Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[ZeroFang]

Read my ISO if you are going to make a case against me then use your head? Works wonders!

Read my ISO if you want to see the case against you and then use your head? Works wonders!

[Switz]

Goddammit, Enigma, stop being snarky and actually contribute. At least Zajnet's not even bothering to not defend himself.

Unvote; Vote: Enigma

[Enigma]

I don't understand why you guys think millar is suss...

I felt pretty convinced that he is actually a lover. The concern here is there is a doctor and with 16 players to choose from, the most logical one would be to protect a 'confirmed' lover hence save a possible 2 town deaths.

@Muthaa: He said his partner was on the prod list (what yabba quoted),

so there are only 3 possible suspects for his lover remaining, me, switz, and you.

Now ideally we want to avoid having any more lover claims unless it is absolutely necessary so hopefully neither of us 3 would want to distance ourselves from being lovers to isolate the other 2. More confirmed lovers means it's much more likely the town:mafia ratio will suffer in the upcoming days and doctor pure luck is harder to come by.
I don't understand why you being on the short list are distancing yourself away from millar, because it's a pretty anti town thing to do. Ideally all three of us (unless one of us were scum) would try to prevent millar's lover from being isolated.

Care to explain why you are still attacking millar?

If you are going to find me suspicious at least read all my posts. It's not hard to pick out who exactly is millar's lover and I'm sure other people would have noticed it already.

Goes to show who just wants to promote a mislynch for the sake of lynching and don't really read through posts much and who wants to actually make sure who they are lynching are actually scum.

Since by Zerofang's awesome logic I am going to be nightkilled and I am useless anyways unless I claim:

Claim Lover.

[DavidParker]

Well, better night killed than lynched.

Unvote

Miller gonna confirm this?

[Enigma]

Does millar look like hes actually been in this thread recently?

You know what's a smarter idea? Asking the other 2 parties if they are the lover or not.

[Switz]

Oh. Well, I guess that would make sense. I'm not Millar's Lover, so unless Muthaa counterclaims,

Unvote; Vote: Zajnet

.

Since you're now in significantly more danger of NKing, any chance you could give us your thoughts on who's scummy?

[don_johnson]

unvote, vote: mallowgeno

enigma: being confirmed doesn't mean you don't have to contribute. you know what would have been better than a lover claim? a post with actual content and scumhunting.

[Mr.Sandman]

Does millar look like hes actually been in this thread recently?

You know what's a smarter idea? Asking the other 2 parties if they are the lover or not.

You're saying the other two lovers should claim to prove your innocence? Terrible idea.

Don, where does this connection between Mallow and zero come from...

Mallowgeno first. If scum, zero next. More when I return from vacation.

...and what do you think of Zajnet?

[Muthaa]

I'm not millar's lover either.

[ZeroFang]

Unvote; Vote: Zajnet

I'm not millar's lover.

Does millar look like hes actually been in this thread recently?

You know what's a smarter idea? Asking the other 2 parties if they are the lover or not.

You're saying the other two lovers should claim to prove your innocence? Terrible idea.

Don, where does this connection between Mallow and zero come from...

This man speaks the truth.

[Robocopter87]

^^^ Need to bold.

[ZeroFang]

^^^ Need to bold.

I always forget that don't I.

Unvote; Vote: Zajnet

[don_johnson]

zero: why not vote mallowgeno?

[Mr.Sandman]

Whoever said Robo was scum, after reading his post 3 above, I just ISO'd him, and I think you may be right. Things I noticed: voted chiuahua at the start of day 1 (possible bussing) but changed to millar then xite and towards the end, rejoins the chiauhua bandwagon when prompted by Fidelis, with this vote.

unvote vote Chi

I shall help in this endeavor I guess.

A reluctant vote if ever I saw one. It has nothing to do with the reasons he had against chi before. He doesn’t even bring them up again. He makes no effort to support the bandwagon, it almost seems at points as if he is discouraging it, but he joins it anyway.

Tries to buy chi some time, despite being one of the ones voting him:

Hey, Chi hasn't posted in this game or the other game I'm in with him.

Day 2, contributed very little of value, just one liners here and there. Big contrast to what he had been like pre-Chi bandwagon.

Don't know if he needs one more but,

unvote vote SV

Wow.

Gets on the SV wagon AFTER SV had self hammered. Doesn’t say anything at the time then a few posts on, gets all celebratory on us.

Day 3, has posted to avoid prods for 5 pages and contributed absolutely nothing. Example of this being 3 above. Hasn’t commented on anything that has happened today or any other day yet.

I like the Zajnet case and I will rejoin that one if this one doesn’t look like it’ll take off the ground today, but I feel more sure about this one as I see pretty much nothing that would give me any confidence that Robo is townie.

unvote, vote Robo

[ZeroFang]

zero: why not vote mallowgeno?

Because at the moment I suspect Zajnet more.

I ISOed mallow really quickly, and I actually find him a bit scummier than Zaj. I'm going to do a bit more research before I change my vote, but it's something to look in to.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Day Three, vote Count #2

• mallowgeno (Zajnet, Robocopter87, don_johnson) 3 L-5
  Muthaa (mallowgeno) 1 L-7
  Robocopter87 (Mr.Sandman) 1 L-7
  Wacka Alpaca (Sanxion, Muthaa) 2 L-6
  Zajnet (Switz, ZeroFang) 2 L-6

Not voting: DavidParker, Enigma, millar13, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Wacka Alpaca

With 14 alive, 8 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA:

mallowgeno (Friday, 20th August)

Activity Check!

millar13 requires replacement. Sigh.

Prod Count:

smashbro_of_the_SSS - 2

chihuahua0, millar13, Muthaa, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, Shattered Viewpoint, youngminii - 1

Deadline for Day Three is Monday, August 23rd at 8pm UK time.

[don_johnson]

hey guys, its my birthday. in lieu of gifts and well wishes i will be accepting mallow votes...

[DavidParker]

Vote: mallow

[don_johnson]

happy birthday to me...

[ZeroFang]

Your ava's a monkey and you smell like one too!

Just kidding. Kinda

[don_johnson]

Wow. This is shaping up to be the worst birthday ever.

[Muthaa]

Probably because you're on your computer right now...

[Mr.Sandman]

Today has been pathetic. Deadline on Monday and we have absolutely no consensus on who the lynch should be. Players just popping on to vote and not adding anything else don't help. Given that there is a high chance we'll lose two more townies tonight if Enigma's claim is correct, I don't see where this lacaidaisical attitude has come from.

Further point to add to my case on robo, he has been posting and active in other games, it's just this one in which he chooses to active lurk in.

I still think that given day 1, Xite/mallow is unlikely scum. Could someone set out a case on mallowgeno for me. Something more than two lines would be nice.

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

Hi guys, unfortunarely, I'll be V/LA until Monday; this weekend I'm moving into college, so idk when I will have time before Monday to get online.

As for the cases, I believe that the Zajnet one is strongest, so

vote: Zajnet

As for Mallow and Xite, I recently was playing a game where Xite acted close to how she did in this game (i believe) and turned out to be scum on the flip. I'll have to reread that slot, see what i think. I have to go to work now, so hopefully more tonight.

[Robocopter87]

Further point to add to my case on robo, he has been posting and active in other games, it's just this one in which he chooses to active lurk in.

It be true, I have been a little apathetic towards this game.

I agree we need to get it together and lynch someone. Just SOMEONE, to avoid a No Lynch.