Mini 1014 - Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over

[d3x]

It has been my experience that Millers flip 'Miller' and not 'Townie' upon their deaths.

[Zachrulez]

Well Furcolow flipped town ghost.

Since the flavor of my cop role is that I check people to see if they are ghosts, I think it's safe to say he was a miller.

[sottyrulez]

Reposting for iso purposes.

Well Furcolow flipped town ghost.

Since the flavor of my cop role is that I check people to see if they are ghosts, I think it's safe to say he was a miller.

[Scott Brosius]

My theory - Peter is the lead character in GB... DRS knows this, and fakeclaimed knowing that anyone in the Peter role, would have a PR... or at least likely to have one. He wanted to expose a PR with his fake claim.

You overestimate drshotty's gambit ability. There's a lingering suspicion that he is being ridiculous again and claiming as town, but he needs to be lynched regardless (if not today, tomorrow)

I am Baby Oscar Barrett and being innocent and adorable, I am Beloved. It's ultimately a Beloved Princess role. The fluff of my Role revolves around the Ghosts {specifically Vigo the Carpathian} trying to find me so that they can become more powerful.

Unfortunately this means 2 things.

1. If you guys Lynch me {and Scum are sure to be pushing for it, now more than ever} we'll lose a Day.
2. If I'm NKed, the same thing will happen.

I guess we're damned if we do and damned if we don't.

So are the Ghosts actively hunting you in an attempt to grow stronger? Or is that just filler Role PM stuff? If there is a way for the scum to increase their powers, you need to die.

I don't think there are holes in the claim, but it's difficult to believe that a player who has been investigated as guilty, claims a role that is detrimental to town if he is lynched or NKed. That seems like a great fake-claim to save yourself.

[sottyrulez]

All of d3x's play from the point of our investigation reveal has been designed around self preservation, which is really the biggest red flag of all.

[XScorpion]

Why would Lynching me tomorrow over today be more beneficial to the Town?

Because you may or may not be lying, whereas I know for sure that Shotty is lying. I guarantee shotty won't be killed by scum tonight, but assuming you're telling the truth, you might.

Where are you getting the 1st 'princess-ish' Role?

Did you miss the part where mallowgeno claimed? Pay attention.

[jasonT1981]

I was afraid something like that was going to happen. I got a Mod PM last night saying that I had been 'Slimed'. At the time, I didn't know exactly what that meant, but now I can be sure. I guess it's Claim time.

I am Baby Oscar Barrett and being innocent and adorable, I am Beloved. It's ultimately a Beloved Princess role. The fluff of my Role revolves around the Ghosts {specifically Vigo the Carpathian} trying to find me so that they can become more powerful.

Its amazing how they found you on night one... especially since you did nothing in game to make it seem like you were a threat to them to make them target you in the first place.

[Coach Travis]

I don't buy the claim at all, the whole thing sounds forced to me, and just a bit ridiculous, plus the whole thing of claiming a role that would hurt the town upon lynch really does just seem like self preservation. I still think he's the best lynch option.

[LimMePls]

I don't buy the claim.

Vote: d3x

L-2.

[drmyshottyizsik]

I think it's believable. I mean he would have to be pretty creative to come up with that fluff, and really what is the point in claiming that? It has no bennefits as scum. First of it's unlikely so you guys will jump on him, scum first. Then if he isn't nk'd he will be lynched tomorrow instantly. But it also has a town benefit. Now, if you guys believe him, there is no reason for a mislynch on him during the day. Instead we can scum hunt and kill a scum instead. ALSO!!! I want to make this VERY clear. If he isn't lynch today and he isn't Nk'd tonight, please don't instalynch him. Because scum could always kill some one else, then get you guys to lynch him. And once again they get a free nk and a mislynch. But the other thing that really bothers me about his claim and is making me

FoS

him is that he totally forgot about my doctornes. He should have asked me to protect him. And that is the only thing I find scummy about his claim. Scum would be the ones who wouldn't think to ask for protection, because they aren't really scared of being Nk'd.

[XScorpion]

But the other thing that really bothers me about his claim and is making me FoS him is that he totally forgot about my doctornes. He should have asked me to protect him.

