Mini 1014 - Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over

[jasonT1981]

GW has a lot to lose over the CC... I mean, if DRS flips Peter on a lynch, GW will be screwed the next day and will have NO out for the counterclaim.

My theory - Peter is the lead character in GB... DRS knows this, and fakeclaimed knowing that anyone in the Peter role, would have a PR... or at least likely to have one. He wanted to expose a PR with his fake claim.

I am sure DRS is scum... BUT I don't want a lynch right now, people still need to give their reads on the game such as SB and more importantly Sotty has a guilty.. we cant lynch until Sotty reveals it. It is very important we do not lynch before Sottys guilty is revealed.

[LimMePls]

^^Truf.

[sottyrulez]

Ok guys, Shotty's not going to be the lynch today even though I'm very much leaning that way over GW. As clear cut as that situation looks, I simply don't have a guilty result on Shotty.

The guy I actually have a guilty result on is d3x, and I think that result and the interactions we have gotten say a lot toward Coach Travis likely being town.

After d3x, I suspect shotty due to his claim and ghost writer's counter making much more sense, and I'm pretty weary of Starbuck's lurking at this point, I wouldn't be surprised if she turned out to be scum. I definitely wouldn't like to see her getting a pass to endgame with her activity level being such as it is.

Vote: d3x

[XScorpion]

I still think we lynch shotty first, just because we know for a fact that one of Shotty or GW is scum.

[jasonT1981]

ok. Starbuck has promised content by monday. I hope she delievers

vote:D3X

[sottyrulez]

I still think we lynch shotty first, just because we know for a fact that one of Shotty or GW is scum.

I'm in a position to trust my guilty result in this situation, mainly because the reason I investigated d3x in the first place was because he was playing lurky, and when he did post he didn't post with the pro activeness that I've known him to post with when he's town.

Given that, I'd prefer to lynch my guilty over picking one of GW and Shotty to lynch.

[XScorpion]

Whatever. Either one is fine.

unvote
Vote: D3x

[Coach Travis]

Good catch on D3x, I never really said much about him to this point, simply because his lurky playstyle was challenging to read, and I never really got much from reading his posts, he wasn't really saying much nobody else was saying, like he was trying his best to not stand out:a clear scum tactic. So yeah, I'll trust that investigation, and

Vote:D3x

Finally looked into the whole thing with shotty and GW, and I agree that one of those, likely shotty, should be our next lynch.

[LimMePls]

I'm ok with the d3x lynch, but I'd like a vote count first.

@Mod: Can we get a vote count please?

[jasonT1981]

2- one of Ghost Writer and Drshotty {hint- it's not GW}

sr's Result -> Drshotty -> CT
Reason being we have a Cop result from sr, then we have a CC on Drshotty, then we have scummy play and evidence on CT. With any luck, that's the whole ScumTeam and we just won.

If we're in some alternate reality where alignment is dictated by facial hair, I guess Drshotty could be telling the truth and have a Guilty on XS; making the team sr's Result, XS, and Ghost Writer, but I can't see that happening in anything but said evil universe.

HEH HEH HEH BUSSING IN BOLD!!!!!!

Also, in his big catch up... not one mention I can see of DRShotty

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 4#p2423854

Infact, his earlier 'game stuff' post catch up also contained no mention of DRS

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 7#p2403067

Scum team BUSTED!!

[jasonT1981]

Heh heh heh

On Iso of DRS not one mention of D3x in

ANYTHING.

.. not one mention the Entire game.

[XScorpion]

That's why I voted for him yesterday lol...he had basically posted nothing (didn't he replace Reckoner?)
Also I doubt there are only 2 scum in a 12 player game...there is probably either a 3rd scum or a 3rd party, leaning towards 3rd scum because no one died last night.

[XScorpion]

Lol...here's the extent of how much Reckoner had to say about d3x:

I like d3x.

Awesome.

