Open 239 - C9++

[Ythan]

Mafuyu (0):
Fate (0):
animorpherv1 (0):
Ythill (2): Fate, Nobody Special
nhammen (0):
drmyshottyizsik (1): Fishythefish
Fishythefish (0):
Andrius (0):
Nobody Special (0):
Unsight (1): Andrius
AGar (0):

not voting (7):
Mafuyu
animorpherv1
Ythill
nhammen
drmyshottyizsik
Unsight
AGar

With 11 alive it's 6 to lynch. Deadline is August 12 at 11:59pm EST.

[Nobody Special]

ITT Ythan can't count.

[Ythan]

I forgot it counts the OP.

[Ythill]

Vote: Ythill

for not knowing who he's playing with.

Heh. At least you know I'm not scum with Unsight/AGar. What's funny is that I saw you posting and still was stupid.

Anyway... did an iso scan of Reck's most recent games. Fate has been in a lot of them, ani in a few. Didn't see anyone else from this player list. NS is familliar with Reck from GD, but he'd probably kill me over Reck.

VOTE: animorpherv1

[Nobody Special]

NS is familliar with Reck from GD, but he'd probably kill me over Reck.

I am curious to hear your reasoning behind this.

[Ythill]

NS is prob-town.

@NS:

Think real hard. There's only one reasonable answer.

[Andrius]

Totally confused as to what you mean with the GD thing, unless its the Guys Pt. II thread that has a reputation.

[Ythill]

Yes, both are members of the Guys posse. As am I, FTR.

Mod:

Fix the bold tags in my last post please?

[Mafuyu]

Mafuyu absolutely would have NKed me if she was scum. NS and ani might have too. Who's afraid of Reck?

Yes. Exilon would agree if he was in this game desu. =/

To try and confuse Ythill a bit though, setup speculation next post, as Mafuyu is now off to work.

Vote NS

. Mafuyu forgets NS' reason.

[Ythill]

Why are you trying to confuse me? (It's already working.)

[nhammen]

And how am I player #9? I was totally the last one to /in in the Queue.

There are only 9 players. I'm assuming the others are on-deck replacements.

Mafuyu absolutely would have NKed me if she was scum. NS and ani might have too. Who's afraid of Reck?

A) C9++ is a 12 player set up.
B) I didn't think about thinking about who would have a reason to kill RECK. Except, now that I do think about it, nobody would. I've played in 4 games with him (I think), and while he was only slightly scummy, he was never much of a threat to the scum either. If I am remembering correctly anyways. The only game I have played with him in the past 6 months he was scum, so my memories of his Town play may be a bit off.
C) RECK's death also means we have at least 1 D. This means that there must be at least 3 scum. Also, only 1 kill last night means SK is slightly less likely (but they could just be holding it). Or maybe Doc RECK prevented a kill. Too soon to really tell.

NS is familliar with Reck from GD, but he'd probably kill me over Reck.

I am curious to hear your reasoning behind this.

Why? Do you have reason to believe his reasoning is wrong?
VOTE: Nobody Special

[AGar]

Flawless logic:

Lynch Ythill and when he flips scum, we get two confirmed townies. He only thought there were 9 players anyways.

VOTE: Ythill

[Andrius]

Flawless logic:

Lynch Ythill and when he flips scum, we get two confirmed townies. He only thought there were 9 players anyways.

VOTE: Ythill

Erm, the last time I saw a mis-count in the player numbers it was a town-player who thought the Mini Theme has 20 people. >_>

Ok. NK speculation is getting us nowhere because it seems (IDK I've never played with most of you/Reck) that its not getting us anywhere.

[Nobody Special]

NS is prob-town.

@NS:

Think real hard. There's only one reasonable answer.

Oh. Okay, then.

Mafuyu forgets NS' reason.

You don't love me anymore!

And how am I player #9? I was totally the last one to /in in the Queue.

There are only 9 players. I'm assuming the others are on-deck replacements.

Mafuyu absolutely would have NKed me if she was scum. NS and ani might have too. Who's afraid of Reck?

A) C9++ is a 12 player set up.
B) I didn't think about thinking about who would have a reason to kill RECK. Except, now that I do think about it,

nobody

would. I've played in 4 games with him (I think), and while he was only slightly scummy, he was never much of a threat to the scum either. If I am remembering correctly anyways. The only game I have played with him in the past 6 months he was scum, so my memories of his Town play may be a bit off.
C) RECK's death also means we have at least 1 D. This means that there must be at least 3 scum. Also, only 1 kill last night means SK is slightly less likely (but they could just be holding it). Or maybe Doc RECK prevented a kill. Too soon to really tell.