What.
The.
Hell.

[drmyshottyizsik]

But the other thing that really bothers me about his claim and is making me FoS him is that he totally forgot about my doctornes. He should have asked me to protect him.

What.
The.
Hell.

If you were scared that being Nk'd would totally kill the town, the great thing would be to say hey protect me. Or if he wasn't dumb, then asumming that he would be protected should have happened

[XScorpion]

Are you claiming doctor now?

[drmyshottyizsik]

Oh sorry no. I was typing hypitheticly.
No but he should ask for a Doc to protect him or at least not be so scared of being Nk'd because a Doc would protect him.

[sottyrulez]

Awesome.

We're still not lynching Shotty first. d3x really wants to stay alive as long as possible and I'm curious why.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Awesome.

We're still not lynching Shotty first. d3x really wants to stay alive as long as possible and I'm curious why.

Maybe because he is telling the truth.(but I don't think so)

[XScorpion]

then...vote him? lol.

[sottyrulez]

Townies are generally more concerned with helping the town than they are with self preservation.

[drmyshottyizsik]

then...vote him? lol.

I'm not 100% sure man I mean if he is telling the truth then we just fucked up
but ok

unvote
Vote DmwhateverthelettersandnumberarebecauseIdontfeellikelooking

And sotty isn't not lynching a town member helping the town?

[sottyrulez]

IF he's town, which I seriously doubt.

[drmyshottyizsik]

IF he's town, which I seriously doubt.

Me to, but it will suck if he is

[sottyrulez]

Umm... why are you asking for a CC, sr? Why are you assuming that there's only 1 Cop?

@Everyone else- If you're a Cop, plz don't Claim.

Why are you assuming that we are a cop?

Yeah, I'm also not liking shotty so far, and considering my thoughts on Reck, he may be the best lynch option. Of course, I'm interested to see the investigation results, since at this point I agree sotty has no reason to claim if they aren't actually the cop.

Said the Scum.

Regardless of what's about to go down, the last few pages shows that we have 2 or 3 Caught Scum.

1- sr's Investigation result {assuming it's neither of the next 2}
2- one of Ghost Writer and Drshotty {hint- it's not GW}
3- CT

Why CT? Aside from everything yesterday {seriously, why didn't we Lynch this guy}, because "not liking" has nothing to do with the Counter Claim of GW. The above post felt very noncommittal to me. One of the two of them {barring the highly unlikely scenario previously presented of Drshotty FakeClaiming as Town} is Scum. Period. I think it's pretty obvious that it's Drshotty. Why would Scum Ghost Writer expose himself {

*snicker*

} for no reason what-so-ever to get one of the 2 Claimed Cops Lynched. Especially before sr's results were shown.

The question we are now left with is this. In what order do we want to clean house? I would like to wait for sr's results before we decide, but I'm strongly leaning...
sr's Result -> Drshotty -> CT
Reason being we have a Cop result from sr, then we have a CC on Drshotty, then we have scummy play and evidence on CT. With any luck, that's the whole ScumTeam and we just won.

If we're in some alternate reality where alignment is dictated by facial hair, I guess Drshotty could be telling the truth and have a Guilty on XS; making the team sr's Result, XS, and Ghost Writer, but I can't see that happening in anything but said evil universe.

Seems content with stating that we have several scum caught with reactions to our claim + guilty result. If one of the possible results was a guilty on him, why is d3x not concerned about this? Why not come out with the truth of his "claim" here? The guilty result might not even be on him. (And clearly he didn't think it was.) Being up front about the "sliming" at the least would seem like it would be information that would help town. d3x's behavior seems more like a scum who was hoping that the result WASN'T on him.

In addition to that, the notion that d3x might survive and the argument not to autolynch him in that case is downright amusing. If he is town, the scum are going to kill him to ensure the extra night. The only real reason for him to survive the night is if he's actually scum.

[drmyshottyizsik]

What if he is protected?

[sottyrulez]

That shouldn't happen.

We also shouldn't be speculating about protective roles. Last thing we want is to out any of those roles.

[XScorpion]

I think Sotty is the appropriate person to defend at this point