Ythan wrote:I could always randomly reassign mafia roles between the living and dead mafia players if anyone believes that would be less intrusive than the mistake itself.
Your discretion. As nh stated, the damage has already been done in confirming the existance of an SK (unless his logic is wrong, which it doesn't look to be).
Vote Agar
Nh noted a possible situation in the mastalk which Mafuyu agrees with. Specifically, he noted Agar's similarity in action with another scum member regarding how Mafuyu began the fullclaim (namely, mentioning the existance of at least one M as opposed to stating outright Mason Pair). Nh could probably provide a better explanation, when he's not studying for grad test.
Mafuyu is also of the opinion that scum and SK will try to communicate today in some fashion. Having two confirmed town in a population-stacked scenario means that they have to coordinate kills (specifically, in decimating the mason pair so as to remove the confirmation advantage that town now has).
Lastly for this post, setup speculation. Mafuyu believes the following, and would like counterpoints if any of these thoughts are faulty:
DD should not claim (Backup Doctor). Doing so directs tonight's kill as follows: Doc-Bypass SK to Mason, Scum to Backup.
CC is a dead-end thought unless millers are not naiive.
V probably does not exist, but if they somehow do then a claim is best, as it puts the SK in a very rough situation. Hiding Vig-hood only creates end-game problems at this point, so it's better to have SK squirm (and thus commit more tells) than remain hidden.
MMM can't happen by Ythan's IC explanation (that they are confirmed from the start).
B should not claim unless placed at L-1 or L-2. B anonymity is useful to hamper the remaining scum, and SK doesn't care one way or another (unless they claim Vig, B roleblocks, and the block fizzles, which won't happen).
Guh. The words.
