that he IS a scummy player and that we should acept that as his playstyle. Scummy. His second post was dedicated to appear helpful by trying to speculate about the setup with no SOLID evidence and adding a wikipedia link.

TELLS do help but they are not that powerful. You HAVE to analyse MOTIVATIONS.

[Switz]

Hello, all. Welcome to the dream, etc, etc.

Choosing between ooba and BC was a bit tricky, but misrepping beats a weird early Unvote and a modvote in my book.

Vote: ooba

Switz, Why DID YOU HAVE to choose between Ooba and RC?

Um, I didn't. Those two just looked about equally scummy to me on first read, so I made a gut call based on what I wrote above.

Anon makes a good point with Chrono though. I've read games with him in them before so the admission that he always looks scummy didn't catch my eye as anything out of the ordinary.

[manho]

yes but then you voted Anon. Why?

random.

[AlmasterGM]

manho smells like lies. The ooba vote was followed by a quote. Calling it random is a non-sequitor - what was the quote there for, shits and giggles?

Unvote. Vote: manho

[manho]

manho smells like lies. The ooba vote was followed by a quote. Calling it random is a non-sequitor - what was the quote there for, shits and giggles?

Unvote. Vote: manho

random is for the anon vote. the ooba vote is for his "putting word in chrono's mouth", but i then understand it, and unvoted.

[Chronopie]

Trying to build a mountain out of a molehill here anon.

The first was saying hi.

The second was exactly as intended. Speculation, given movie flavour, at what roles may or may not be in the game. It was

not

intended for anyone to claim, to confirm/deny that said role existed. Therefore, not rolefishing.

UNVOTE: Data
VOTE: Anon

[Data]

Hello, all. Welcome to the dream, etc, etc.

Choosing between ooba and BC was a bit tricky, but misrepping beats a weird early Unvote and a modvote in my book.

Vote: ooba

And maybe I'm just obtuse, but I don't understand Data's point above about BC's post being an edited one. Why would scum be more likely than town to intend to (presumably random) vote someone, immediately unvote, and then vote the mod?

I am running under the assumption that scum are more preoccupied with how they present themselves to the town, and are thus more likely to have second thoughts about a vote. The oddly placed unvote is possible evidence of editing, and thus a point of intrigue.

Anon's case on Chrono runs along a similar train of thought, and I intend to migrate to the Chrono wagon if BC responds adequately to my assertions. I am not as convinced regarding Anon's guess that manho is town, however.

[Tuberkulos]

Manho is TOWN because he IS NOT scared of what people think about him. He votes whoever he thinks is scum. He unvotes whoever he thinks is town. He doesnt care if people see him as a votehopper.

Chronopie is SCUM because he IS scared of what people think about him. His first post was dedicated to stablish the precedent that he IS a scummy player and that we should acept that as his playstyle. Scummy. His second post was dedicated to appear helpful by trying to speculate about the setup with no SOLID evidence and adding a wikipedia link.

Is Data scummy because he urged us to accept his playstyle?

[Tuberkulos]

EBWOP

Manho is TOWN because he IS NOT scared of what people think about him. He votes whoever he thinks is scum. He unvotes whoever he thinks is town. He doesnt care if people see him as a votehopper.

Chronopie is SCUM because he IS scared of what people think about him. His first post was dedicated to stablish the precedent that he IS a scummy player and that we should acept that as his playstyle. Scummy. His second post was dedicated to appear helpful by trying to speculate about the setup with no SOLID evidence and adding a wikipedia link.

Is Data scummy because he urged us to accept his playstyle?

[TonyMontana]

Just like Inception, this game is actually based on Dreamscape

Vote Count One

L-4

BloodCovenent

- ooba, Iecerint, Data

L-5

anon

- manho, Chronopie
L-5

manho

- Seraphim, AlmasterGM
L-6

AlmasterGM

- tuberkulos
L-6

Chronopie

- anon
L-6

ooba

- Switz
L-6

Switz

- bv310

Not Voting

- BloodCovenent

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

Deadline in ~6.5 days

[ooba]

Greetings Almaster!

Good to see a lot of familiar faces this game ..

---

Um, I didn't. Those two just looked about equally scummy to me on first read, so I made a gut call based on what I wrote above.

Anon makes a good point with Chrono though. I've read games with him in them before so the admission that he always looks scummy didn't catch my eye as anything out of the ordinary.

This post is over defensive... Prempting someone saying "So why didn't chrono look scummy on your first read" ..

Vote: Switz

---

Also I think its best I claim this at the outset .. I thought about breadcrumbing it so that I can point to it later but I sort of suck at that so ..

I am Miller.

[ooba]

ebwop: I missed a "a" in there .. "I am a Miller".

[manho]

ebwop: I missed a "a" in there .. "I am a Miller".

is that missing "a" really matter?

[Tuberkulos]

I am a Miller.

Which role from the movie did you get?

[ooba]

@manho - It doesn't but I hate making obvious errors - esp. since its in bold ..

@Tuberkulos - I am not claiming that right now . Plus any other abilities I might have.