Since you've not played with me (that I recall--and certainly not 4 games), I assume the bolded 'nobody' means 'no one' and does not refer to me a a player. Correct me if otherwise.

NS is familliar with Reck from GD, but he'd probably kill me over Reck.

I am curious to hear your reasoning behind this.

Why? Do you have reason to believe his reasoning is wrong?

No, I was simply curious. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

[Mafuyu]

Why are you trying to confuse me? (It's already working.)

Mafuyu rarely gets to.

Mafuyu also lied about following up with a setup speculation post. On further reflection when Mafuyu should have been working, it's not a good idea to drop too much information, as C9++ seems to be designed so that for each time scum options get 'whittled' down, scum receive a disproportionate amount of retaliatory information. In other words, Mafuyu's initial, unspoken idea of "Everyone available, provide a reasonable guess as to the number of T's in-game, preferably not accurate to what role you might have" is really freaking stupid.

You don't love me anymore!

The ones you love always hurt you the most. NS has taught Mafuyu that, ne?

[Fate]

Pro-town NK analysis eh?

Unvote:
Vote: Mafuyu

Incorrect usage of -desu FTL.

Oh and that set-up speculation seems like "HEY IF DERS A SK COME OUT PL0X"

Did your kill get stopped by Reck last night Mafuyu?

[AGar]

Guys, Ythill is obv scum and even willing to hand us two confirmed townies. Let's lynch him now, makes everything that much easier.

[Nobody Special]

For the moment,

I'm okay with that.

[Ythill]

Or maybe Doc RECK prevented a kill.

Or GF/SK/RB did. I don't think setup speculation is very helpful at this point, but it's nice to know we're dealing with 3 mafia.

Flawless logic:

Lynch Ythill and when he flips scum, we get two confirmed townies.

By that logic, it would be three confirmed townies (I didn't include NS earlier because I was talking to him and figured he already knows his alignment). But your logic isn't flawless. If I'm scum, my mistake could have been faked. Also, I'm not scum.

Mafuyu's initial, unspoken idea of "Everyone available, provide a reasonable guess as to the number of T's in-game, preferably not accurate to what role you might have" is really freaking stupid.

QFT.

@Fate:

Mafuyu is prob-town.

[Fate]

^^^It worked AGAR!!!


Town:
Agar

Scum:
Nobody

Unvote:
Vote: Nobody Special

TRAP SPRUNG

[Fate]

Damn it Ythill. *arrows pointing to NS' #42*

[Fate]

Lynch Ythill and when he flips scum, we get two confirmed townies.

By that logic, it would be three confirmed townies (I didn't include NS earlier because I was talking to him and figured he already knows his alignment). But your logic isn't flawless. If I'm scum, my mistake could have been faked. Also, I'm not scum.[/quote]

I'll let AGAR answer for himself but I'm pretty sure if you think hard enough you can see what he was doing...


Vote Nobody pl0x

[Nobody Special]

Also, I'm not scum.

Convince me.

[AGar]

Flawless logic:

Lynch Ythill and when he flips scum, we get two confirmed townies.

By that logic, it would be three confirmed townies (I didn't include NS earlier because I was talking to him and figured he already knows his alignment). But your logic isn't flawless. If I'm scum, my mistake could have been faked. Also, I'm not scum.

Ok, listen. I get that you have this posse from Guys, Pt. 2, but I WILL NOT BE MADE A MOCKERY OF! MY LOGIC IS ALWAYS FLAWLESS. PERFECT! SAYING ANYTHING OTHERWISE IS MADNESS! MADNESS I TELL YOU!

And obviously you knew NS was in the game, so he would not be confirmed. You were only saying you didn't realize myself and Unsight were in the game. Obv if you flip scum, then NS does as well. Easy peasy one two threesy.

Fate. Get on Ythill wagon first. He's obviously the brains of the operation.

[Nobody Special]

TRAP SPRUNG

What.....?

Damn it Ythill. *arrows pointing to NS' #42*

Fate, darling, you're going to have to understand something about me: I DON'T GET CRYPTIC SHIT LIKE THIS. If you have something to say, SAY IT. In WORDS.