[CallMeLiam]

Vote Count

XScorpion

- 1 - drmyshottyizsik

drmyshottyizsik

- 2 - Ghostwriter, LynchMePls

d3x

- 3 - sottyrulez, jasonT1981, XScorpion

Not Voting

- 8 - d3x, Coach Travis, Starbuck, , Scott Brosius, mallowgeno,

Six votes to lynch

[d3x]

I was afraid something like that was going to happen. I got a Mod PM last night saying that I had been 'Slimed'. At the time, I didn't know exactly what that meant, but now I can be sure. I guess it's Claim time.

I am Baby Oscar Barrett and being innocent and adorable, I am Beloved. It's ultimately a Beloved Princess role. The fluff of my Role revolves around the Ghosts {specifically Vigo the Carpathian} trying to find me so that they can become more powerful.

Unfortunately this means 2 things.

1. If you guys Lynch me {and Scum are sure to be pushing for it, now more than ever} we'll lose a Day.
2. If I'm NKed, the same thing will happen.

I guess we're damned if we do and damned if we don't.

Regarding jT's points on me talking about drshotty; he wasn't in the game when I had made either of those posts. I would find it rather weird if I had spoken to/about him.

Regarding my activity level in this game; I've been on V/LA, had house guests, overseen the downstairs being remodeled, and started a new job all within the last 2 weeks alone. Check my last few games, my activity has been dipping for some time and I'm fairly sure I'm going to disappear for a while again {as I did at the end of last year}. Hell, read Star Wars Mafia {or ask the guys who were in it with me: Scott and LMP}.

I'm throwing my Vote where it belongs.

Vote: drmyshottyizsik

[jasonT1981]

fair enough on your point on DRS, i forgot he replaced into the game late.

[sottyrulez]

Are we supposed to believe there is two miller-ish roles in this game?

[XScorpion]

We could always lynch shotty today and d3x (if he survives, which is unlikely if he's telling the truth) tomorrow...

[XScorpion]

Sotty- I think you mean princess-ish roles.

Also d3x: Why didn't you tell us you were 'slimed' at the beginning of the day? What reason would you have for keeping it secret?

[sottyrulez]

See the problem here is that we already lynched Slimer.

[d3x]

@sr-

Are we supposed to believe there is two miller-ish roles in this game?

No. I haven't seen the first 'miller-ish' Role, but aside from that, it's not my Role that made me flip Guilty. It was whatever Scum ability is out there to Slime people. I'm not a Miller, I'm Beloved.

@XS-

We could always lynch shotty today and d3x (if he survives, which is unlikely if he's telling the truth) tomorrow...

Why would Lynching me tomorrow over today be more beneficial to the Town?

I think you mean princess-ish roles.

Where are you getting the 1st 'princess-ish' Role?

Why didn't you tell us you were 'slimed' at the beginning of the day? What reason would you have for keeping it secret?

The first real post of the Day was a Cop saying they had a Guilty. Immediately saying that I probably would have investigated Guilty would be AutoLynch. It'd be like Claiming Miller after you're investigated. Keep in mind, I did not know what it meant that I was Slimed, the Mod didn't say. Also, I have the feeling that it's a temporary state. It would be ridiculous powerful to have a permanent Miller maker in a game. Unless the Scum wanted to paint me every Night, it wouldn't be an issue.

@sr-

See the problem here is that we already lynched Slimer.

And? Slimer was not the only one who Slimed people. There was an entire underground subway system of ooze in the second movie. In fact, when Slimer Slimed someone, it didn't actually do anything. When the GBers were doused in the Slime from the subway, they started acting differently until they were cleaned off. It wouldn't make sense for this ability to be Slimer's {regardless of his name}.

[sottyrulez]

d3x needs to die. His role claim is filled with holes and he needs to be lynched. For some reason he really wants an extra night, we're not giving it to him.

Shotty is probably his buddy who he is bussing. So if we lynch shotty today and he flips scum d3x gets to argue his point some more. No. Lynch him now.

d3x is claiming to have been slimed, that's what I meant by talking about another miller role. I don't buy it for one second.

[d3x]

Who is the first Miller-ish Role, sr?

[d3x]

While you're at it, what are the holes in my Role Claim?

Role- Baby Oscar Barrett
Function- Beloved

[sottyrulez]

Slimer would have come up as a ghost so it's not much of a leap to assume that the role was a miller.